Article · 2021
Conflict antiquities' rescue or ransom: The cost of buying back stolen cultural property in contexts of political violence
International Journal of Cultural Property
An article on buying looted cultural property as rescue in contexts of political violence, with cases from Cambodia, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Ukraine and a discussion of Cyprus.
Hardy reviews open-source evidence on the purchase of looted cultural property as rescue from destruction or dispersal. Reporting, legal documents, institutional statements and investigations carry the examination of the practice and its consequences through cases from Cambodia, Afghanistan, Pakistan and Ukraine, with Cyprus discussed in the conclusion.
He argues that purchases presented as rescue can sustain demand for looted objects, incentivise further extraction and smuggling, and provide revenue to armed groups and other criminal actors. Claims of rescue can also obscure uncertain supply chains, launder assets or reputations, and make restitution harder, and Hardy asks how buyers could establish an object's origin, its risk of destruction or the destination of payment.
In Cambodia the case is the Kneeling Attendants from Koh Ker and the claim that their purchase protected them from the Khmer Rouge, set beside evidence of looting by armed forces during the conflicts of 1970–98. For Afghanistan and Pakistan Hardy examines the Schøyen Collection, manuscripts attributed to museum theft or looting, and accounts of transactions involving dealers, intermediaries and collectors. The Ukraine case concerns 24 paintings stolen from a Dutch museum in 2005, some recovered in 2016.
Hardy concludes that purchase-based rescue can contribute to political violence and the illicit market, and he sets commercial purchase against the practice of the Afghanistan Museum-in-Exile (pp. 17–20).
What it records
- Artworks removed from churches in Cyprus were, in Hardy's description, stolen to be ransomed back to the Republic of Cyprus.p. 17
- Illicit antiquities in Cyprus were bought by private collectors under a secret government policy and then legalised through amnesty, Hardy states.p. 17
- Douglas A. J. Latchford argued that the Koh Ker statues might have been shot at by the Khmer Rouge if they had not been smuggled out.p. 8
- Some manuscripts in Martin Schøyen's collection had been stolen from the National Museum in Kabul, Hardy states.p. 12
- Antiquities in Afghanistan were looted from sites, stolen from museums or subject to extortion by factions during conflicts, Hardy states.p. 13
- The Ukrainian Security Service recovered four paintings stolen from a Dutch museum on 14 April 2016.p. 15
- Buying objects in the name of rescue can create demand for further antiquities to be rescued, Hardy argues.p. 17
- The Afghanistan Museum-in-Exile does not acquire objects through commercial transactions.p. 19
Where to read
- The Schøyen Collection and Afghan and Pakistani manuscriptspp. 9–14
- Dutch paintings recovered in Ukraine and proposed paymentspp. 14–17
- Cyprus church artworks and government-policy acquisitionspp. 17–18
Contents
- Introduction1
- The argument in principle3
- The cost of keeping cultural property in the country of origin3
- Safe haven4
- A global practice and its global consequences5
- Financing of political violence in Cambodia and laundering of reputations around the world8
- Fuelling of an illicit market and financing of political violence in Afghanistan8
- The realities of “rescue” from Afghanistan and Pakistan10
- Obstacles to the return of cultural property and implications for acquisition11
- Laundering of antiquities and reputations with claims of “rescue” from Afghanistan11
- The realities of extraction from Afghanistan and Pakistan13
- Incentivization of “art-napping” for ransom in the Netherlands, financing of political violence in Ukraine, and weakening of international support for insecure democracies14
- Conclusion17
- “Rescue” by purchase in contexts of political violence18
- “Rescue” by purchase in crisis19
People, places and institutions
People
- Martin Schøyencollector of manuscripts and cultural objects
- Douglas A. J. Latchfordcollector who argued the statues were rescued
- Benazir Bhuttosaid the Begrami ivories were in safe keeping
- Naseerullah Khan Babarsaid a stolen ivory was in safe keeping
- Zaman Khanassociated with looting and excavation negotiations
- Marianne Yaldizmuseum director in acquisition correspondence
- Subhash Kapoordealer named in the account of acquisitions
Institutions
- Republic of Cyprusrecipient of ransomed church artworks
- National Museum of Afghanistansource of stolen cultural property
- Afghanistan Museum-in-Exilerefuge for endangered cultural property
- British Librarybuyer of manuscripts from Afghanistan and Pakistan
- Schøyen Collectioncollection discussed in the Afghanistan and Pakistan cases
- Metropolitan Museum of Artrecipient of the Kneeling Attendants
- Biblical Archaeology Societyadvocated rescuing unprovenanced artifacts
- Westfries Museumowner of the paintings stolen in 2005
- Ukrainian Security Servicerecovered four stolen paintings
- UNESCOapproved a refuge for Afghan cultural property
Places
- Koh Kersource of the Kneeling Attendants
- Jobarlocation of a synagogue in the Syria case
Also named: National Archives of Afghanistan, Suleymaniyah Museum, Directorate of Antiquities in Suleymaniyah, J. Paul Getty Trust, Museum of the Louvre.
Extent pp. 1–22; bibliography
ModernLooting and the LawCollectingMuseumsHistory of Archaeology
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
1 pageCorrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.