Scholar · Cataloguer

Joachim Menant

fl. 1864–1912 · France

French magistrate at Rouen and specialist in Oriental cylinder seals (1820 to 1899), whose Recherches of 1886 were the first to go into the Cypriot cylinders.

Biography

Joachim Menant was a French magistrate who studied Oriental cylinder seals, and in his Recherches sur la glyptique orientale he was, in Ferdinand Dümmler's words of 1886, the first to go into the Cypriot cylinders to some extent4.

A magistrate at Rouen

He was born on 16 April 1820, the son of Joachim Menant and Amable Boissière, and was ten when his father died5. Delaporte gives Cherbourg as his birthplace6. At Caen he studied law, with little enthusiasm at first; his enthusiasm was for philosophy, taught by A. Charma5.

His first wife, Mlle Régnée, daughter of a counsellor at the Court of Caen, died after six months5. Some years later he married Mlle Lefebvre, daughter of the director of naval construction at Cherbourg5. Menant became an advocate, was named substitut in 1851, and finally became counsellor at the Court of Appeal of Rouen5. On 15 April 1878, as judge at the civil court of Rouen, he was given a mission to England to study collections of Assyro-Chaldaean cylinders7.

Beside the law he worked on Assyria, and on 27 March 1861 he read to the Académie des Inscriptions a memoir on the elementary principles of reading Assyrian texts5. His Assyrian grammar of 1868 glossed one country name as "evidently" the island of Cyprus8. Perrot and Chipiez cited his Annales des rois d'Assyrie for the tribute the Cypriot kings paid to Esarhaddon9. The Académie elected him a membre libre on 3 February 18885.

The cylinders from Cyprus

In 1884 Georges Perrot and Chipiez took most of their chapter on Chaldaeo-Assyrian seals from Menant, who, they wrote, had studied cylinders more deeply than any other scholar for many years10. They credited him with first suggesting and sketching a classification of the cylinders, and they found the evidence he gave for schools at Ur, Erech and Agade apparently of value in many cases10. Max Ohnefalsch-Richter later reported that Perrot, on those same pages, condemned the classification as too detailed3.

The first volume of the Recherches (1883) noted that Menant already knew the cylinders from General Cesnola's excavations in New York11. The second volume treated the Cypriot cylinders on pp. 241-2524.

Dümmler objected that Menant built his history of these cylinders on the statements of the Cesnola brothers, one of whom placed them all at Curium and the other at Salamis4. By Dümmler's account Menant thus put all the cylinders in the second Babylonian empire, with the mid-fifth century as lower limit, on the wrong assumption of a temple treasure hidden from war4. Dümmler also said Menant overlooked L. di Cesnola's own admission that he had bought cylinders from the necropolis near Nicosia, and that even the oldest Cypriot cylinders followed Babylonian models but were not such late imitations as Menant believed4. He agreed with Menant that Assyrian models were almost never copied on them4.

Ohnefalsch-Richter repeated in 1893 that, as Dümmler had shown, Menant had often been led into error on the date and character of the Cypriot cylinders by trusting the Cesnolas' data too much3. He called one of Menant's figures a bad reproduction, yet judged that, though details would need correcting, Menant's work "will always retain its value as the foundation of an enduring structure"3. John L. Myres still cited the second volume in 1914 for cylinders in the Cesnola Collection in New York2. William Hayes Ward called Menant "the teacher of all subsequent scholars" in the study of these stones12.

The de Clercq catalogue

The first volume of the catalogue of Louis de Clercq's cylinders (1888) was published by de Clercq with Menant's collaboration; de Clercq wrote the descriptions, while Menant was responsible for the method, the classification and the reading of the inscriptions13. The catalogue says cylinders were made particularly in the colonies, in Cyprus above all, and that only groups whose finding explorers had recorded, as in Cyprus and Sardinia, could be judged with certainty13. Ohnefalsch-Richter disputed the catalogue's attributions: of the cylinders Menant there called archaic Chaldaean, he held five certainly and one probably Cypriot3.

The Urkham cylinder

On 2 August 1889 Menant told the Académie that a Chaldaean cylinder in the British Museum bearing the name of Urkham raised doubts about its authenticity14,15. Claude Delaval Cobham wrote from Larnaca on 23 August that an executor of Dr Hine had handed him the cylinder days after Hine's funeral, and that it never left him until he gave it to the British Museum in September 188015. Menant accepted that it therefore could not have been made from Rich's drawing, but held that the letter only moved the date of its making and did not undo his criticism15.

