Article · 1999
A Cypriot silver bowl reconsidered: II. The technique and physical history of the bowl
Metropolitan Museum Journal 34 21-30
An article on how a fragmentary silver phiale from Cyprus in the Metropolitan Museum was made, how it corroded and how it has been restored and conserved.
Hendrix examines the manufacture and physical history of a silver phiale from Cyprus, MMA 74.51.4557, of which about one-third survives. She combines examination of the bowl with metallographic and elemental analyses, tool finds from excavations and depictions of metalworking, and the article runs from the bowl and its background through its physical history to its conservation history.
Hendrix describes the bowl as hammered from sheet metal, with the design traced into the interior and the figures worked in repoussé. Its folded rim and the raised tracing visible on the back are set beside tracing tools from Middle and Late Cypriot tombs at Lapithos and Egyptian wall paintings of metalworkers, in a discussion that Hendrix places in the first millennium BCE. She concludes that the marks and the excavated tools are consistent with the proposed techniques, while the available evidence does not identify the source of the metal (pp. 23–27).
The conservation history separates fragment 4559 from bowl 4557 and shows how plaster backing both hid the bowl's thinness and protected its brittle remains. Restorations are documented from before 1934 through 1938, and the treatment begun in 1997 removed modern white paint and repainted the design lines in pale dull purple acrylic (pp. 27–30).
What it records
- MMA 74.51.4557 preserves approximately one-third of a silver phiale from Cyprus.p. 21
- Hendrix considers a Cypriot silversmith the most prudent attribution for MMA 74.51.4557, though its technique does not settle whether the maker was Cypriot or Phoenician.p. 23
- MMA 74.51.4557 is now 0.15 cm thick.p. 26
- The silver sample from MMA 74.51.4557 was completely mineralised, and the analysis could not establish whether the bowl was originally of pure silver.p. 27
- The Metropolitan Museum acquired bowls and fragments MMA 74.51.4556–4559 in 1874–76.p. 27
- Hendrix argues that fragment 4559 does not belong to bowl 4557, citing the different quality of its traced design.p. 28
- When brought to the conservation laboratory in 1997, MMA 74.51.4557 was in four large pieces with cracks in the silver and plaster restorations.p. 29
Where to read
- Manufacturing techniques and the evidence on the bowlpp. 23–26
- Corrosion and metallographic evidencepp. 26–27
- Restorations and conservation treatmentpp. 27–30
Contents
- The Bowl and Its Background21
- The Physical History of the Bowl26
- The Conservation History of the Bowl27
Objects published here
4- Silver phiale, approximately one-third preserved, Metropolitan Museum, Cyprus, MMA 74.51.4557, Figures 1, 4 (p. 21)
- Silver bowl with a central motif of a pharaoh smiting three enemies, Metropolitan Museum, MMA 74.51.4556, Figure 11 (p. 27)
- Silver bowl fragments with traced designs of running animals, Metropolitan Museum, MMA 74.51.4558a and 4558b, Figures 11, 12 (p. 27)
- Silver fragment later placed at the centre of bowl 4557, Metropolitan Museum, MMA 74.51.4559, Figures 11, 15 (p. 28)
People, places and institutions
People
- General L. P. di Cesnolaacquired the bowls for the Museum
- Dr. Karageorghisaddressed the bowl's attribution
- Herbert Maryondefined sinking and raising
- Myresdescribed the bowls in 1914
- Bissingpublished bowl fragments in 1923–24
Institutions
- Metropolitan Museumholds and treated the silver bowls
- Sherman Fairchild Center for Objects Conservationtreated the bowl in 1997
- Cesnola Collectioncollection containing the silver bowls
Places
- Lapithosfindspot of metalworking tools
- Thebeslocation of tomb paintings of metalworkers
Also named: Allan Marquand, Joan R. Mertens, Susan M. White, Mark T. Wypyski, Sidon, Tyre, Saqqara.
Extent pp. 21–31, figs 4–15 (including 8a–b)
Defines sinking, raising, annealing, repoussé
Cypro-ArchaicMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgeModernMetalworkTechnologyMuseumsHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
4 objectsWho did what
8 recordsBuying, selling and giving 1
- p. 21
Luigi Palma di CesnolaAgent forThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
The Museum acquired the bowls and bowl fragments through General L. P. di Cesnola.
Silver bowls and bowl fragments, among othersNo. MMA 74.51.4556, 4557, 4558, and 4559
Recording and study 7
- 1999 · p. 20
Elizabeth HendrixPublished
Elizabeth Hendrix authored the article on the bowl’s technique and physical history.
Silver phiale from CyprusNo. MMA 74.51.4557
- 1997 · p. 21
Elizabeth HendrixStudied
Elizabeth Hendrix examined the phiale during conservation and investigated its manufacture and physical history.
Silver phiale from CyprusNo. MMA 74.51.4557The Metropolitan Museum
- p. 21
Elizabeth HendrixEmployed byThe Metropolitan Museum of Art
Elizabeth Hendrix was an assistant conservator at The Metropolitan Museum of Art.
- p. 22
Elizabeth Hendrix drew the traced design in the silver bowl.
Traced design in silver bowlNo. MMA 74.51.4557
- 1887 · p. 27
- 1914 · p. 27
John Linton MyresPublished
John L. Myres described bowls 4556 and 4557 and fragments 4558 and 4559 separately.
Bowls and bowl fragmentsNo. MMA 74.51.4556, 4557, 4558, and 4559
- p. 27
Friedrich Wilhelm von BissingPublished
Friederich Wilhelm von Bissing published fragments of the Museum’s silver phialae and illustrated the bowl.
Fragments of the Museum’s silver phialae, including the bowlNo. MMA 74.51.4557
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.