Edited volume · 2010
Political Economies of the Aegean Bronze Age: Papers from the Langford Conference, Florida State University, Tallahassee, 22–24 February 2007
Daniel J. Pullen (ed.)
Oxford and Oakville: Oxbow Books
A collection of twelve papers on political economies in Minoan and Mycenaean societies and their predecessors, from the 2007 Langford Conference at Florida State University.
Revised papers from the 2007 Langford Conference at Florida State University, with a response by James C. Wright, compare political economies in Minoan and Mycenaean societies and in their predecessors. The papers address production, distribution and consumption, exchange, craft specialization, ritual, and the roles of local and non-elite groups. They draw on archaeological, architectural, ceramic, mortuary and Linear B evidence from Crete and the Greek mainland, and they consider variation between regions and periods.
How it is organised
Pullen's introduction, Goals of the Volume and Political Economies of the Aegean Bronze Age, frames the comparative questions and discusses differences among Aegean polities. William A. Parkinson's Beyond the Peer: Social Interaction and Political Evolution in the Bronze Age Aegean examines interaction at macro-regional, regional and local scales, including imported objects and obsidian. Jan Driessen's Spirit of Place. Minoan Houses as Major Actors considers the House as a social and economic unit grounded in architecture, property, ritual and memory, and Ilse Schoep's Making Elites: Political Economy and Elite Culture(s) in Middle Minoan Crete examines production and consumption, with Quartier Mu at Malia as a principal case.
Sofia Voutsaki's From the Kinship Economy to the Palatial Economy: The Argolid in the Second Millennium BC traces changes in the Argolid from mortuary, settlement and workshop evidence. Joanne M. A. Murphy's Political Economies in Ritual: A Comparative Study of the Rise of the State in Pre- and Protopalatial Knossos and Phaistos compares ritual evidence at the two sites. Dimitri Nakassis's Reevaluating Staple and Wealth Finance at Mycenaean Pylos assesses finance through Linear B evidence for staples, valuables, payments and feasting, and Cheryl A. Ward's Seafaring in the Bronze Age Aegean: Evidence and Speculation reviews archaeological and textual evidence for ships, maritime exchange and possible routes.
Thomas F. Tartaron's Between and Beyond: Political Economy in Non-Palatial Mycenaean Worlds examines political relationships across Corinthian sub-regions and presents evidence from the Saronic Harbors Archaeological Research Project at Kalamianos. Kim Shelton's Citadel and Settlement: A Developing Economy at Mycenae, the Case of Petsas House uses the building's pottery, storage and architectural evidence to discuss production and administration. Peter M. Day, Maria Relaki and Simona Todaro's Living From Pots? Ceramic Perspectives on the Economies of Prepalatial Crete considers ceramic production, exchange and consumption through examples from Knossos, Myrtos Fournou Korifi and Phaistos, and Michael L. Galaty's Wedging Clay: Combining Competing Models of Mycenaean Pottery Industries compares ceramic production and use in Messenia, Mycenae-Berbati and Crete, including staple and wealth wares. Wright's Political Economies in the Aegean Bronze Age: A Response closes the volume.
The papers
Parkinson works from a Late Bronze Age dataset of imported objects, counted separately for Crete and the mainland, and from the circulation of obsidian in Messenia. Driessen takes the House concept from Levi-Strauss and discusses it with Joyce's house-society model and Gillespie's definition of corporate Houses. He applies it to settlement architecture, including the town blocks at Palaikastro interpreted as Houses, and sets out how such groups held estates, heirlooms and valuables over generations (pp. 11–65).
For Crete, Schoep treats Quartier Mu at Malia, excavated and published by Poursat, as a principal case of elite production and consumption, and argues from it for polities of different sizes in Middle Minoan Crete. Murphy finds the clearest ritual evidence of Knossos and Phaistos in large deposits around the palace west courts. Day, Relaki and Todaro follow Prepalatial pottery from production through exchange to consumption, with Aghia Triada among their examples of storage and consumption.
