Book · 1989

Monks and Monasteries of the Egyptian Deserts

Otto F. A. Meinardus

Cairo: American University in Cairo Press

A survey of Coptic monasticism in Egypt, from the first desert ascetics to the monasteries of the twentieth century, with a history of each major site and an account of monastic roles and practice.

Meinardus surveys Coptic monasticism in Egypt through histories of individual monasteries, descriptions of their buildings and communities, and a closing discussion of monastic life. The survey runs from St. Antony and the Red Sea monasteries of St. Antony and St. Paul to the Wādī 'n-Natrūn, St. Samuel at al-Qalamūn, Dair al-Muharraq, the shrine and renewed monastery of St. Menas at Abû Mînâ, the monasteries of Upper Egypt and monasticism in the Fayyûm. Its sources are Coptic and Ethiopian synaxaria, histories of the patriarchs, Arabic and Syriac texts, inscriptions, graffiti, manuscript notes, church traditions and accounts by travellers.

How it is organised

The opening chapters introduce St. Antony and follow the histories of the monasteries of St. Antony and St. Paul (pp. 1–47). A chapter on the Wādī 'n-Natrūn precedes chapters on its principal monasteries: al-Barāmūs, Abū Maqār, Anbā Bishoi and as-Surīān. Dair Anbâ Samwil, Dair al-Muharraq and Abû Mînâ follow, then Upper Egyptian monasticism and the Fayyûm. A chapter on the sociology of Coptic monasticism and an epilogue come last, with notes, a bibliography and indices after them.

The evidence

The site accounts describe churches, keeps or qasrs, chapels, refectories, cells, gardens, wells and springs, often with measurements and dates (pp. 27–32, 44–47). Observations recorded over several centuries are set side by side, among them descriptions of buildings, water sources, gardens and libraries and counts of monks. The chapters on present-day monasteries record churches, relics, libraries, staff, resident monks and novices, farming, and guest accommodation and services.

For Abû Mînâ Meinardus also reports the excavations of the Kaufmann expedition and the later work at the ancient pilgrimage centre (pp. 168–179). The final thematic chapter classifies monastic roles and practices: the solitary and the coenobitic monk, the priest, prophet, scholar, scribe, shepherd and ascete.

The argument

Meinardus presents desert monasticism as an institution that changed under ascetic ideals, repeated destruction and rebuilding, and growing contact with visitors and the wider Church. The histories show settlements affected by raids, persecution, plague, desert travel and shifting church relations. In the Wādī 'n-Natrūn he describes successive destructions and returns, the changing balance among its monasteries, and the movement of manuscripts into European collections. The Red Sea accounts follow St. Antony's monastery from early settlement through damage and rebuilding, drawing on pilgrims' and travellers' descriptions to show changes in access and population (pp. 5–26, 52–70, 73–143).

The modern monasteries appear as renewed communities with enlarged buildings and new farming and educational work, which Meinardus links to new roads, agricultural projects, guest facilities and church leadership. He records the rebuilding of the monastery at Abû Mînâ from 1959, developments at Abû Maqâr after 1969, and the growth of several other houses by the 1980s. His treatment also follows the monasteries' part in Coptic church life, including the recruitment of patriarchs from monastic communities, and his account of monastic life separates solitary and communal forms and considers the range of personal motives within the Church (pp. 103–104, 119–120, 143, 178–179, 190–201).

Dating

The histories begin with ascetic settlements of the late third and fourth centuries and end with the monastic revival of the twentieth. Each monastery's story is arranged around its foundation traditions, recorded raids and rebuilding, medieval developments, later pilgrim and traveller accounts, and conditions observed in the twentieth century. At Abû Mînâ he distinguishes the late fourth-century shrine, the fifth-century basilica and later buildings, and then gives the sequence of excavation and reconstruction (pp. 168–179).

Limits of the evidence

Meinardus calls the volume an introduction. He states that sources and manuscripts were not all accessible to him and that he does not claim to establish the historical accuracy of every tradition he reports (pp. ix–xii, 26–27, 50–51, 202–204).

