Collector · Agent · Cataloguer · Donor
John Holmes
1815–1894 · United Kingdom
Leeds businessman and collector who exhibited and helped sell T.B. Sandwith's Cypriot pottery in Yorkshire from 1870 and in 1882 sold his collection to Leeds as the start of a public museum.
Biography
John Holmes (1815-1894) was a Leeds businessman, art enthusiast and collector who placed the Cypriot pottery of T.B. Sandwith in exhibitions, arranged its sales and lectured on it1.
A Leeds draper
Holmes was born at Sheffield on 8 March 1815, the child of "humble but honourable parents"7. In 1825 the family, three daughters and one son, moved to Leeds, where he went to a poor school for three years and a better one for one year before being sent into the drapery business7. Apprenticed at 14, he took drawing lessons at the Mechanics' Institute outside his working hours1. In 1838 he succeeded to his father's business, and in 1839 he married Sarah Ann Dale; the marriage lasted forty-two years7.
As the business prospered he began to collect books, pictures, ancient carvings and prehistoric antiquities7. Reeve calls him an active social reformer and a key driver of the co-operative movement in Yorkshire1. In 1857 he read a paper on co-operation at the first meeting of the Social Science Association in Birmingham, and in 1864 he became treasurer of the Miners' National Conference and produced its Transactions7. He admired John Ruskin, with whom he met and corresponded, and chaired the School of Art Committee at the Leeds Mechanics' Institute1. G.J. Holyoake later wrote that "it was his merit to be an enthusiast for art, when few persons of the middle-class engaged in trade were so"1. Holmes retired from business in 18747.
Selling Sandwith's pottery
By his own account, written in 1885, Holmes first saw the Cypriot pottery in a shop window in High Street, Sheffield, "in the autumn of 1869"1. Reeve doubts that date: it comes before Henry Sandwith's letter in the Sheffield Daily Telegraph, and she says it may be an error1. In August 1870, with the help of Henry Sandwith, Holmes showed part of the collection for sale in the picture gallery of the Mechanics' Institute in Leeds, and the exhibition raised a considerable sum towards Sandwith's charitable aims1. Smith says the study of Cyprian pottery brought Holmes into connection with the Consul and with Dr Humphry Sandwith, an association he prized very highly7.
On 28 September 1870 Holmes read Sandwith's paper "On recent discoveries of Greco-Phoenician Pottery at Dali" to the Geological and Polytechnic Society of West Yorkshire, at a meeting chaired by William Aldam; his text does not survive1. In Leeds the sales appear to have been managed by Henry Denny, Holmes and Henry Sandwith, with each price settled case by case1.
In 1873 Holmes toured Italy, Greece, Egypt and Judea, adding to his collection7. Reeve says he took no direct part in archaeology in Cyprus but paid a brief visit to Larnaca on a Cook's Tour of the Near East in 18731. In May 1873 he bought a Middle Cypriot bronze axe at Dali (ancient Idalion), now LEEDM.D.1964.03831. In 1874 he lent Cypriot antiquities to an archaeological exhibition at the Royal Archaeological Institute's meeting at Ripon1.
The 1875 Exhibition
At the Yorkshire Exhibition of Arts and Manufactures in Leeds in 1875, the prospectus names Holmes and Fred. R. Spark as honorary secretaries of the Fine Art Department, under Dr Gott, Vicar of Leeds8. Holmes was responsible for the Antiquarian Section, using his own collection and loans that included Sandwith's Cypriot objects, and arranged for much of the collection to be shown for sale1,9. During the Duke of Edinburgh's tour he "especially directed the Duke's attention to... the remarkable collection of pottery from Cyprus"1. A Bichrome oenochoe he exhibited was bought by William Verity, and Ethel Stott gave it to Leeds Museum in 19571.
Holmes's catalogue section apologised that the cataloguing and placing of the collection was "very imperfect and inadequate"1. Reeve finds his descriptions too ambiguous to identify the objects, and says he divided them into three periods but lacked Sandwith's cautious, evidence-based approach1. She calls his approach "somewhat cavalier", a reflection of the emergent state of archaeological practice at the time1.
Lectures and the Leeds museum
Holmes's 1878 lecture on Cyprus drew 400 to 500 people, admitted free, with the Mayor of Leeds presiding1. He presented the Cypriot objects as evidence for the truth of Biblical history, and claimed that under Turkish rule Cyprus had fallen to "almost unparalleled degradation" but that English rule gave hopes of restoring it1. At the British Association meeting in York in 1881 he read a paper on the Cyprian pottery deposited by Consul Sandwith in the York museum, and the Yorkshire Philosophical Society made him an honorary member1.