On the mainland, Voutsaki sets a kinship economy of exchange among households and kin groups in the early Middle Helladic Argolid, known from Lerna and Asine, against the palatial economy that followed. Nakassis uses the Pylos tablets to argue that staple distribution often ran through public feasts, and that finance there fits a prestige economy better than the models of staple finance and wealth finance he reviews (pp. 127–148). Tartaron reports the cyclopean foundations of Kalamianos, part of them under water, and Shelton the large well and storeroom deposits of Petsas House at Mycenae. Galaty weighs the competing models of Mycenaean pottery industries against the Messenian sherds, among them the kylikes.
Ward finds only three Bronze Age shipwrecks located and excavated, one of them at Point Iria in the Aegean proper. Wright's response discusses the papers through small worlds, microstates, local political organization and the relationship between centres and communities, and discusses the Iron Age polities of Cyprus in comparison with the Aegean (pp. 248–266).
What it records
- Parkinson's Late Bronze Age dataset counts 407 imported items and 284 contacts for Crete, and 351 items and 196 contacts for the mainland.p. 18
- Romanou was the main site of obsidian blade production identified by the Pylos Regional Archaeological Project in Messenia, Parkinson reports.p. 27
- Driessen proposes that Minoan social groups organized as Houses invested across generations in architectural estates, heirlooms and valuables.p. 57
- Schoep argues for larger and smaller polities in Middle Minoan Crete, in place of a small set of large peer polities.p. 80
- Voutsaki argues that exchange among households and kin groups was a principal organizing feature of the early Middle Helladic Argolid.p. 92
- Large-scale deposits around the palace west courts are the clearest evidence for ritual at Knossos and Phaistos in the periods discussed, in Murphy's reading.p. 123
- Pylos's territory extended across approximately 2,000 km², Nakassis estimates.p. 130
- Nakassis concludes that staples at Pylos were often distributed through public feasts and that finance there is better described as a prestige economy.p. 139
- Three Bronze Age shipwrecks had been located and excavated, with only Point Iria in the Aegean proper, Ward records.p. 155
- Kalamianos has cyclopean architectural foundations spread across about 10 hectares, with some of the site submerged, Tartaron reports.p. 177
- The well deposit of Petsas House contained more than 300 whole vases and over 500 restorable vases, Shelton reports.p. 191
- Storeroom Alpha at Petsas House contained approximately 500 vases, over 90 per cent decorated fine ware, Shelton reports.p. 191
- About half of the ceramic assemblage at Myrtos Fournou Korifi was imported from the northern side of the Isthmus of Ierapetra, Day, Relaki and Todaro report.p. 213
- 114 of the 310 sampled Messenian sherds were definitely from kylikes, Galaty reports.p. 231
- The Langford Conference papers were revised for publication after the conference held at Florida State University in February 2007.
Where to read
- Models of interaction and the imported-object datasetpp. 11–34
- Obsidian production and distribution in Messeniapp. 25–29
- The Minoan House model and architectural evidencepp. 35–57
- Quartier Mu, production and elite culture at Maliapp. 71–80
- Kinship economy and centralization in the Argolidpp. 86–105
- Ritual deposits at Knossos and Phaistospp. 112–123
- Staple and wealth finance in the Pylian Linear B textspp. 127–148
- Prepalatial Cretan pottery production and exchangepp. 212–221
Contents
- IntroductionDaniel J. Pullen1
- Beyond the Peer: Social Interaction and Political Evolution in the Bronze Age AegeanWilliam A. Parkinson11
- Spirit of Place. Minoan Houses as Major ActorsJan Driessen35
- Making Elites: Political Economy and Elite Culture(s) in Middle Minoan CreteIlse Schoep66
- From the Kinship Economy to the Palatial Economy: The Argolid in the Second Millennium BCSofia Voutsaki86
- Political Economies in Ritual: A Comparative Study of the Rise of the State in Pre- and Protopalatial Knossos and PhaistosJoanne M. A. Murphy112
