Scholar

Karl Bernhard Stark

fl. 1860–1879 · Germany

German classical archaeologist (1824-1879), professor of archaeology at Heidelberg, who in 1863 published the Cypriot limestone torso of the Berlin museum and in 1871 a lyre-player from Larnaka.

Biography

Karl Bernhard Stark was a German archaeologist, professor of archaeology at Heidelberg from 1855, who wrote on two Cypriot statues in the Archäologische Zeitung, a torso in Berlin in 1863 and a lyre-playing woman from near Larnaka in 18711,2,5.

Life

Stark was born at Jena on 2 October 1824, the son of Karl Wilhelm Stark, professor of pathology5. He attended the gymnasium at Hildburghausen from 1838 to 1841 and then spent a year at Schulpforta5. From 1842 he studied classical philology at Jena, then for some semesters at Leipzig under G. Hermann, and at Berlin he spent a whole year in the house of August Boeckh5. He took his doctorate at Jena in 1845 with a dissertation on Anacreon5. Early in 1848 he travelled by way of Munich to Italy, staying in Venice, Florence, Rome and Naples5. In the autumn of 1848 he became Privatdozent at Jena in classical philology and archaeology, and in 1850 extraordinary professor5,6.

His first large book, Gaza und die philistäische Küste, appeared in 18525. In 1855 Heidelberg appointed him full professor of archaeology and co-director of the philological seminar5. R. Hoche writes that Stark created an archaeological museum there out of meagre beginnings and first founded the scientific study of archaeology at Heidelberg5. Niobe und die Niobiden followed in 18635. In the same year he was elected president of the archaeological section for the next philologists' meeting, to be held at Heidelberg7. In 1871, with help from the Baden government, he set out for Greece and the Greek East, visiting Troy, Smyrna and Ephesus, and he came back to Heidelberg only at Easter 18725. He published his account of the journey, Nach dem griechischen Orient, in 1874 and was rector of the university in 18735.

The preface to the German edition of Perrot and Chipiez's history of ancient art (1884) called him one of the most learned archaeologists of Germany, who, asked by a publisher to revise the Handbuch, chose to write a new one8. Only the first part of its first volume appeared under Stark's own hand5. He came back ill from a journey to Bavaria in September 1879, and Hoche writes that a rapidly developing illness killed him on 12 October 18795.

The Berlin torso, 1863

Stark's article "Der cyprische Torso des Berliner Museums" opened the first number of the Archäologische Zeitung for 18631. He said the torso was there shown to the archaeological public in a faithful drawing for the first time1. It came from the papers and effects of Ludwig Ross, but neither Ross's travels nor other printed notes told how he had acquired it1. An editorial note adds that Ross had described it, when he handed it to the royal museum, as the torso of a Phoenician statue from Idalion1. Stark placed Cyprus in the front rank of the lands where Oriental and Greek art met, credited Ross, who travelled the island in 1845, with essential services to it, and noted the recent digs of Count de Vogüé at Golgoi and Idalion1. He read the statue as a mixture of Egyptian and Assyrian forms under Greek stylistic influence1. Stark held that Cyprus came under real Egyptian rule under the Saite kings and that the torso should not be dated much before Amasis; it might even show that king, though the lower limit was hard to fix1.

Olivier Masson and Antoine Hermary give the torso as Berlin Sk. 508, 71 cm high, first reproduced on Stark's plate, and date it to the second half of the 6th century BC4. They found it rarely mentioned: Perrot noted it briefly after Stark, and more recent works seemed not to discuss it4. C. V. Olien reads the 1863 article as an early call by Stark to research "Oriental" art, lest Greek art be understood as a mosaic of Oriental forms, within what Olien calls the legacy of imperialist logic in the study of Cypriot sculpture9.

The lyre-player, 1871

In 1867, Stark relates, the German traveller Joseph Bachmaier saw an ancient female statue at the door of a Greek café in Beirut, brought from Larnaka by the owner, who knew only that it had been dug up a few years before in a garden near the town2. Bachmaier took it to Munich, where talks with the Glyptothek failed because it did not fit a niche, and its owner then went to North America hoping to sell it2. Stark acquired a plaster cast for the Heidelberg collection2. He put forward Sappho, with a question mark, arguing that no name expressed the muse of Cypriot festivals so clearly, and weighed a grave monument as a second possibility2,10.