In 1881, after money losses and the death of his wife, Holmes thought of leaving England and offered his collections to Leeds Corporation at half an expert's valuation, on condition that they became the nucleus of a public museum7. Reeve instead gives the negotiated price as half the collection's worth as assessed by Holmes himself1. The Council voted 35 to 13 to buy the collection, for which a price of £250 had been proposed1. Years of friction followed: Holmes objected to the delay and the unsuitable rooms, and in 1885 he refused the committee's demand that he arrange, catalogue and label the collection1. Holmes complained repeatedly in the press about slow progress, which Reeve says he did "rather disingenuously given his lack of co-operation"1. The Holmes Collection was shown at the opening exhibition of Leeds Art Gallery in October 18881. Holmes died in 1894, and obituaries appeared in the Barnsley Chronicle on 2 June and the Leeds Mercury on 4 June1.
Life and work
1869
September
Autumn 1869: first sees T.B. Sandwith's Cypriot pottery in a Sheffield High Street shop window; begins to study 'Cyprian pottery'.
1870
August
With Henry Sandwith, shows part of the Sandwith collection for sale at the Mechanics' Institute Picture Gallery, Leeds; raises money for Sandwith's famine relief; leads to acquaintance with Humphry Sandwith.28 September
Reads T.B. Sandwith's paper 'On recent discoveries of Greco-Phoenician Pottery at Dali' to the Yorkshire Geological and Polytechnic Society.
1873
May
On a Cook's tour of the Near East buys a Middle Cypriot bronze axe at Dali (LEEDM.D.1964.0383) and visits a graveyard near Larnaca with a guide.- Publishes A Sketch of the History of Leeds from Pre-historic Times to 1872 AD.
1875
- Fine Art Department, Yorkshire Exhibition: displays the Sandwith Cypriot collection and writes its catalogue section (three chronological periods; apologises for lack of typology); Leeds Mercury description probably his.
1880
- Described as owning at Holmstead, Roundhay, near Leeds, an extensive collection of prehistoric and artistic treasures, including a collection of ware from Cyprus, formed over about forty years.
Roundhay, Leeds(1880). The Antiquary. The Antiquary, vol. 4
1881
- Reads 'On the Collection of Cyprian Pottery, &c., deposited by Consul Sandwith, C.B., in the Museum, York' at the BAAS meeting, York; elected honorary member of the Yorkshire Philosophical Society.
19 September
About thirty members of the Bradford Historical and Antiquarian Society visited his house at Holmstead, Roundhay, to inspect his collection.Roundhay, Leeds(1880). The Antiquary. The Antiquary, vol. 4
1882
January
After the loss of his wife and financial losses, and planning to emigrate to New Zealand, offers his collection to Leeds Corporation at half its expert valuation (GBP 250) as the nucleus of a public museum; the council votes 35 to 13 to buy; years of friction follow over display.LeedsAnna Holly Reeve (2021). Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947. PhD thesis, University of Leeds; W. Smith (ed.) (1882). A Yorkshire Antiquary [John Holmes]. Old Yorkshire, 57-59. Longmans, Green & Co., p. 59
Through their hands
10 recordsCame from
- 1873Purchase
PurchaseJohn Holmes purchased a bronze axe at Dali; the page does not name the seller.
No. LEEDM.D.1964.0383Dali (ancient Idalion), CyprusReeve 2021, p. 105
- 1881Sale
SaleHolmes offered to sell his collection to the Leeds Town Council for a public museum.
Sold to Leeds Town Councilcollection, including ancient Cypriot objects£250Reeve 2021, p. 145
- n.d.Partnership
PartnershipJohn Holmes and Henry Sandwith were among those involved in managing sales of Sandwith’s objects in Leeds.
Worked with Henry SandwithSandwith’s Cypriot antiquitiesReeve 2021, p. 91
- n.d.Partnership
PartnershipJohn Holmes and Henry Denny were among those involved in managing sales of Sandwith’s objects in Leeds.
Worked with Henry DennySandwith’s Cypriot antiquitiesReeve 2021, p. 91
- n.d.Agency
AgencyprobablyHolmes played a role arranging the purchase of Cypriot pottery, and the Special Fund payment was routed through him.
Agent for Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society£14Reeve 2021, p. 122
- n.d.Sale
SaleLeeds voted to purchase Holmes’ collection for a public museum.
Sold to Leeds Free Public MuseumHolmes’ collection, including ancient Cypriot antiquities£250Reeve 2021, p. 148Reeve 2021, p. 101
- n.d.Note
NoteHolmes arranged an offer of further ancient Cypriot objects from Sandwith’s collection to the committee, which turned it down.