- Reevaluating Staple and Wealth Finance at Mycenaean PylosDimitri Nakassis127
- Seafaring in the Bronze Age Aegean: Evidence and SpeculationCheryl A. Ward149
- Between and Beyond: Political Economy in Non-Palatial Mycenaean WorldsThomas F. Tartaron161
- Citadel and Settlement: A Developing Economy at Mycenae, the Case of Petsas HouseKim Shelton184
- Living From Pots? Ceramic Perspectives on the Economies of Prepalatial CretePeter M. Day, Maria Relaki, Simona Todaro205
- Wedging Clay: Combining Competing Models of Mycenaean Pottery IndustriesMichael L. Galaty230
- Political Economies in the Aegean Bronze Age: A ResponseJames C. Wright248
People, places and institutions
People
- Gary Feinmandefinition of political economy
- Renfrewpeer-polity interaction model
- Cherrypeer-polity model on Crete
- Nick Karduliasnegotiated peripherality and exchange
- Eric Clinecatalogued imported Late Bronze Age objects
- Claude Levi-Straussformulated the House concept
- Rosemary Joycehouse-society model
- Susan Gillespiedefines corporate Houses
- Todd Whitelawinterpreted Myrtos Fournou Korifi households
- Peter Warreninterpreted Myrtos Fournou Korifi
- Alexandre Farnouxdirected excavation at Malia
- Baineshigh culture model
- Yoffeehigh culture model
- Jean-Claude Poursatexcavated and published Quartier Mu
- Eleni MilkaMiddle Helladic mortuary evidence
- G. C. NordquistAsine settlement and household industry
- Paul Halsteadwealth-finance model
- John KillenLinear B payments and finance
- Broodbankearly maritime travel and the Cyclades
- Cemal Pulakdirected the Uluburun shipwreck project
- George Bassdirected the Cape Gelidonya excavation
- Spyros Iakovidisgeneral director of the renewed Petsas House excavation
- Amenhotep IIIpharaoh named in discussion of Aegean contacts
Institutions
- Florida State Universityhosted the Langford Conference
- Pylos Regional Archaeological Projectsurvey evidence for obsidian production
- Archaeological Society of Athensrenewed the Petsas House excavation
- Saronic Harbors Archaeological Research Projectsurvey and research project at Kalamianos
Places
- CreteMinoan political economy and exchange
- Greek MainlandMycenaean political economy and exchange
- PylosLinear B finance, obsidian exchange and pottery
- Argolidkinship economy and palatial centralization
- Kalamianoscoastal settlement surveyed by SHARP
- Petsas HouseMycenae production and storage complex
- MycenaeArgive political economy and imported goods
- KnossosMinoan palace, ritual and Houses
- PhaistosMinoan palace, elite culture and ritual
- MaliaQuartier Mu and elite production
- Quartier Muelite complex and workshops
- Romanouobsidian blade production site
- Myrtos Fournou KorifiMinoan settlement and House interpretation
- Gournianeighbourhood and house organization
- Palaikastrotown blocks interpreted as Houses
- Tylissoscontinuity of place and architecture
- LernaMiddle Helladic cemetery and settlement
- AsineMiddle Helladic settlement and cemetery
- Melossource of Aegean obsidian
- Messeniaregional obsidian circulation and the Pylian state
- KommosCretan exchange centre
- Poros-KatsambasCretan centre and harbour
- MochlosCretan production and elite culture
- MonastirakiMiddle Minoan elite and administrative evidence
- ThebesLinear B sealings and administration
- Aghia TriadaPrepalatial consumption and ceramic storage
- Berbati Valleyregion of a pottery workshop
- Egyptmaritime exchange comparator
Also named: Jeremy Rutter, Nicolle Hirschfeld, Sahure, Tuthmosis III, Myrtos Pyrgos, University of Bonn.
Defines peer-polity interaction, House, elite culture, kinship economy, palatial economy, staple finance, wealth finance, prestige economy, diagnostic events, Fabric 1, Fabric 2, wealth ceramics
NeolithicEarly Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgePotteryTradeCraft ProductionReligion and CultSettlements
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 page- The MinoansCompendium
People it is cited for
2 people- George Fletcher Bass2 citations
- Åkerström2 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.