Scholar · Museum director

Eduard Gerhard

1795–1867 · Germany

Berlin archaeologist who in 1846 published two limestone statuettes that Ludwig Ross had brought from Idalion, and argued that their style was old Greek, not Phoenician.

Biography

Eduard Gerhard was the archaeologist of the Berlin Museum who, in a paper read to the Berlin Academy on 13 August 1846, published two female statuettes that Ludwig Ross had brought from Idalion on Cyprus, and argued that their style was old Greek rather than Phoenician1,10.

Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Gerhard was born in Posen on 29 November 1795, where his father was employed as a judge11,12. His eyes troubled him from early youth, and work on the scholia to Pindar made it worse, as did repeated attacks of fever11. Otto Jahn records that at one time the eye disease struck so badly that for several weeks he could not see at all12.

In Rome, on 9 December 1828, the founding of an institute was agreed at the house of Bunsen12. The Instituto di corrispondenza archeologica opened on 21 April 1829, the birthday of the city, and Karl Ludwig Urlichs calls Gerhard and Bunsen its founders11. In Jahn's account its first direction had the Duc de Blacas as president, Bunsen as secretary, and Gerhard and Theodor Panofka as vice-secretaries12.

In Berlin the Academy of Sciences elected him a corresponding member in 1832 and a full member in February 183511. At the start of March 1833 he received a permanent post as archaeologist of the Berlin Museum, at a salary Urlichs gives as 1,150 thalers11. He was given charge of the vases and terracottas in 1836 and the direction of the sculpture department in 185511. The university made him extraordinary professor in 1843 and full professor in 184411. On 5 July 1842, in Frankfurt, he married Emilie von Riess, the 23-year-old daughter of Geheimrat von Riess, the Electoral Hessian envoy to the Federal Diet11,12.

A note of 1847 in the Archäologische Zeitung says the museum owed its idols of soft Cypriot limestone to Ross, at whose prompting Louis de Mas Latrie later took similar figures from the same find-spot, Idalion, to Paris13. Ross himself held the Idalion idols to be Phoenician, as Gerhard noted, citing the Academy's Monatsbericht for 184614.

Gerhard's paper "Über die Kunst der Phönicier" was printed in the Academy's Abhandlungen for 1846, pp. 579-618, and reprinted in his collected academic papers1,15. In it he called the temple at Paphos "without doubt" a work of Phoenician art, known from coin types10. The sanctuary seemed to him more a setting for extravagant festivals than an artistically finished temple, and its plain conical cult image suggested to him that it had no figured decoration at all10. The reprint has a ground plan of the Paphos temple after Ali Bey, Hammer and Ketsch14.

Archaic Sicilian goddesses, he concluded, must count as old Greek and "in no case" as Phoenician10. Gerhard put in the same case several Venus idols that his colleague Ross, "not without belief in their Phoenician origin", had brought from Idalion to the Berlin museum10. He presented drawings of the chief of them "as allegedly Phoenician", as a supplement to his earlier paper on Venus idols10. He joined them to the Etruscan Venus idols by their pose and by their attributes, among them a flower and a cup, which he found very far from the Phoenician cone-shaped Venus14. He added a similar idol from Cyprus already published by Caylus10.

The plate number differs between printings: the body of the 1846 text points to plate VII, while the plate commentary puts the figures under section VI, and later writers give plate VI1,10,16. In that commentary, headed "Cypriot Venus idols", Gerhard wrote that the two figures he gave would suffice to show that the style first taken for Phoenician was rather old Greek10. His figure 1 is the upper part of a draped Venus holding a pomegranate blossom in her left hand below the breast, and figure 2 a similarly dressed figure pressing a cup to her body10. Other sculptures that came to Berlin with them carried flowers or flower stems and were, in his words, wholly consistent in style10.

Olivier Masson and Antoine Hermary identify the first figure as a limestone statuette from Idalion, 37 cm high, inventory unknown and perhaps lost1. The second, probably also from Idalion, is known to them only from Gerhard's engraving1. They call his paper a pioneering study, the first to take up Ross's Cypriot objects1. Félix Lajard published Gerhard's statuette again in 18491.

Barth wrote on the same subject in the Archäologische Zeitung in 1848, and Karl Bernhard Stark cited the two papers together in 185217. A writer in the Annali of 1869 found the dress of the Berlin statuettes oriental in manner and judged Ross's argument that Idalion had always been Phoenician not well founded7. The same writer thought Gerhard, in his paper on Venus idols, had named a Cypriot idol Urania "without reason"7. Hermary, writing in 1990, calls Gerhard one of the archaeological authorities of the day, and notes that he wrongly took a text on the Mas Latrie statuettes to be by Longpérier when it was by Charles Lenormant6. Max Ohnefalsch-Richter later credited him with first illustrating a winged Etruscan bronze of Kypra with a dove on her head18.

From 1855 to 1867 Gerhard directed the museum's sculpture and cast section, into which some of Ross's Cypriot antiquities came; Masson and Hermary say no list of them seems to survive1. His sight weakened over his last ten years until it was almost gone11. In the preface to his collected papers, dated 21 September 1866, he wrote that for years he had had to work without the use of his own eyes14. He died a gentle death on 12 May 1867, his wife alone with him at the end11,12.

Life and work

  1. 1846

    1. 13 August

      Presented 'Ueber die Kunst der Phoenicier' to the Berlin Academy, noting two female statuettes ('Venusidole') from the Ross collection, with engravings (Akad. Berlin pl. VI, 1 and 2); Masson and Hermary say they were found at Idalion and reproduce them. He called two Ross statues and the Caylus one 'angeblich phönicisch'.

