Article · 2004
Measures against the illicit trade in cultural objects: The emerging strategy in Britain
D. Gaimster
Antiquity 78(301) 699-707
An article on British measures against the illicit trade in cultural objects, from accession to the 1970 UNESCO Convention to the 2003 Act and the proposed accession to the 1954 Hague Convention.
Gaimster surveys the British response to the illicit trade in cultural objects, from accession to the 1970 UNESCO Convention and the Dealing in Cultural Objects (Offences) Act 2003 to enforcement, due diligence and the protection of cultural property in armed conflict. He draws on the recommendations of the Illicit Trade Advisory Panel, parliamentary inquiries and debates, government guidance, legislation and statements by government departments and trade bodies.
Voluntary codes and existing theft offences, he argues, do not adequately cover objects illegally excavated or removed from monuments and wrecks. Gaimster presents a new offence, international cooperation and stronger intelligence as ways to reduce the market for unlawfully removed objects while supporting legitimate trade (pp. 700–702). The 2003 Act covers dishonest dealing in objects known or believed to have been illegally excavated or removed, and the prosecution must prove dishonesty and knowledge or belief. Gaimster describes proposed databases and translated cultural-property laws as tools for due diligence and enforcement.
The closing section sets out the provisions of the 1954 Hague Convention and relates them to the looting of cultural property in Iraq. In 2003 the Ministry of Defence accepted UK ratification of the Convention and its two Protocols, and the Department for Culture, Media and Sport announced an accession programme in May 2004 (pp. 704–706).
What it records
- The UK Government acceded to the 1970 UNESCO Convention in October 2002.p. 701
- The Dealing in Cultural Objects (Offences) Act 2003 came into force on 30 December 2003.p. 702
- The Act defines dealing in a tainted cultural object as acquiring, disposing of, importing or exporting it, or arranging to do so.p. 702
- The Act provides for a Crown Court sentence of up to seven years' imprisonment, an unlimited fine, or both.p. 702
- The Iraq (UN Sanctions) Order 2003 made it a criminal offence to deal in or hold Iraqi cultural property removed after 6 August 1990.p. 704
- By the end of May 2004, UNESCO had received more than 26 pieces of legislation for its electronic cultural property legislation database.p. 704
- In 2003 the Ministry of Defence confirmed that it was content for the UK to ratify the Hague Convention and its two Protocols.p. 706
Where to read
- The new offence, its scope and penaltiesp. 702
- Proposed intelligence and due-diligence toolspp. 703–704
- Iraq and the 1954 Hague Conventionpp. 704–706
Contents
- Introduction699
- International co-operation: accession to the 1970 UNESCO Convention701
- The need for a new criminal offence701
- How the new offence works702
- Impact on the marketplace702
- Next steps: testing the system702
- Epilogue: Iraq, Hague Convention and beyond704
- References706
People, places and institutions
People
- Lord Renfrewdiscussed the illicit antiquities trade
- Norman Palmerchaired the Illicit Trade Advisory Panel
Institutions
- Department for Culture, Media and Sportdeveloped policy and the accession programme
- UNESCOadministers the convention and a legislation database
- Illicit Trade Advisory Panelreviewed legislative and non-legislative options
- House of Commons Culture, Media and Sport Select Committeeinquired into cultural property and illicit trade
- HM Customsworked on enforcement and export controls
- Ministry of Defencereviewed UK policy on the Hague Convention
- Standing Conference on Portable Antiquitiescalled for UK ratification of the Hague Convention
- Iraq National Museumlooted during the recent conflict
Places
- Londondescribed as a global supply-network centre
Also named: Estelle Morris, Lord McIntosh, British Art Market Federation, British Antiquities Dealers Association, UNIDROIT, Metropolitan Police, Council for British Archaeology, Baghdad.
Extent pp. 699–707, 1 fig.
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
5 pages- How to Sell Antiquities Legally: Laws, Provenance and StepsArticle
- Inherited Cypriot Antiquities? What You Have and Your OptionsArticle
- Selling Cypriot Antiquities Legally: A Step-by-Step GuideArticle
- Selling Cypriot Antiquities in the UK: Law, Auctions and ExportArticle
- Collecting Cypriot Antiquities Today: Law, Provenance and Due DiligenceCompendium
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.