Other

John Garstang

fl. 1899–1953

Liverpool archaeologist whose Egyptian pottery from Beni Hasan went to the Cyprus Museum in 1904 in exchange for Cypriot vases, and who later found Cypriot pottery in Cilicia.

Biography

John Garstang (1876-1956), then Reader in Egyptian Archaeology at the University of Liverpool, was at the centre of an unusual exchange in 1904-5 that sent Egyptian pottery from his tombs at Beni Hasan to the Cyprus Museum1.

Pottery for Nicosia, vases for Liverpool

Garstang and E. Harold Jones cleared some 900 tombs at Beni Hasan in two seasons, from December 1902 to May 1903 and from late 1903 to March 1904, for a Committee of Patrons in England1. In The Times of 18 February 1904 Garstang offered sets of the pottery, "typical work of the XIth Dynasty", to museums in the United Kingdom and the Colonies1. Letters of 30 March and 22 June 1904 show Jones handling most of the correspondence with the museums and schools that applied1.

Merrillees traces the Cyprus donation to an agreement between the High Commissioner, Sir W. F. Haynes Smith, and Garstang, who wrote to him from Cairo on 1 May 1904 about the arrangements1. In the spring of 1904 the Cyprus Museum received two full cases from Beni Hasan1. George Jeffery called the contents "a number of very rough earthenware jars with no artistic character", which Garstang assigned to Dynasties XI-XII and XXII-XXV1. As far as Merrillees knows, the vases were never registered, drawn or photographed, their number is unrecorded, and they have not been seen again1.

The Cypriot side of the bargain met an administrative hitch in the colonial government1. Jeffery chose the so-called "duplicates" in the Cyprus Museum that could go to Liverpool1. On 15 May 1905 Garstang told the new High Commissioner, King-Harman, that he was sending two more cases of pottery, this time from Esna, and asked that the Cypriot pottery be sent to the Institute of Archaeology at Liverpool1. Two cases of Cypriot antiquities left for Liverpool in June 1905, and the Esna cases were due in Cyprus the following month; what became of them is unknown1. Jeffery's diary for 21 November 1905 records a visit to the museum "for purpose of inspecting pottery to be sent to Liverpool"1. Esna, unlike Beni Hasan, had yielded imported Cypriot vases1.

In Liverpool the Cypriot pottery was accessioned only in 1908, in a Catalogue of Cypriot Vases of which no trace has been found1. Merrillees presumes that most of the Cypriot vases without provenance in the present Garstang Museum of Archaeology came from the Cyprus Museum's donation1. Thomas Kiely writes that the Institute, which Garstang founded in 1904, received this pottery for its founding collection2.

Cypriot pottery in Cilicia

Garstang had studied mathematics at Oxford and turned to archaeology in 18973. In 1907 he became Rankin Professor of the Methods and Practice of Archaeology at Liverpool4. He was the first Director of the British School of Archaeology in Jerusalem from 1919, and in July 1920 was asked to organise the Department of Antiquities in Palestine; J. W. Crowfoot was appointed Director of the School from 19274.

In 1936 Garstang became director of the Neilson Expedition, which worked at Mersin in Cilicia3. Einar Gjerstad read in his reports that a considerable number of Cypriot pottery, imported and locally made, had been found there, consisting, as far as he could judge from the descriptions and illustrations, of White Painted and Bichrome III and IV and Black-on-Red I (III) and II (IV)5. Garstang dated Levels V and VI to the Late Bronze Age by fragments of Cypriot milk bowls with "wishbone handles" and bilbils6. Éric Jean judges that neither the few pieces recovered nor the unsecured stratigraphy of that excavation show an Early Iron Age occupation at Mersin7.

Britain founded an Institute of Archaeology at Ankara in 1948 with Garstang as director, and he became its President in 19493. His wife, Marie-Louise Bergès of Toulouse, died in 19493. Garstang, of Boars Hill near Oxford, died on 12 September 19568,9. Shimon Gibson says he died aboard a ship in the harbour of Beirut, two days after a cruise visit to Mersin as guest of honour4.

Life and work

  1. 1936

    1. excavator of Jericho, author of Liverpool Annals 1936 article in Claude Schaeffer's papers (Collège de France), 1 document.

      Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 242, «[Cahier de notes concernant Chypre, Gaza, Jéricho, l'Egypte, la Syrie (chronologies)]», undatedof 107

  2. 1948

    1. Excavated 2 objects (among them 'Sherd from a cream ware vessel with black concentric circles and black', inv. 1948.2138 B); now in the Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge.

      Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge collection online, inv. 1948.2138 B; 1948.2138 C

  3. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Said in the recorded talk «Cypro-Cilician connections in the Late Bronze Age» (Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, 2023-11-07): Excavated various sites in 1936 including Sirkeli Höyük; in 1938 concentrated on Yumuk Tepe.

      Ekin Kozal, «Cypro-Cilician connections in the Late Bronze Age», recorded lecture, 60th Public Lecture Series, Winter Semester 2023, Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, published on YouTube 2023-11-07, at 0:12:02

Connections

6 people

Recording and study

2 records
Employed by2

Mentioned in

14 mentions

Sources

  1. 1.Robert S. Merrillees (2020). “An Unwonted Exchange: Egyptian Antiquities from Beni Hasan and Esna (?) in the Cyprus Museum, Nicosia”. Dust Demons and Pots: Studies in Honour of Colin A. Hope (Orientalia Lovaniensia Analecta 289). Peeters.
  2. 2.Thomas Kiely. “Britain and the archaeology of Cyprus, II”.
  3. 3.André Parrot (1957). “Nécrologie: John Garstang (1876-1956)”. Syria 34, 400-404.
  4. 4.Shimon Gibson (1999). “British Archaeological Institutions in Mandatory Palestine, 1917-1948”. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 131.
  5. 5.Einar Gjerstad (1948). The Swedish Cyprus Expedition, Vol. IV Part 2: The Cypro-Geometric, Cypro-Archaic and Cypro-Classical Periods. Stockholm.
  6. 6.John Garstang (1939). “Explorations in Cilicia: The Neilson Expedition. Excavations at Mersin, Part IV: The Late and Middle Bronze Ages: Imperial-Hittite and Cilician-Hittite Periods”. Annals of Archaeology and Anthropology (Liverpool) 26.
  7. 7.Éric Jean (2003). “From Bronze to Iron Ages in Cilicia: The Pottery in its Stratigraphic Context”. Identifying Changes: The Transition from Bronze to Iron Ages in Anatolia and its Neighbouring Regions (Istanbul).
  8. 8.The London Gazette (1956). “[Deceased estates notices, Trustee Act 1925]”. The London Gazette 40959, 7365.
  9. 9.Society of Antiquaries of London (1957). “Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries [Anniversary 1957: obituary list of Fellows]”. The Antiquaries Journal 37, 267.
  10. 10.Elena D. Corbett (2014). Competitive Archaeology in Jordan: Narrating Identity from the Ottomans to the Hashemites. Austin, University of Texas Press. Online
  11. 11.Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology, Cambridge collection online.
  12. 12.Ekin Kozal, «Cypro-Cilician connections in the Late Bronze Age», recorded lecture, 60th Public Lecture Series, Winter Semester 2023, Archaeological Research Unit - University of Cyprus, published on YouTube 2023-11-07, at 0:12:02. Online
  13. 13.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 242, «[Cahier de notes concernant Chypre, Gaza, Jéricho, l'Egypte, la Syrie (chronologies)]», undatedof 107. Online
  14. 14.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 175, «["Enkomi C.F.F Schaeffer Plates IV-VII"]», 1947of 48, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 242, «[Cahier de notes concernant Chypre, Gaza, Jéricho, l'Egypte, la Syrie (chronologies)]», undatedof 107. Online
  15. 15.Elizabeth Brophy, Royal Statues in Egypt 300 BC-AD 220: Context and Function (2015).
  16. 16.Ashten R. Warfe; James C.R. Gill; Caleb R. Hamilton; Amy J. Pettman; David A. Stewart, Dust, Demons and Pots: Studies in Honour of Colin A. Hope (2020).
  17. 17.p. 582-583.
  18. 18.Godbey, Allen Howard, 1864-1948, Ancient oriental history new light on the Old Testament, some factors shaping ancient Palestine.
  19. 19.Evangelical Theological Society; J. Barton Payne, New perspectives on the Old Testament. (1970).
  20. 20.The Excavation of Tell Beit Mirsim. Vol. I: The Pottery of the First Three Campaigns (1930).
  21. 21.Josh McDowell and Sean McDowell, Mc Dowell Josh Mc Dowell Sean Evidence That Demands A Verdict (1999).
  22. 22.Aaron Greener, Late Bronze Age Imported Pottery in the Land of Israel: Between Economy, Society and Symbolism (2015).
  23. 23.Ashten R. Warfe; James C.R. Gill; Caleb R. Hamilton; Amy J. Pettman; David A. Stewart (eds), 2020, Dust, Demons and Pots: Studies in Honour of Colin A. Hope.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.