      BerlinO. Masson, A. Hermary (1988). Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 9, 3-10, pp. 4; O. Masson (1990). Correspondances chypriotes: lettres des frères Colonna-Ceccaldi et de L. Palma di Cesnola à W. Froehner. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14, 29-44, p. 4

  2. 1855

    1. 1855–1867

      Director of the sculpture section of the Berlin Royal Museum, where some of Ross's Cypriot antiquities entered; Tieck had directed it 1830-1851.

      BerlinO. Masson, A. Hermary (1988). Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 9, 3-10, p. 3

  3. After 1867

Connections

7 people

Recording and study

2 records
Published1
  • 1846Gerhard reported and reproduced two female statuettes in his study of Phoenician art.

    deux statuettes fémininesBerlinMasson & Hermary 1988, p. 4

Directed1

Objects

Mentioned in

9 mentions

Documents · 2

Sources

  1. 1.O. Masson, A. Hermary (1988). “Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 9, 3-10. Online
  2. 2.O. Masson (1990). “Correspondances chypriotes: lettres des frères Colonna-Ceccaldi et de L. Palma di Cesnola à W. Froehner”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14, 29-44. Online
  3. 3.E. Gerhard (1868). Gesammelte akademische Abhandlungen.
  4. 4.“Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard Gerhard”. Wikidata / GND. Online
  5. 5.Ludwig Mercklin (1854). Aphrodite Nemesis mit der Sandale, griechisches Erzbild des Dorpater Museums.
  6. 6.Antoine Hermary (1990). “Histoire des études sur la sculpture chypriote”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 14. Online
  7. 7. (1869). “[Article on the Aphrodite of the Villa Albani]”. Annali dell'Instituto di corrispondenza archeologica.
  8. 8.James Hastings (1908). Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics.
  9. 9.Josiah C. Nott (1868). Indigenous Races of the Earth.
  10. 10.Eduard Gerhard (1848). “Über die Kunst der Phönicier”. Abhandlungen der Königlichen Akademie der Wissenschaften zu Berlin, aus dem Jahre 1846, philosophisch-historische Klasse, 579-618.
  11. 11.Karl Ludwig Urlichs (1878). “Gerhard, Friedrich Wilhelm Eduard”. Allgemeine Deutsche Biographie 8, 760-766. Duncker & Humblot. Online
  12. 12.Otto Jahn (1868). Eduard Gerhard. Ein Lebensabriss.
  13. 13. (1847). “[Editorial survey of new finds]”. Archäologische Zeitung, Neue Folge 1.
  14. 14.Eduard Gerhard (1866). Gesammelte akademische Abhandlungen und kleine Schriften. Georg Reimer.
  15. 15.“[Article citing Gerhard on Phoenician art]”. Jahrbücher des Vereins von Alterthumsfreunden im Rheinlande.
  16. 16. (1866). “[Article on a figure of the Cyprian Aphrodite with dove]”. Archäologische Zeitung 24.
  17. 17.Karl Bernhard Stark (1852). Gaza und die philistäische Küste.
  18. 18.Max Ohnefalsch-Richter. “[Paper on Cypriot and Etruscan female figures]”. Verhandlungen der Berliner Gesellschaft für Anthropologie, Ethnologie und Urgeschichte.
  19. 19.O. Masson, A. Hermary, 1988, Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin.
  20. 20.Deutsches Archäologisches Institut, 1869, Annali dell'Instituto di corrispondenza archeologica; Antoine Hermary, 1990, Histoire des études sur la sculpture chypriote.
  21. 21.Ludwig Mercklin, Aphrodite Nemesis mit der Sandale griechisches Erzbild des Dorpater Museums (1854).
  22. 22.Deutsches Archäologisches Institut. [from old catalog], Annali. Annales (1869).
  23. 23.Josiah Nott, Indigenous Races Of The Earth [ 1868].
  24. 24.Josiah C. Nott, Nott, Josiah C. Indigenous Races Of The Earth [1868] (1868).
  25. 25.James Hastings, M.A., D.D., Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics (1908).
  26. 26.Josiah Clark Nott - Indigenous Races of the Earth.
  27. 27.Masson & Hermary, 'Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin', CCEC 9 (1988) p. 3.
  28. 28.Gerhard, Eduard, 1795-1867, [from old catalog] ed; Curtius, Ernst, 1814-1896, [from old catalog] ed; Fränkel, Max, 1846-1903, [from old catalog] ed, Archäologische Zeitung (1867).
  29. 29.Gerhard, Eduard, 1795-1867, [from old catalog] ed; Curtius, Ernst, 1814-1896, [from old catalog] ed; Fränkel, Max, 1846-1903, [from old catalog] ed, Archäologische Zeitung (1857).
  30. 30.Alexander Conze; Otto Jahn, 1864, Sculpturen aus Kypros, leaf 99.
  31. 31.E. Gerhard, 1866, Gesammelte akademische Abhandlungen und kleine Schriften.
  32. 32.O. Masson, A. Hermary, 1988, Le voyage de Ludwig Ross à Chypre en 1845 et les antiquités chypriotes du Musée de Berlin, p. 3; L. Ross; E. Gerhard (ed.), 1845, Kurion und das Heiligthum des Apollon Hylates auf Kypros (letter to the editor); with the report of the Roman Institute's session; E. Gerhard, 1848, Über die Kunst der Phönicier, pp. 596-597; E. Gerhard, 1850, Widdergottheiten, p. 151; K. B. Stark (editor's note signed A. d. H.), 1863, Der cyprische Torso des Berliner Museums.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.