Chapter · 2007
Times change: the current state of the debate in Old World chronology
M. H. Wiener; edited by M. Bietak and E. Czerny
In The Synchronisation of Civilisations in the Eastern Mediterranean in the Second Millennium B.C. III, 25-47. Vienna: Austrian Academy of Sciences
A chapter on the debate over Old World chronology, weighing Egyptian astronomical dates, ice cores, tree rings and radiocarbon for the Theran eruption against Cypriote pottery and pumice finds.
Wiener surveys the scientific and archaeological methods used to date the Theran eruption and the Aegean Bronze Age. He begins with Egyptian astronomical dates, turns to ice-core dating, dendrochronology and radiocarbon dating, and ends with archaeological evidence tied to Egyptian chronology and a summation.
He argues that chronological claims depend on the quality and interpretation of measurements as well as on archaeological context, and examines sources of error in radiocarbon dating: calibration, regional variation, sample treatment and old-carbon contamination. In his conclusion the ice-core and tree-ring arguments for an early eruption have lost support, while radiocarbon alone cannot decide between the Aegean Long and Short Chronologies. The ranges he reports may support an eruption between 1550 and 1525 BCE or an earlier one, and oscillations in the calibration curve prevent a clear choice (pp. 29–39).
Cypriote pottery enters the argument through the White Slip I bowl in the Volcanic Destruction Level at Thera, studied by Merrillees, and through the White Slip contexts at Enkomi studied by Crewe. Wiener also compares White Slip and other pottery sequences, and pumice finds at Tell el-Dab'a and Tell el-'Ajjul, with Egyptian archaeological contexts. The archaeological evidence, as he presents it, challenges a seventeenth- or early sixteenth-century BCE date for the eruption (pp. 39–40).
What it records
- R. Krauss places the seventh year of Senwosret III in 1831–30 BCE on the basis of lunar dates.p. 26
- Wiener reports that the Anatolian floating tree-ring chronology is fixed, in all likelihood, to within +8/−10 years.p. 28
- Most Theran radiocarbon determinations fall within the oscillating portion of the calibration curve and are consistent with an eruption date between 1550 and 1525 BCE, Wiener states.p. 37
- The VERA Laboratory's analysis of 25 selected Akrotiri samples produced two calibrated ranges, 1640–1600 BCE and 1570–1530 BCE.p. 38
- The Theran Volcanic Destruction Level contained a Cypriote White Slip I bowl that, Wiener says, showed evidence of use and ancient repair.p. 39
- Forty-eight samples of Theran pumice were collected from various strata at Tell el-'Ajjul.p. 40
Where to read
- Egyptian astronomical chronologypp. 25–27
- Radiocarbon dating and the Theran eruptionpp. 29–39
- Cypriote pottery and pumice evidencepp. 39–40
Contents
- Egyptian Astronomy, Texts and Interconnections25
- Ice-Core Dating27
- Dendrochronology28
- Radiocarbon Dating29
- Archaeological Evidence Based on Egyptian Chronology39
- Summation40
- Acknowledgements41
- Bibliography41
Objects published here
1- Cypriote White Slip I bowl from the Volcanic Destruction Level at Thera, Volcanic Destruction Level at Thera (p. 39)
People, places and institutions
People
- R. KraussEgyptian lunar chronology
- K. KitchenEgyptian chronology
- R.A. Wellsinterprets Egyptian lunar observations
- S. ManningAegean chronology and tree-ring dating
- Nicholas J.G. Pearceanalysed Greenland tephra
- Merrilleesstudied the Theran White Slip bowl
- L. Crewestudied Enkomi White Slip contexts
Institutions
- VERA Laboratoryradiocarbon laboratory that analysed Akrotiri samples
Places
- Theraeruption and chronology under discussion
- Akrotirisource of radiocarbon samples and archaeological evidence
- Tell el-Dab'apottery and pumice contexts
- Tell el-'AjjulCypriote pottery and pumice contexts
- EnkomiCypriote exchange and White Slip sequence
- Porsuksource of Anatolian tree-ring samples
- Gordionsource of an Anatolian tree-ring sequence
Also named: University of Vienna, Toumba tou Skourou, Ayia Irini.
Extent pp. 25–47, fig. 1
Late Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeChronology and DatingPotteryLandscape and Climate
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- What Pots Were ForArticle
Who did what
1 recordRecording and study 1
- p. 39
Lindy CreweStudied
Crewe examined surviving records of the Enkomi excavations and agreed that securely identified White Slip I contexts were probably late LC IB.
limited surviving records of the Enkomi excavations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.