Connected with Leeds Free Public Library CommitteeReeve 2021, p. 153
- n.d.Collection
CollectionJohn Holmes formed a small antiquarian collection, mostly from objects obtained second-hand from Sandwith.
antiquities, including Cypriot objectsLeedsReeve 2021, p. 82
- n.d.Acquisition
AcquisitionHolmes said he obtained a lamp at Larnaca.
lamp with Christian imageryReeve 2021, p. 106
- n.d.Collection
CollectionJohn Holmes' collection included a triple juglet transferred from Leeds Art Gallery.
No. LEEDM.D.1964.0305Reeve 2021, p. 288
Connections
12 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Borrowed from Thomas Backhouse SandwithLeeds 1875 exhibition; Holmes later wrote on the Sandwith collection in York Museum; Yorkshire Exhibition of Arts and Manufactures, Leeds 1875 A. H. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, pp. 87; Reeve 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds (PhD, Leeds), pp. 931875–1881
- Sold to William Henry VerityBichrome oenochoe LEEDM.D.1964.0371 at the 1875 exhibition Anna Holly Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, fig. 2.3 caption1875
- Sold to Mr Beckworth (Leeds)Holmes collection for the Leeds Free Public Museum; Holmes collection for Leeds Free Public Museum Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, pp. 146-148; Reeve 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds (PhD, Leeds), p. 1461882
Fieldwork & employment
- Guided Alfred, Duke of Saxe-Coburg and GothaJohn Holmes directed the Duke of Edinburgh’s attention to the Cypriot pottery collection at the Exhibition. Reeve 2021, p. 941875
Scholarship
- Published material of Thomas Backhouse SandwithJohn Holmes wrote the exhibition catalogue section describing the display of Sandwith’s Cypriot pottery. Reeve & Waite 20201870–1881
- Material published by Anna Holly ReeveHolmes's collection in Leeds Free Public Museum A. H. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: objects, networks and museums from 1870 to 19472021
Colleagues & contacts
- Worked with Henry DennyJohn Holmes and Henry Denny were among those involved in managing sales of Sandwith’s objects in Leeds. Reeve 2021, p. 911803–1871
- Connected with Thomas Backhouse Sandwithpaper 'On recent discoveries of Greco-Phoenician Pottery at Dali' Anna Holly Reeve, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947 (2021), p. 1181831–1900
- Worked with Henry SandwithJohn Holmes and Henry Sandwith were among those involved in managing sales of Sandwith’s objects in Leeds. Reeve 2021, p. 911870–1875
- Met Humphry SandwithHolmes viewed the reserved Sandwith specimens at Wimbledon; viewing of reserved Sandwith specimens at Wimbledon A. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, p. 88-89; Reeve 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds (PhD, Leeds), p. 881870
- Worked with Humphry SandwithCypriot specimens Anna Holly Reeve, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947 (2021), p. 881870
- Worked with Joshua Ingham IkinYorkshire Exhibition of Arts and Manufactures, 1875 Anna Holly Reeve, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947 (2021), p. 1221870–1876
- Worked with William AldamprobablyReeve judges it likely that Holmes solicited the donation Reeve, M., 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 19471870
- Worked with John GottFine Art Department, Yorkshire Exhibition 1875; Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society; Fine Art Department, 1875 Exhibition Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947; Reeve 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds (PhD, Leeds), p. 931875–1881
- Connected with Walter HardingLeeds Art Gallery display of the Holmes collection; Holmes collection of antiquities A. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, pp. 154-157; Anna Holly Reeve, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947 (2021), p. 1571888–1889
Recording and study
3 records- Catalogued1
1875Holmes’s catalogue described ancient Cypriot pottery, including vessels and Black on Red ware.
Yorkshire ExhibitionReeve 2021, p. 124
- Curated1
1875John Holmes arranged for a substantial part of Sandwith’s collection to be displayed for sale at the exhibition.
Sandwith’s ancient Cypriot collectionLeedsReeve & Waite 2020
- Other work1
John Holmes lectured and wrote for local audiences about ancient Cypriot antiquities.