What it records

  • Meinardus limits the study to inhabited monasteries.p. xi
  • The 1989 revised edition shortened or omitted chapters from the first edition to make room for new material.p. xii
  • Meinardus reports that it is now generally assumed the monastery of St. Antony was built in the reign of Julian the Apostate, between 361 and 363.p. 5
  • Abû Sâlih describes the garden at the monastery of St. Antony as containing about a thousand palm trees.p. 9
  • The monastery of St. Paul had twenty-six monks in 1956.p. 43
  • Mawhūb recorded 712 monks in seven monasteries of the Desert of Scetis in 1088, twenty of them at al-Barâmûs.p. 58
  • Dair Abû Maqâr received 2,000 feddans of desert land from President Sadat in 1978.p. 103
  • Pope Shenûdah III spent about forty months in enforced exile at Dair Anbâ Bishoi, between September 1981 and January 1985.p. 120
  • A note in a Syriac manuscript says that John found one monk at the Monastery of the Syrians in 1413.p. 125
  • The Monastery of the Syrians had sixty monks in Mawhūb's census of 1088.p. 125
  • The community of Dair Anbâ Samwil numbered fifteen monks and six novices in 1985.p. 153
  • A fire at the 1988 feast of Dair al-Muharraq killed twenty-six children, six women and fifteen men.p. 167
  • The Kaufmann expedition excavated the shrine and monastery of St. Menas from 1905 to 1907.p. 177
  • Pope Anbā Kīrillus VI laid the foundation stone of the new monastery of St. Menas on 27 November 1959.p. 179

Where to read

  • St. Antony and the beginnings of the monasterypp. 1–9
  • St. Antony's monastery in travellers' accounts and its present buildingspp. 10–32
  • The Wādī 'n-Natrūn monasteries and their historiespp. 48–143
  • Dair Anbâ Samwil and the cave of St. Samuelpp. 144–154
  • The shrine and rebuilt monastery of Abû Mînâpp. 168–179
  • Monasteries of Upper Egyptpp. 180–185
  • Motives and roles in Coptic monasticismpp. 190–201

Contents

  • St. Antony the Ascete1
  • Dair Anbâ Antūniûs5
  • Dair Anbâ Bûlâ33
  • The Valley of the Wâdī 'n-Natrūn48
  • Dair al-Barâmûs52
  • Dair Abû Maqâr72
  • Dair Anbâ Bishoi105
  • Dair as-Surîān121
  • Dair Anbâ Samwil144
  • Dair al-Muharraq155
  • Dair Abû Mînâ168
  • Upper Egyptian Monasticism180
  • Monasticism in the Fayyûm186
  • The Sociology of Coptic Monasticism190
  • Epilogue202

People, places and institutions

People

  • St. Antonydesert ascetic and monastic exemplar
  • St. Macarius the Greatfounder figure of Scetis monasticism
  • St. Paul the Thebanhermit honoured at the Red Sea monastery
  • Pachomiusorganiser of Upper Egyptian communal monasticism
  • Pope Shenûdah IIICoptic pope, monastic leader, exiled to Anbâ Bishoi
  • Abûnâ Mattâ al-Maskinmonastic leader at Abû Maqâr
  • Anbā Kīrillus VIpope who founded the new monastery of St. Menas
  • Johann GeorgDuke of Saxony, visitor to the monasteries
  • Agnes Smith Lewisvisitor to monasteries and their manuscripts
  • Marcus Simaikacatalogued monastic manuscripts
  • Kaufmannexcavated the shrine of St. Menas

Institutions

  • German Archaeological Institute in Cairoexcavation body at Abû Mînâ
  • Metropolitan Museum of Art Egyptian Expeditiondocumented the Wādī 'n-Natrūn monasteries
  • Coptic Museumholds manuscripts recovered at Abû Maqâr

Places

  • Wādi 'n-Natrūnvalley of four principal monasteries
  • Monastery of St. AntonyRed Sea monastery, its history and buildings
  • Dair Anbâ BûlâRed Sea monastery of St. Paul
  • Dair al-BarâmûsWādī 'n-Natrūn monastery
  • Dair Abû MaqârWādī 'n-Natrūn monastery
  • Dair Anbâ BishoiWādī 'n-Natrūn monastery
  • Monastery of the SyriansWādī 'n-Natrūn monastery
  • Dair Anbâ Samwilmonastery of St. Samuel
  • Dair al-Muharraqmonastery of the Blessed Virgin Mary
  • Abû Mînâancient shrine and renewed monastery of St. Menas
  • Dair al-Malāk GhobriâlFayyūm monastery and laura
  • Dair Anbâ Shenûdahthe White Monastery of Upper Egypt
  • Dair DurunkaUpper Egyptian monastery
  • Dair Anbâ BakhûmUpper Egyptian monastery
  • Dair Mārti GirgisUpper Egyptian monastery
  • Dair al-FakhûriUpper Egyptian monastery
  • Dair al-HammâmFayyūm monastery

Also named: Mawhūb.

Extent 3 maps; bibliography, pp. 225–236; index, pp. 237–245

Defines anchoritic, coenobitic, Era of the Martyrs

Late AntiqueMedievalModernRomanReligion and CultArchitectureHistory of ArchaeologyMuseumsLandscape and Climate

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.