Last years

La Trémoïlle wrote that after Menant settled in Paris his health suffered a shock, and that a grave illness of his daughter in May 1899 dealt him a blow from which he did not recover5. The sources disagree on the day of his death in August 1899: La Trémoïlle gives 28 August, aged 795, while Delaporte, who places it in Paris, and the American Journal of Archaeology give 30 August6,16. His daughter Delphine Menant continued his Persian and Avestan studies12.

Life and work

  1. 1886

    1. His Recherches sur la glyptique orientale (2 vols., Paris, dated 1883-6 in Myres) was cited by later Cypriot writers for cylinder seals found by the Cesnolas, e.g. Salaminia nos. XIV, 57 and XIV, 34 = Menant II p. 249 figs 252-253.

      J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art; Max Ohnefalsch-Richter (1893). Kypros, the Bible and Homer. London, Asher & Co.

Connections

3 people
Claude Delaval CobhamLouis Constantin Henri Fr…D' John HineJoachim Menant
DisputesScholarshipColleagues

Mentioned in

5 mentions

Sources

  1. 1.J. Menant (1883-1886). Recherches sur la glyptique orientale. Paris.
  2. 2.J. L. Myres (1914). Handbook of the Cesnola Collection of Antiquities from Cyprus. New York, Metropolitan Museum of Art.
  3. 3.Max Ohnefalsch-Richter (1893). Kypros, the Bible and Homer. London, Asher & Co..
  4. 4.F. Dümmler (1886). “Mittheilungen von den griechischen Inseln, IV. Aelteste Nekropolen auf Cypern”. Mittheilungen des Deutschen Archaeologischen Instituts, Athenische Abtheilung 11, 209-262.
  5. 5.Duc de La Trémoïlle (1901). “Notice sur la vie et les travaux de M. J. Menant”. Comptes rendus des séances de l'Académie des inscriptions et belles-lettres. Paris.
  6. 6.L. Delaporte (1909). Catalogue du Musée Guimet: cylindres orientaux. Paris: E. Leroux.
  7. 7.Ministère de l'Instruction publique (1878). “[Table of scientific missions granted, year 1878]”. Archives des missions scientifiques et littéraires.
  8. 8.Joachim Menant (1868). Exposé des éléments de la grammaire assyrienne.
  9. 9.G. Perrot and C. Chipiez (1885). Histoire de l'art dans l'antiquité, III: Phénicie, Cypre.
  10. 10.G. Perrot and C. Chipiez (1884). Histoire de l'art dans l'antiquité, II: Chaldée et Assyrie.
  11. 11.Joachim Menant (1883). Recherches sur la glyptique orientale. Première partie: Cylindres de la Chaldée.
  12. 12.William Hayes Ward (1910). The Seal Cylinders of Western Asia. Washington, D.C.: Carnegie Institution of Washington.
  13. 13.L. de Clercq, with J. Menant (1888). Collection de Clercq: catalogue méthodique et raisonné. Antiquités assyriennes, cylindres orientaux, cachets, briques, bronzes, bas-reliefs, etc. Tome premier: Cylindres orientaux. Paris: Ernest Leroux.
  14. 14. (1889). “[Report of the Académie des Inscriptions sitting on Menant's Urkham cylinder]”. Journal des débats politiques et littéraires.
  15. 15.Joachim Menant (1889). “[On a Chaldaean cylinder in the British Museum, with a postscript on Cobham's letter]”. Revue archéologique.
  16. 16. (1900). “[News note: death of Joachim Menant]”. American Journal of Archaeology, 2nd series 4.
  17. 17.Journal des débats politiques et littéraires, 1889, Issues of 5 Aug and 21 Sept 1889 (Hine cylinder correspondence), 21 Sept 1889; J. Menant, 1889, Le cylindre d'Urkham au Musée britannique, pp. 322-324; Journal des débats politiques et littéraires, 1889, Issues of 5 Aug and 21 Sept 1889 (Hine cylinder correspondence), issue 21 Sept 1889.
  18. 18.Journal des débats politiques et littéraires (1889-09-21).
  19. 19.Chuqut, Revue critique D histoire et de litterature 1815 (1915).
  20. 20.L. de Clercq and J. Menant, 1888, Collection de Clercq. Catalogue méthodique et raisonné. Tome I: Cylindres orientaux, Paris: E. Leroux.
  21. 21.The Athenaeum 1889-09-28: Iss 3231 (1889).
  22. 22.Société scientifique et littéraire des instituteurs de France, Revue des sciences et des lettres (1889-01-01).
  23. 23.Ernest Leroux, Revue Archeologique Troisieme Serie Tome.14 (1889).
  24. 24.Chuqut, Revue Critique D Histoire Et De Litterature 1912 (1912).

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Date of birth unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.