Article · 1987

The Cypriote Surrender to Persia

Henry J. Watkin

Journal of Hellenic Studies 107 154-163

An article on when Cyprus came under Persian rule, weighing Xenophon's Cyropaedia and Herodotus against the claim that Cypriote sculpture records a political realignment.

Watkin reassesses when Cyprus became part of the Persian Empire and examines the argument that political allegiance shaped the development and distribution of Cypriote sculpture. Three numbered sections take Xenophon's account, Herodotus' chronology and the archaeological arguments in turn, comparing passages in the Cyropaedia and Herodotus with evidence for Persian naval power and the sequence of the Egyptian campaign.

Watkin argues that the Cyropaedia is an unreliable independent source for Cyrus' conquests and for the status of Cyprus, since its account serves an idealizing portrait of the ruler. He reads Herodotus on the Cypriote surrender as placing it close to the Cypriote share in Kambyses' expedition against Egypt. Persian control of the sea depended on the Phoenician fleet, he argues, which makes annexation of Cyprus before the Egyptian campaign unlikely, and he concludes that Cyprus was annexed during the campaign, at about the time Persian naval power developed (pp. 156–160). Watkin also associates the submission of Phoenicia, Cyprus and the East Greek cities with the preparations for the Egyptian campaign.

He then challenges Gjerstad's reading of Cypriote sculpture as evidence for a political realignment around 545 BC. His discussion takes in Vermeule's interpretation of Egyptianizing motifs, Schmidt's chronology of the sculpture from Samos, and the evidence for Cypriote sculpture and workshops at Naukratis, drawing on studies of limestone and terracotta figures, the stratigraphic dating of finds from the Heraion on Samos, clay analysis and the inscription on a statue base from Naukratis. Watkin rejects the claim that Cypriote workshops in Samos, Rhodes and Naukratis closed because Cyprus submitted (pp. 161–163).

What it records

  • Watkin argues that the Cyropaedia should not be trusted as evidence about Cyrus unless other sources corroborate it.p. 156
  • Watkin places the submission of Phoenicia, Cyprus and the East Greek cities between early 526 and spring 525 BC.p. 160
  • Watkin argues that Persia had no effective naval capability before the invasion of Egypt.p. 161
  • Schmidt's chronology places the end of the Neo-Cypriote class shortly before 550 BC at the latest.p. 162
  • Watkin argues from their material and local style that the alabaster figures at Naukratis were made there.p. 162
  • Watkin dates the inscription on a statue base found at Naukratis to the fourth century, on the evidence of its letter forms.p. 163

Where to read

  • Xenophon’s account of Cyprus under Cyruspp. 156–158
  • Persian naval power and the date of Cyprus’ submissionpp. 158–161
  • Cypriote sculpture at Samos and Naukratispp. 161–163

Contents

  • I156
  • II158
  • III161

People, places and institutions

People

  • Xenophonauthor of the *Cyropaedia*
  • Herodotussource for the surrender and the campaign
  • KambysesPersian king who campaigned in Egypt
  • Cyrusking whose reign is central to the dating
  • Hilldated the surrender before the fall of Babylon
  • Gjerstadlinked sculpture chronology to political change
  • Breitenbachanalysed the *Cyropaedia*
  • C. Vermeulereinterpreted Egyptianizing sculpture
  • Gerhard Schmidtstudied Cypriote statuary from Samos

Places

  • Samosfindspot of Cypriote statuary
  • Rhodesfindspot of Cypriote statuary
  • Naukratisfindspot of sculpture and statue-base inscription
  • Phoeniciasource of Persian naval strength
  • Egyptdestination of Kambyses’ campaign

Extent pp. 154–163

Cypro-ArchaicCypro-ClassicalSculptureForeign ContactsChronology and DatingHistory of Archaeology

Who did what

1 record

Recording and study 1

  • Gerhard SchmidtStudied

    Gerhard Schmidt studied Cypriote figures from the Heraion on Samos, mostly terracottas and some limestone sculptures.

    Cypriote statuary found at the Heraion on Samos

    p. 162

People it is cited for

4 people

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.