Article · 2019

The Mainstream Media and the "Shocking Bad Art" from Cyprus: 1870s New York Reacts to the Cesnola Collections

Ann-Marie Knoblauch

An article on how New York newspapers and magazines received the Metropolitan Museum of Art's 1872 and 1876 purchases of Cesnola's Cypriot antiquities, from 1872 to the opening of the Fifth Avenue building in 1880.

Knoblauch follows New York newspaper and magazine reports on the Cesnola collections from their first purchase in 1872 through the opening of the Metropolitan Museum's Fifth Avenue building in 1880. She compares reports in the New York Herald, the New York Times and other local publications with Hiram Hitchcock's 1872 essay on Cesnola, and draws on the press response to the first collection's sculptures, Cesnola's 1878 interview and criticism of the scale and repetition of the second collection.

New Yorkers, she argues, often dismissed the sculpture and pottery as artistically weak while welcoming the collections as a prize that raised the city's cultural standing. She links this response to Gilded Age competition, consumerism and admiration for the self-made businessman. Newspapers cast Cesnola as an enterprising American hero and presented the acquisition as a victory over European institutions, repeating the claim that the British Museum had coveted the antiquities; an 1880 letter disputes that account.

Commentary shifted from criticism of the unfamiliar style of the sculpture to complaints that the quantity of Cypriot material overwhelmed the museum. Favourable portraits of Cesnola and the competitive language around the purchases appeared alongside reports of low public attendance and doubts about the objects' artistic appeal.

What it records

  • The Metropolitan Museum of Art purchased Cesnola's Cypriot collections in two lots, in 1872 and 1876.p. 67
  • The two collections contained around 20,000 objects acquired by Cesnola while he served as US Consul on Cyprus from 1865 to 1876.p. 67
  • The first sale included nearly 10,000 objects, among them around 1,000 limestone sculptures from Golgoi.p. 69
  • New York newspapers portrayed the Cesnola collection as a prize that the British Museum had coveted.p. 73
  • An 1880 letter writer identified as "An Englishman" stated that the British Museum authorities had declined to acquire the collection.p. 73

Where to read

  • Hitchcock’s 1872 essay and the first collection’s receptionpp. 68–70
  • Press accounts of Cesnola and the second collectionpp. 71–74

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • Metropolitan Museum of Artpurchased and exhibited the Cesnola collections
  • British Museumsaid to have coveted the collection
  • Harper's New Monthly Magazinepublished Hitchcock's essay
  • New York Heraldreported on the collection and Cesnola
  • New York Timesreviewed the collections and their reception

Places

  • New Yorksetting of the press response and the purchases
  • Golgoisanctuary and findspot of limestone sculpture
  • Londonwhere the collection was shown for sale

Also named: Athienou-Ayios Photios, John Taylor Johnston, Christian Union, Louvre, Idalium, Besbes, P.T. Barnum.

Extent pp. 67–74, 7 figs; bibliography

ModernMuseumsCollectingHistory of ArchaeologySculpture

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Who did what

5 records

Buying, selling and giving 3

Recording and study 2

People it is cited for

4 people

Institutions it is cited for

1 institution

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

Missing from this record

  • Journal not recorded

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.