Dealer

Canessa

fl. 1897–1924

The Canessa brothers' antiquities firm of Naples, Paris and New York, which assembled 300 vases for the Metropolitan Museum in 1906 and is named as a seller of the Second Cyprus Treasure.

Biography

"Canessa" in Paris was the antiquities firm of the Canessa brothers of Naples, which assembled a collection of vases that the Metropolitan Museum bought in 1906 and which several writers name as the dealer who sold J. Pierpont Morgan the Second Cyprus Treasure2,3,13.

The firm

Numismatica Ars Classica gives the business as that of Cesare Canessa (1863-1922) and Ercole Canessa (1868-1929), later carried on by Ambrogio (born 1900) and Guglielmo Canessa (1905-1975)4. The 1930 sale catalogue says the firm was founded in Naples forty-five years earlier, with branches in Paris and New York5. It traded as C. & E. Canessa, at 19 rue Lafayette in 1901, and the Metropolitan Museum's notes of 1906 call it A. & C. Canessa of Paris and Naples2,6. In Paris the firm later moved to the Champs-Élysées and the Place Vendôme4. The 1924 sale catalogue says the brothers came to New York about twenty years earlier and latterly occupied Benjamin Altman's former galleries in West 50th Street7. Their 1924 catalogue says they supplied objects and advice to Morgan, Henry Walters, Altman and many museums7.

The Canessas held sales jointly with Arthur Sambon from 1900, and numismatic auctions in the 1920s, among them the Caruso collection in 1923; Cesare's daughter had married Caruso's son4. Sambon credits a Canessa, digging with de Prisco and Cacace, with bringing to light the Boscoreale and Taranto silver3. The Metropolitan Museum had bought the Boscoreale frescoes from the firm in 19032.

The Second Cyprus Treasure

In early summer 1902 Byzantine silver plate and gold jewellery were found at Karavas, near ancient Lapithos, west of Kyrenia8. O. M. Dalton says the finders hid the treasure and dealt with dealers in Paris, and that the more important part was put beyond the reach of the authorities and reached Paris8. The part seized in Cyprus stayed there after the Government won the finders' lawsuit on appeal8. Dalton says the dealer in Paris was secure, as it could not be proved that he knew the objects came from excavation and he was neither British nor French, and that the price demanded, running into five figures, left the treasure unsold in winter 19058.

A letter of 3 May 1904 in W. Froehner's correspondence with Gustave Schlumberger says that Morgan was in Paris and "Canessa lui a vendu un bronze très cher"1.

The sources disagree on who sold Morgan the treasure, Canessa or Sivadjian3,9. Sambon wrote in 1906 that it passed "de main en main" and was finally acquired by the antiquary Canessa, who sold it to Morgan3. Le Journal said Canessa had hardly brought it to France when Morgan bought it10. Melanie Holcomb names Ercole Canessa, in April 190611. The Metropolitan Museum's 2000 catalogue lists a belt from the treasure as ex Amedeo Canessa, Paris12. On the other side, Froehner's journal records Sivadjian showing him the silver in November 1903 and June 1904, and the Byzanz catalogue of 2001 says Morgan bought from "Sivadyan"1,9. Morgan gave the treasure to the Metropolitan Museum in 191712.

Vases for the Metropolitan Museum

Until 1906 the Metropolitan Museum's vases were only the Cesnola Collection from Cyprus2. At Luigi Palma di Cesnola's instigation the Canessas assembled 300 Greek and Roman vases to fill the gaps, and the museum bought them in January 19062,13. The Burlington's "Art in America" section, edited by Frank J. Mather, welcomed them as a step towards correcting the lack of other ancient pottery13. A Burlington correspondent judged the collection of high average merit but with few pieces of the finest sort, and thought "bigness" had guided the choice14.

Cesare Canessa died in Naples on 12 November 1922, and the firm's collection was sold in New York in 1924 to settle his estate7,15. The sale included a "Cypriote" jar with three women's heads above the rim7. Ercole Canessa died in January 1929, and the rest of his collection was sold in New York on 29 March 19305.