LeedsReeve 2021, p. 83
Objects
Bronze axe, Middle Cypriot, bought at Dali May 1873, shown 1875 and probably 1881, sold 1882
From Dali (Idalion)Leeds Museums and Galleries LEEDM.D.1964.0383May 1873
Triple juglet, Tell el-Yahudiyeh ware, exported by T.B. Sandwith, bought by Holmes, sold to Leeds Free Public Museum
Leeds Museums and Galleries LEEDM.D.1964.0305
Bichrome spouted jug, label of the 1875 Yorkshire Exhibition, exhibited by Holmes
Leeds Museums and Galleries LEEDM.D.1964.03461875
Bichrome oenochoe exhibited by Holmes in 1875 and bought there by William Verity
Leeds Museums and Galleries LEEDM.D.1964.03711875
Bichrome footed kylix, possibly the Sandwith piece left with Humphry Sandwith, probably deposited at Leeds Art Gallery as part of the Holmes Collection
Leeds Museums and Galleries LEEDM.D.1988.0005
Mentioned in
25 mentionsDocuments · 4
- Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947
Purchase, sale, partnership · 1873 · p. 105; p. 94; p. 124; p. 145; p. 91; p. 122; 148, 101; p. 153; p. 82; p. 83; p. 106; p…
John Holmes purchased a bronze axe at Dali; the page does not name the seller.
Reeve 2021
- Re-collecting Cypriot antiquity: The Kent collection in Harrogate
Published · 1875
John Holmes wrote the exhibition catalogue section describing the display of Sandwith’s Cypriot pottery.
Reeve & Waite 2020
- A Yorkshire Antiquary [John Holmes]
Smith 1882
- A Yorkshire Antiquary: John Holmes (1815-1894)
Holmes 1992
Institutions · 9
- Leeds Museums and Galleries
Seller (1881–1882), object from them · 1870
Aldam gave 5 pounds towards buying Greek pottery from Cyprus for the Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society museum after Holmes read Sandwith's paper on…
Reeve 2021; Reeve 2021, fig. 2.5 caption; Reeve 2021, fig. 2.4a caption
- Leeds Philosophical and Literary Society
Member, object from them · 1870
William Aldam gave £5 towards purchase of Greek pottery from Cyprus; a Bichrome amphora (LEEDM.D.1964.0350) from T. B. Sandwith's collection was recorded in…
Reeve 2021, pp. 87-88; Reeve 2021, pp. 117-120; Reeve 2021, pp. 88-89
- Royal Archaeological Institute
Lender (1874) · 1874
At the RAI's Ripon meeting John Holmes lent Cypriot objects for exhibition; Fairless Barber was a principal organiser.
Reeve 2021, p. 99
- Halifax Literary and Philosophical Society
1875
After the 1875 Yorkshire Exhibition, John Holmes arranged loans of Sandwith's collection to museums in York, Sheffield and Halifax (Reeve says Halifax, not…
Reeve 2021
- Leeds Mechanics' Institute
Member · 1875
Picture Gallery fundraiser for a permanent public art collection (1870s); Holmes lectured and chaired its School of Art Committee
Reeve 2021
- Leeds City Council
Sold · 1881
Reeve 2021, p. 145
- People · 12listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Anna Holly Reeve (2021). “Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947”. PhD thesis, University of Leeds.
- 2.W. Smith (ed.) (1882). “A Yorkshire Antiquary [John Holmes]”. Old Yorkshire, 57-59. Longmans, Green & Co..
- 3.John Holmes (1873). A Sketch of the History of Leeds from Pre-historic Times to 1872 AD. Leeds, McCorquodale and Co..
- 4.John Holmes (1881). “On the Collection of Cyprian Pottery, &c., deposited by Consul Sandwith, C.B., in the Museum, York”. British Association for the Advancement of Science, York meeting (Anthropology section).
- 5.G. M. Holmes (1992). “A Yorkshire Antiquary: John Holmes (1815-1894)”. Sheffield Art Review, 15-21.
- 6. (1880). “The Antiquary”. The Antiquary, vol. 4.
- 7.W. Smith (ed.) (1882). “Fairless Barber”. Old Yorkshire.
- 8.Yorkshire Exhibition of Arts and Manufactures (1875). Prospectus of the Yorkshire Exhibition of Arts & Manufactures at Leeds.
- 9.A. Reeve, S. Waite (2020). “Re-collecting Cypriot antiquity: The Kent collection in Harrogate”. Journal of the History of Collections. Online
- 10.A. H. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: objects, networks and museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 11.Anna Holly Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 12.Anna Holly Reeve, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947 (2021).
- 13.A. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 14.Reeve 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds (PhD, Leeds).
- 15.Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 16.A. Reeve et al., 2020, Re-collecting Cypriot antiquity: The Kent collection in Harrogate.
- 17.Anna Holly Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947, p. 119; Anna Holly Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 18.A. H. Reeve, 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
- 19.Reeve, M., 2021, Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947.
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.