Article · 2016

Crisis in Context: The End of the Late Bronze Age in the Eastern Mediterranean

A. Bernard Knapp and Sturt W. Manning

American Journal of Archaeology 120(1) 99-149

An article on the end of the Late Bronze Age in the eastern Mediterranean, weighing climate, chronological, documentary and archaeological evidence, with a regional section on Cyprus.

Knapp and Manning review the evidence for the changes and destructions around the end of the Late Bronze Age across the eastern Mediterranean, taking in climate research, radiocarbon chronologies, earthquake explanations, documentary accounts and archaeology from the Aegean, Anatolia, the Levant and Cyprus. They argue that no single explanation fits changes that occurred at different times and in different settings. Climatic change may have added stress, in their view, but the immediate destruction followed from human actions within varied local circumstances. Their conclusions describe the outcome as regionally varied, with destructions, mobility and economic change alongside continuity and new political arrangements.

The evidence

The climate discussion reviews pollen, sediment, isotope, marine and cave records, together with radiocarbon dates and age-depth models. The authors examine the resolution of the records from Tell Tweini, the Cyprus B22 core and the Sea of Galilee, and argue that these do not securely date particular events at the close of the Late Bronze Age. Dating limitations also make it hard to tie climate records closely to historical events (pp. 102–116).

The documentary evidence includes Egyptian accounts, Hittite and Ugaritic correspondence, and texts concerning ships, military threats and grain supplies. Knapp and Manning hold that documentary claims cannot simply be equated with archaeological destruction layers, and they compare the texts with evidence for destruction, abandonment, pottery, buildings and settlement change, stressing uncertainty in the dating and interpretation of many sites and texts (pp. 118–134).

Cyprus

The regional survey follows Cypriot sites from late LC IIC into LC IIIA and the ProBA 3 period, which the authors date to ca. 1200–1050 B.C.E. They describe a sequence of destructions and abandonments, not a single island-wide event, and report continuity in several areas of material culture. (pp. 132–134).

Dating

Knapp and Manning discuss the crisis broadly within the late 13th to early 12th centuries B.C.E., while describing destructions and abandonments that spread over more than a century. They criticise attempts to assign precise dates to climate shifts and to particular destructions when the underlying radiocarbon and archaeological sequences are insufficiently resolved. They conclude that the evidence supports a general shift towards more arid conditions in parts of the eastern Mediterranean, without establishing a single climatic episode as the cause of the crisis (pp. 103–107, 137–138).

What it records

  • Knapp and Manning argue that the Cyprus B22 core, dated by just three radiocarbon dates, is too coarsely dated to give meaningful chronological resolution from about 1300 B.C.E. onwards.p. 103
  • Knapp and Manning argue that several proxies point to more arid conditions in the final centuries of the second millennium B.C.E., though precise dating is lacking.p. 111
  • Knapp and Manning state that Enkomi shows no evidence of earthquake-related destruction.p. 112
  • Knapp and Manning state that documentary sources do not allow events at Ugarit to be placed in a fully secure sequence.p. 120
  • The excavators of Tell Tweini suggest a date for its level 7A destruction sometime in the first quarter of the 12th century B.C.E.p. 129
  • Destructions and abandonments at Cypriot sites unfolded over some 100–150 years, beginning with abandonments in late LC IIC, in the authors' account.p. 132
  • Hala Sultan Tekke Vyzakia was among the Cypriot town centres abandoned during the period under discussion.p. 132
  • Enkomi, Kition and Kouklia Palaipaphos show destruction of monumental structures during ProBA 3.p. 132
  • Late Bronze Age destructions and abandonments on Cyprus affected coastal centres, inland settlements and production villages alike.p. 132
  • Enkomi, Palaipaphos and Kition, three large coastal or near-coastal towns, survived the crisis and emerged as new centres of authority.p. 134
  • Knapp and Manning find no evidence in the Late Bronze Age archaeological record of Cyprus for Philistines or other Sea Peoples.p. 134
  • Knapp and Manning describe social resilience and cultural continuity in Cyprus throughout the 12th and into the 11th century B.C.E.p. 134

Where to read

  • Climate proxies and the Late Bronze Age drought debatepp. 102–116
  • Radiocarbon evidence and Aegean chronologypp. 113–117
  • Ugaritic correspondence and grain-shortage textspp. 118–122
  • Regional destruction and abandonment evidencepp. 123–134
  • Cyprus: site sequence, migration claims and cultural continuitypp. 132–134
  • Agents, causes and the authors' conclusionspp. 134–138

Contents

  • Introduction99
  • Science and Archaeology: A Difficult Liaison100
  • (Paleo-)Climate, Drought, and Famine102
  • Earthquakes and Natural Disasters112
  • The Case for Chronology113
  • The Documentary Case118
  • The Archaeological Case123
  • The Aegean123
  • Anatolia126
  • The Levant127
  • Cyprus132
  • Agents and Protagonists134
  • Conclusions137
  • Works Cited139

People, places and institutions

People

  • David Kaniewskiclimate studies assessed by the authors
  • Muhlycommented on Sea Peoples evidence in Cyprus
  • Junginterprets Cypriot pottery and migration
  • Karageorghisdiscusses Jung's conclusions on Cyprus
  • Singerinterprets documentary evidence and migration
  • Broodbankoffers a trade-focused account of change
  • Maranlinks elite building to internal stresses
  • Clineinterprets crisis chronology and destructions
  • Langgutauthor of a climate and pollen study
  • Iacovoudiscusses Cyprus chronology and political geography
  • Sandarsauthor on Sea Peoples and climate stress
  • Dickinsonassesses proposed causes of the Aegean collapse
  • Yasur-Landauinterprets migration and settlement evidence

Places

  • Enkomidestroyed, then a new centre of authority
  • Kitiondestroyed, then a new centre of authority
  • Kouklia Palaipaphossite in the Cypriot destruction sequence
  • Palaipaphossurviving coastal centre
  • Hala Sultan Tekke Vyzakiaabandoned town centre
  • Myrtou Pigadhesdisrupted ceremonial centre
  • Maronitown centre abandoned in late LC IIC
  • Maa Palaeokastrosite in the migration and pottery discussion
  • Pyla Kokkinokremnosabandoned town and pottery site
  • Larnaca Salt Lakearea where the Cyprus climate core was taken
  • Tell Tweinisite in the climate and chronology debate
  • Ugaritsource of documentary and archaeological evidence

Also named: Maroni Vournes, Kalavasos Ayios Dhimitrios, Alassa Paleotaverna, Morphou Toumba tou Skourou, Athienou Bamboulari tis Koukounninas, Apliki Karamallos.

Extent pp. 99–149, 7 figs, 1 map (fig. 7); bibliography

Late Bronze AgeModernChronology and DatingLandscape and ClimateForeign ContactsSettlementsPottery

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.