Edited volume · 2002
Marsa Matruh II: The objects
Donald White (ed.)
Philadelphia: INSTAP Academic Press
A volume of nine chapters and two appendices on the finds from Bates's Island, Marsa Matruh, from Aegean and Cypriot imports to botanical, faunal and later-period material.
Finds from the University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology's excavations on Bates's Island, Marsa Matruh, are set out here beside Cypriot White Slip sherds that Oric Bates collected during his stay in 1913/14 and that Harvard University's Peabody Museum later held. Chapters catalogue the pottery, tools and other finds, analyse plant and animal remains, and draw together the island's Late Bronze Age evidence and its later activity.
How it is organised
Chapters 7 to 15 run from Russell's study of Aegean and selected Cypriot pottery to a final summary divided between Hulin and White. Two appendices follow, a MASCA analysis and a Late Bronze Age sherd context list, and plans, plates and an index complete the volume. The Late Bronze Age is the main period, and the chapters on later material cover Greek, Roman and Ottoman-era finds.
The papers
Russell classifies and catalogues the Aegean and Cypriot imports, including the Bates collection at the Peabody Museum, and considers chronology and trade. Hulin catalogues Egyptian, Canaanite and Cypriot plain pottery, with lamps, stoppers, pot marks and pottery groups, and summarises their chronological distribution (pp. 1–45).
White's chapter on Late Bronze Age implements records evidence for metalworking, tools, stone objects, beads and ostrich eggshells, with the crucible fragments and the proposed exchange of ostrich eggshell among the topics (pp. 47–72).
Reese and Rose present mammal, fish, bird, marine-invertebrate, freshwater-shell and land-snail evidence in tables organised by context and period (pp. 73–107).
El-Hadidi describes the modern vegetation, wood anatomy and plant remains from soil samples, and assesses the limits of pollen evidence (pp. 109–116).
Bailey catalogues Greek and Roman pottery from Area I on Bates's Island and Area V on the mainland, covering fine and coarse wares, transport amphorae and lamps. White follows with later metal, stone, glass, faience, terracotta and plaster finds and the architectural stone from Area V, and Thorn arranges the Ottoman-era pottery from the upper levels into painted, tin-glazed, sgraffito, marbled, slipped and solid-glazed groups (pp. 117–168).
The final summary gives Hulin's discussion of the Late Bronze Age and of chronological questions, and White's historical postscript on the post-Bronze Age island (pp. 169–179).
The MASCA analysis of the crucibles and the lump of ore is the joint work of White, Fleming, Killick, Pigott and Swann, and the sherd context list ties catalogue numbers to excavation contexts (pp. 187–194).
The catalogue
Entries carry chapter-and-entry numbers, such as 7.1, 12.1–12.155 and 13.18, and the appendix context list cross-references catalogue numbers by excavation context. Each entry gives a description, fabric or material, findspot or excavation context and inventory number, with a date or chronology and a figure or plate where supplied. Inventory numbers follow patterns such as 85I-P-…, 87I-P-…, 87I-M-… and 89I-P-…. The entries draw on the Pennsylvania excavations and on the Bates collection at the Peabody Museum (pp. 1–168).
Limits of the evidence
White notes that contributors had limited opportunities to study material first-hand. The Egyptian Antiquities Organization stored the finds and regulated their export, and its restrictions on sending finds abroad for analysis affected the research that had been planned.
What it records
- A White Slip I bowl fragment found by Oric Bates is held in Harvard's Peabody Museum.p. 3
- Russell says White Shaved Ware is most common from LC IB to LC IIB.p. 4
- Cypriot coarse wares make up 81% of the pottery from the upper levels and 78% from the lower levels between walls S118 and S121.p. 28
- Hulin argues that the island's Aegean and Cypriot pottery, including White Shaved Ware, resembles that of Canaan more than that of Egypt.p. 173
- The Aegean pottery from Bates's Island is predominantly Late Helladic IIIA, in Russell's identification.p. 1
- Egyptian pottery makes up roughly 17% of the pottery from Bates's Island, by Hulin's estimate.p. 20
- White reports 19 crucible fragments from a range of island occupation deposits.p. 50
- Sixty ostrich eggshell fragments come from island contexts, in White's count.p. 60
- White considers it likely that islanders obtained empty ostrich eggshells from Libyans for export and resale.p. 61
- Reese and Rose report 361 fish bones and fragments from 47 excavation deposits.p. 88
- El-Hadidi investigated 48 soil samples, each weighing 1–2 kg, for archaeobotanical remains.p. 111
- El-Hadidi identified 260 specimens belonging to ten species across samples from all periods.p. 114
- Bailey dates the imported SOS amphora 12.36 to about 730–700 BC.p. 127
- Bailey's Area V pottery catalogue covers four locations on the mainland immediately north of Bates's Island.p. 137
- Thorn associates the pottery from Bates's Island with a 17th-century occupation of the Sponge-Divers House.p. 164
- Hulin concludes that Late Bronze Age activity on the island lasted at least 50 years, with short-term occupation possibly extending to 150 years.p. 169
Where to read