The sources differ on the year: J. J. Bernoulli cites the article as Archäologische Zeitung 1870, while the German edition of Cesnola's book gives 187110,11. The German edition of Cesnola's book and a reviewer of Doell's catalogue of the Cesnola collection compared Cesnola lyre-players with Stark's11,12. Bernoulli saw in it simply a lyre-playing woman with a laurel wreath and nothing more10. The British Museum, whose lyre-player bought from R. H. Lang it records as found or acquired at Larnaka, says its early history is told in Stark 187113.

In his Systematik und Geschichte der Archäologie der Kunst of 1878 Stark surveyed Cypriot research, crediting Ross with first seeing the island's significance in the early 1840s and the duc de Luynes with the only right method in 185214. He named the Cesnola digs near Larnaka and claimed for German scholarship establishing the character of the Cypriot script and language and Johannes Doell's survey of Cesnola's finds14.

Life and work

  1. 1871

    1. Published 'Leierspielende Frau (Sappho?) Statue aus Cypern' in Archäologische Zeitung 28, pp. 67-76 (Berlin, 1871).

      BerlinC. D. Cobham (1908). Excerpta Cypria: Materials for a History of Cyprus. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press

  2. 1879

    1. In Cesnola's account (1879): Proposed that a seated lyre-playing woman from Larnaka is Sappho: «abgebildet ift, möchte B. Stark als Sappho erklären.»

      L. P. di Cesnola, Cypern, seine alten Städte, Gräber und Tempel. Bericht über zehnjährige Forschungen und Ausgrabungen auf der Insel (1879), p. 410

Connections

1 person

Recording and study

1 record
Published1
  • 1863Stark published an article about a previously unpublished torso in the Berlin Museum.

    un torse masculinNo. inv. Skulpturen 508Masson & Hermary 1988, p. 4

Mentioned in

5 mentions

Documents · 4

Sources

  1. 1.K. B. Stark (1863). Der Cyprische Torso des Berliner Museums (No. 796) Gr. Grabrelief. Ein archaeol. Raethsel. Berlin.
  2. 2.K. B. Stark (1871). “Leierspielende Frau (Sappho?) Statue aus Cypern”. Archäologische Zeitung 28, 67-76.
  3. 3.C. D. Cobham (1908). Excerpta Cypria: Materials for a History of Cyprus. Cambridge, Cambridge University Press.
  4. 4.O. Masson, A. Hermary (1988). “Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 9, 3-10. Online
  5. 5.R. Hoche (1893). “Stark, Karl Bernhard”. Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie 35, 488-490.
  6. 6.W. Freund (1906). Triennium philologicum, oder Grundzüge der philologischen Wissenschaften.
  7. 7.[Anon.] (1863). “[Report of the archaeological section of the Philologenversammlung]”. Archäologischer Anzeiger (with Archäologische Zeitung 21).
  8. 8.G. Perrot; Ch. Chipiez; R. Pietschmann (tr.) (1884). Geschichte der Kunst im Alterthum: Aegypten.
  9. 9.C. V. Olien (2023). “Exploring the legacy of imperialist logic: new theoretical approaches to the historiography of Cypriot sculpture”. Empire and Excavation.
  10. 10.J. J. Bernoulli (1901). Griechische Ikonographie mit Ausschluss Alexanders und der Diadochen.
  11. 11.L. P. di Cesnola; L. Stern (ed.) (1879). Cypern, seine alten Städte, Gräber und Tempel.
  12. 12.[anonymous reviewer] (1874). “[Review of J. Doell, Die Sammlung Cesnola]”. Philologischer Anzeiger 6.
  13. 13.British Museum. “Limestone statue of a female lyre-player, 1917,0701.171”. British Museum collection online.
  14. 14.K. B. Stark (1878). “Systematik und Geschichte der Archäologie der Kunst”. Handbuch der Archäologie der Kunst, Erste Abtheilung.
  15. 15.L. P. di Cesnola, Cypern, seine alten Städte, Gräber und Tempel. Bericht über zehnjährige Forschungen und Ausgrabungen auf der Insel (1879).
  16. 16.O. Masson and A. Hermary, 1988, Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin.
  17. 17.Antoine Hermary, Histoire des études sur la sculpture chypriote (1990).
  18. 18.Masson & Hermary, 'Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin', CCEC 9 (1988) p. 3 and n. 13.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.