Scholar
Maxime Collignon
fl. 1879–1919 · France
French historian of Greek art (1849 to 1917) who argued in 1893 that a head on a British Museum vase was Hathor and the vase Cypriot, using Louvre fragments.
Biography
Maxime Collignon was a French archaeologist and historian of Greek art who, in an article of 1893, used fragments of Cypriot vases in the Louvre to argue that a head on a British Museum vase was the Egyptian goddess Hathor and the vase itself Cypriot3.
A teacher in Bordeaux and Paris
The sources disagree on the day of his birth at Verdun in 1849: Georges Radet's obituary gives 9 November4. The text of the French Wikipedia article gives 8 November5. Radet calls him a Normalien, and French Wikipedia alone dates his entry to the École normale supérieure to 1868 and his two doctoral theses to 13 March 18784,5. Th. Homolle and R. de Lasteyrie count seventeen years of teaching in the Faculty of Bordeaux and then in that of Paris6. At Bordeaux he was one of the first contributors to the faculty's Annales4. He was elected to the Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres on 16 March 1894, the year the Académie began its Monuments et Mémoires6.
Cyprus in the handbooks
In his Manual of Greek Archaeology (English edition 1886) Collignon called Cypriot art "one of the most important branches of Phoenician art" and pointed to the statues from Golgoi and Idalion found by General Palma di Cesnola7. In those statues, he wrote, the influences of Egypt and of Assyria predominate in turn7.
The first volume of his Histoire de la sculpture grecque (1892) looked above all to Cyprus for comparisons with the earliest civilisation of the Greek lands8. For the oldest Cypriot cemeteries he said he did little more than summarise an article by Duemmler8. Collignon derived the clay and limestone idols from those tombs, above all Alambra, from a Babylonian prototype, and illustrated a primitive Cypriot terracotta in the Louvre from a photograph supplied by Edmond Pottier8. He held that from the sixth century Ionian art was strong enough in Cyprus to supplant Assyrian and Egyptian influence8.
The head of Hathor
In 1888 Collignon completed the Histoire de la céramique grecque of Olivier Rayet at the request of Rayet's family, without manuscript or notes9. By his preface he wrote the Introduction, chapter X and the part of the volume from chapter XIV onward9. Page 45, in Rayet's part, compared the woman's head on the vase brought back by W. Ramsay with the sphinxes of Euyuk, and called the vase apparently Lydian9. Friedrich Wilhelm von Bissing later ascribed the sphinx reading to Rayet and Collignon together10.
Collignon's article of 1893 in the Revue des Études grecques took up that vase3. He noted that Cecil Smith and Pottier inclined to class it with Cypriot vases, and Smith told him the clay confirmed his view3. His proof was a Cypriot fragment that had passed from the van Branteghem collection to the Louvre, inventory AM 393 D, described by Froehner and shown to him by Pottier3. Its middle zone shows an offering scene round a pillar with a capital in the form of Hathor's head, which he set beside a stele from Kition in the Louvre3. He placed the fragment in Cypriot pottery of the sixth century, read the so-called sphinx as Hathor, and noted that Merriam had said as much in 18853. A second Louvre fragment, also ex van Branteghem, showed the head in a rectangular frame3. He reported the fragments to the Société des Antiquaires the same year11.
Georges Perrot recorded that Smith agreed and had put the vase in a case of Cypriot pottery12. Antoine Hermary wrote in 1994 that van Branteghem bought the AM 393 fragments at the Hoffmann sale of 1890, and that Collignon, unlike Pottier, omitted to mention it1. Aurélie Carbillet names the article among the precursors and calls him the first to link the Louvre sherd's scene with the stone Hathor capitals, supposing a cult of the goddess as a pillar13.
Later work and the Louvre
In a study of the mourner type in 1903 Collignon published three limestone figures of nude women from Cyprus in the Louvre and rejected them as prototypes of the Dipylon mourners, since their date seemed relatively late14. He derived the Cypriot figures from the nude goddess pressing her breasts14. He judged it very probable that the Cypriot potters added women holding jugs to their vases for artistic reasons alone14.
Radet called him a teacher "of rare charm" and an archaeologist "of easy erudition"4. Pottier wrote that he saw through every fancy and rash conclusion "with robust good sense"15. In July 1917 Collignon offered the Louvre two ancient bronzes, according to Antoine Héron de Villefosse16. He died in Paris on 15 October 19174. In 1919 his family gave the Louvre a limestone statue fragment from Cyprus, Cypro-Archaic II, AM 172217.
Life and work
1893
- First editor of the Hathor-head sherds from Amathus (Louvre AM 393), in 'La tête d'Hathor sur des vases chypriotes'; Hermary says he omitted that the sherds came through the March 1890 Hoffmann sale and Van Branteghem's collection (Louvre acquisition 1892).
Antoine Hermary (1994). Un lot d'antiquités chypriotes du Louvre : la vente Hoffmann de mars 1890. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 21; La figure hathorique à Chypre aux IIe et Ier millénaires av. J.-C., p. 419
Undated
n.d.
- Gave an object ('statue', inv. AM 1722) to Musée du Louvre in 1919.