Life and work

  1. 1904

    1. May

      Froehner told G. Schlumberger on 3 May 1904 that Morgan was in Paris and that 'Canessa lui a vendu un bronze très cher'; Morgan was still hesitating over the Lapithos treasure.

      ParisMarie-Christine Hellmann (1991). W. Froehner et Chypre. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 16, 17-28, n. 47

Connections

3 people

Mentioned in

3 mentions

Documents · 1

Sources

  1. 1.Marie-Christine Hellmann (1991). “W. Froehner et Chypre”. Cahiers du Centre d'Études Chypriotes 16, 17-28. Online
  2. 2. (1906). “Greek and Roman Vases”. Bulletin of the Metropolitan Museum of Art 1.
  3. 3.Arthur Sambon (1906). “Trésor d'orfèvrerie et d'argenterie trouvé à Chypre et faisant partie de la collection de M. J. Pierpont Morgan”. Le Musée 3, 121-129.
  4. 4.Numismatica Ars Classica (2018). Auction 105: the George W. La Borde collection (index of provenances). Numismatica Ars Classica, Zurich.
  5. 5.American Art Association, Anderson Galleries (1930). Rare and valuable antiquities ... gathered from famous European collections by the late Ercole Canessa, expert antiquarian & expert at Hotel Drouot, Paris. American Art Association, Anderson Galleries, New York.
  6. 6.Hôtel Drouot (1901). Collection d'antiquités: sculptures, vases peints, terres cuites, verrerie, bijoux, bronzes, médailles (sale 18-20 March 1901). Paris.
  7. 7.American Art Galleries (1924). Illustrated catalogue of the art collection of the expert antiquarians C. & E. Canessa of New York, Paris, Naples. American Art Association, New York.
  8. 8.O. M. Dalton (1906). “A Second Silver Treasure from Cyprus”. Archaeologia 60, 1-24.
  9. 9. (2001). Byzanz: das Licht aus dem Osten. Kult und Alltag im Byzantinischen Reich vom 4. bis 15. Jahrhundert.
  10. 10. (1906). “[Paragraph on the Byzantine treasure from Cyprus bought by J. Pierpont Morgan]”. Le Journal (Paris).
  11. 11.Melanie Holcomb (2008). “'Ugly but . . . important': the Albanian Hoard and the making of the archaeological treasure in the early twentieth century”. Art History 31. Online
  12. 12.Katharine Reynolds Brown, Dafydd Kidd and Charles T. Little (eds) (2000). From Attila to Charlemagne: Arts of the Early Medieval Period in The Metropolitan Museum of Art. Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York.
  13. 13.Frank J. Mather, Jr. (1906). “The Canessa Collection”. The Burlington Magazine 9.
  14. 14. (1906). “[Art in America letter on Metropolitan Museum purchases]”. The Burlington Magazine 8.
  15. 15. (1923). “Cav. Cesare Canessa [death notice]”. The Numismatist 36.
  16. 16.1901, Collection d'antiquités grecques et romaines provenant de Naples (vente, Hôtel Drouot, 18-20 mars 1901, Me Maurice Delestre; experts A. Sambon, C. et E. Canessa); 1903, Collection d'antiquités: vases peints et moulés, terres cuites, verrerie, sculptures, bronzes, bijoux (vente, Hôtel Drouot, 11-14 mai 1903, Me Maurice Delestre; experts A. Sambon, C. et E. Canessa).
  17. 17.M.-C. Hellmann, 1991, W. Froehner et Chypre, n. 47.
  18. 18.Hellmann 1991, 'W. Froehner et Chypre', CCEC 16n. 47.
  19. 19.Le Journal (1906-05-28).
  20. 20.American Art Galleries, 1924, Illustrated catalogue of the art collection of the expert antiquarians C. & E. Canessa of New York, Paris, Naples (American Art Galleries), title page.
  21. 21.Arthur Sambon, 1906, Tresor d'orfevrerie et d'argenterie trouve a Chypre et faisant partie de la collection de M. J. Pierpont Morgan, p. 122; 1906, Le Journal (28 May 1906).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.