- Aegean and Cypriot pottery chronology and ware classificationspp. 1–5
- Peabody Museum sherds collected by Batespp. 14–15
- Egyptian and Cypriot coarse pottery distributions and fabricspp. 20–38
- Metalworking evidence, crucibles and fuelpp. 47–53
- Ostrich eggshell fragments and proposed exchange rolepp. 60–62
- Faunal remains by period and excavation depositpp. 73–107
- Late Bronze Age trade interpretation and White Shaved Warepp. 169–178
- MASCA analyses of crucibles and iron orepp. 187–190
Contents
- Aegean Pottery and Selected Cypriot PotteryPamela Russell1
- Bronze Age Plain Pottery: Egyptian, Canaanite, and CypriotLinda Hulin17
- Late Bronze Age Implements and Other Miscellaneous ObjectsDonald White47
- Organic Remains from the Island and Adjacent AreasDavid S. Reese, Mark J. Rose73
- The Archaeobotany of Bates's Island and its LagoonMohamad Nabil el-Hadidi109
- Pottery of the Greek and Roman PeriodsDonald Bailey117
- Post-Bronze Age ArtifactsDonald White153
- Ottoman Era Local and Imported PotteryJames Thorn163
- A Final Summary of the EvidenceLinda Hulin, Donald White169
- MASCA Analysis of Crucibles and Lump of OreDonald White, Stuart J. Fleming, David Killick, Vincent C. Pigott, Charles P. Swann187
- Late Bronze Age Sherds Context List191
Objects published here
7- White Slip I bowl sherd collected by Bates, Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnology, Harvard University, Bates's Island, 46-4-40/5917 (4), 7.80 (p. 14)
- White Shaved Ware juglet, upper body and mouth, F4-III, 3.1, 85I-P-104, 7.69 (p. 13)
- Miniature bowl, E4-III, 2.1, 85I-P-8, 7.1, Fig. 7:1 (p. 6)
- Largest ostrich eggshell fragment recovered, E4-III, 2.3 (S102), 85I-M0-3, 9.95 (p. 63)
- Ionian cup, perhaps Rhodian, I6-I/II, 2.5, 89I-P-6, 12.1 (p. 119)
- Phocaean Red Slip Ware bowl, H5-II, 1.1, 87I-P-56, 12.57, Fig. 12:6; Pl. 12 (p. 130)
- Copper drachm of Trajan, E4-II/E, 3.1, 87I-C-1, 13.18 (p. 155)
People, places and institutions
People
- Oric Batescollected sherds on the island in 1913/14
- Halford Haskellcommented on stirrup jars
- Merrilleescompared Cypriot pottery found in Egypt
- N. Hirschfeldstudied pot marks
- P.S. Keswaniclassified Cypriot pithoi
- Caton-Thompsonreported lithics and eggshell finds
- Herodotusreported Libyan and Egyptian customs
- Alexandervisited Matruh on his Siwa excursion
- Cleopatralinked in later accounts with Paraitonion
- Antonylinked with Paraitonion before Actium
- Akhenatenpharaoh in the Late Bronze Age discussion
- Ramesses IIpharaoh linked to frontier fortresses
- Merenptahpharaoh in the Late Bronze Age discussion
Institutions
- University of Pennsylvania Museum of Archaeology and Anthropologyexcavated Bates's Island
- Egyptian Antiquities Organizationstored finds and regulated their export
- Peabody Museum of Archaeology and Ethnologyholds sherds collected by Bates
- Museum Applied Science Center for Archaeology (MASCA)analysed crucibles and an ore sample
Places
- Bates's Islandisland excavated at Marsa Matruh
- Marsa Matruhcoastal setting of the excavation
- Zawiyet Umm el-Rakhamnearby fortress site
- Rhodescomparison for Aegean trade
- Ialysoscemetery evidence for trade
- el-Amarnaceramic and eggshell comparisons
- Ugaritcomparison for Cypriot coarse pottery
- Kommoscomparative pottery and artefact site
- Cape Gelidonyashipwreck comparison
- Uluburunshipwreck comparison
- Haua Fteahregional lithic and eggshell comparison
- GhirzaRoman-period ostrich evidence
- Bates's Dumparea of earlier excavation spoil
- Sponge-Divers House (S101)excavated building with later occupation
- East Lagoonlagoon beside Bates's Island
- Area Vmainland pottery and architectural area
Also named: Lucian, Enkomi.
Extent 20 plates, 4 plans; index (pp. 197–206)
Defines Parallel Line Style, Monochrome A, halophytic vegetation, xeric vegetation
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricCypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalHellenisticRomanMedievalModernPotteryTradeCraft ProductionFood and FarmingChronology and Dating
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- White Shaved WareCompendium
Who did what
7 recordsBuying, selling and giving 1
Oric BatesPassed objects toHarvard University’s Peabody Museum
Oric Bates shipped the Cypriot White Slip finds to Harvard University’s Peabody Museum before his death.
Cypriot White Slip sherds found at Matruh
Excavation 2
- p. 171
Oric BatesFound
Oric Bates discovered sherds of Cypriot White Slip II milk bowls on Bates's Island.
- 1913
Oric BatesFound
Oric Bates found a small collection of sherds during his winter stay at Matruh.
Recording and study 4
- p. 1
Pamela RussellStudied
Pamela Russell discussed the significance of Aegean and Cypriot pottery recovered from Bates's Island.
Aegean and some of the Cypriot potteryBates's Island at Marsa Matruh
- p. 17
Linda HulinCatalogued
Linda Hulin catalogued Egyptian, Canaanite, and Cypriot Bronze Age plain pottery.
Bronze Age plain pottery from Bates's IslandBates's Island
- p. 19
Nicolle E. HirschfeldStudied
N. Hirschfeld briefly studied the pot marks from Marsa Matruh for her unpublished Ph.D. thesis.
- p. 54
Donald WhiteCatalogued
Donald White catalogued Late Bronze Age stone and other miscellaneous artifacts from the island.
Late Bronze Age stone and miscellaneous artifactsNo. 9.51–9.85Bates's Island
People it is cited for
1 person- Oric Bates4 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.