Connections
7 peopleSales, gifts & bequests
- Borrowed from G. BellonExposition universelle 1889 J. Chamonard; P. Couve, 1889, Catalogue des vases peints grecs et italo-grecs de la collection de M. Bellon (introduction by Max. Collignon), pp. 383-3841889
Disputes & the law
- Rival of W. M. Ramsayvase from Phocaea Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique Troisieme Serie Tome.22 (1893)1880–1893
Scholarship
- Corresponded with Cecil SmithCypriot vase in the British Museum Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques : publication trimestrielle de l'Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques (1893-01), p. 303; Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Revue des études grecques (1888)1888–1893
- Wrote with Olivier RayetHistoire de la céramique grecque Salomon Reinach (?) ; text as read, 1894, L'Anthropologie 5 (1894), p. 5131888
- Published material of Van BranteghemprobablyAM 393 Hathor-head sherds Antoine Hermary, 1994, Un lot d'antiquités chypriotes du Louvre : la vente Hoffmann de mars 18901893
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with W. M. Ramsayvase of Phocaea Revue archeologique troisieme serie tome.22 (1893)1880–1893
- Connected with Edmond PottierLouvre Cypriot vase fragment Association pour l 'encouragement des études grecques en France, Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Revue des études grecques (1888)1884–1892
- Worked with Olivier RayetHistoire de la céramique grecque; Histoire de la Céramique grecque Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques : publication trimestrielle de l'Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques (1893-01), p. 296; Association pour l 'encouragement des études grecques en France, Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Revue des études grecques (1888)1888
- Worked with L. Couveposthumous completion of the vase catalogue Association pour l 'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques (1888)
Recording and study
1 record- Published1
Maxime Collignon was the first editor of the Hathor fragments.
Hathor vase fragments, AM 393No. AM 393Hermary 1994, p. 17
Objects
Hathor-head vase fragments (amphora fragment with cult scene AM 393 d; fragment with Hathor head AM 393 c)
Musée du Louvre AM 3931890
Mentioned in
10 mentionsDocuments · 3
- Un lot d'antiquités chypriotes du Louvre : la vente Hoffmann de mars 1890
1994 · p. 17
Maxime Collignon was the first editor of the Hathor fragments.
Hermary 1994
- American journal of archaeology
1885
- La figure hathorique à Chypre aux IIe et Ier millénaires av. J.-C.
- People · 7listed under Connections
Sources
- 1.Antoine Hermary (1994). “Un lot d'antiquités chypriotes du Louvre : la vente Hoffmann de mars 1890”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 21. Online
- 2.La figure hathorique à Chypre aux IIe et Ier millénaires av. J.-C..
- 3.M. Collignon (1893). “La tête d'Hathor sur des vases chypriotes”. Revue des études grecques.
- 4.Georges Radet (1917). “Maxime Collignon (1849-1917)”. Revue des Études Anciennes 19, 304. Online
- 5.Wikipédia (2026). Maxime Collignon. Online
- 6.Th. Homolle and R. de Lasteyrie (1918). “Maxime Collignon, collaborateur et directeur des « Monuments et Mémoires », 1894-1917”. Monuments et Mémoires de la Fondation Eugène Piot 23. Online
- 7.Maxime Collignon (1886). “A Manual of Greek Archaeology”. translated by John Henry Wright.
- 8.Maxime Collignon (1892). Histoire de la sculpture grecque, tome I.
- 9.O. Rayet and M. Collignon (1888). “Histoire de la céramique grecque”. Paris: G. Decaux.
- 10.Friedrich Wilhelm von Bissing (1912). Der Anteil der ägyptischen Kunst am Kunstleben der Völker.
- 11.Archaeological Institute of America (1894). “[News: Hathoric vases]”. American Journal of Archaeology 9.
- 12.Georges Perrot. Histoire de l'art dans l'antiquité, tome IX.
- 13.Aurélie Carbillet (2009). “La figure hathorique à Chypre (IIe et Ier millénaires av. J.-C.)”. Thèse de doctorat, Université de Strasbourg.
- 14.Max. Collignon (1903). “De l'origine du type des pleureuses dans l'art grec”. Revue des Études Grecques 16, 299-322. Online
- 15.Edmond Pottier (1917). “Maxime Collignon”. Journal des Savants 15, 523-524. Online
- 16.Antoine Héron de Villefosse (1918). “Don de deux bronzes antiques de M. Maxime Collignon au Musée du Louvre”. Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des Inscriptions et Belles-Lettres 62, 151-156. Online
- 17.Musée du Louvre. [Collections record cl010122315, statue AM 1722]. Online
- 18.Musée du Louvre collection online, 'statue'.
- 19.Association pour l 'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques (1888).
- 20.J. Chamonard; P. Couve, 1889, Catalogue des vases peints grecs et italo-grecs de la collection de M. Bellon (introduction by Max. Collignon).
- 21.Antoine Hermary, 1994, Un lot d'antiquités chypriotes du Louvre : la vente Hoffmann de mars 1890.
- 22.Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques en France, Revue des études grecques : publication trimestrielle de l'Association pour l'encouragement des études grecques (1893-01).
- 23.Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique Troisieme Serie Tome.22 (1893).
- 24.Revue archeologique troisieme serie tome.22 (1893).
- 25.Association pour l 'encouragement des études grecques en France, Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Revue des études grecques (1888).
- 26.Salomon Reinach (?) ; text as read, 1894, L'Anthropologie 5 (1894).
- 27.S. Reinach, 1893, Chronique d'Orient (passage on the Phocaea vase), Revue archéologique 1893.
- 28.Ch.-Em. Ruelle, Revue des études grecques (1888).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- Date of birth unknown
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.