Article · 2007
Not such a new light: a response to Ammerman and Noller
Alan Simmons and Rolfe Mandel
World Archaeology
A response to Ammerman and Noller’s critique of Akrotiri Aetokremnos, covering occupation, sea level, radiocarbon dating and claims for other early sites in Cyprus.
Simmons and Mandel respond to Ammerman and Noller’s critique of Akrotiri Aetokremnos. They revisit the interpretation of the rockshelter and its fauna, the setting of the site, the chronology and claims for other pre-Neolithic sites in Cyprus. The response draws on the site’s stratigraphy, chipped stone assemblage, faunal remains, sediment evidence and radiocarbon determinations, as well as the authors’ earlier excavation and final-report work.
They argue that human activity at Aetokremnos and the hippo remains in Stratum 4 are associated, and that the evidence supports treating the site as an occupation even if it was brief. The proposed continuous sand ramp, they maintain, is unsupported by the slope, sediment and erosion evidence (pp. 476–479).
The early Aetokremnos occupation is set against the later Cypro-Pre-Pottery Neolithic B and a possible PPNA occupation. Levels 2 and 4 are separated, the authors state, by little time. They urge caution about dating surface lithic sites until numerical dates and further analyses are available, and conclude that the chronology of the newly claimed surface sites remains uncertain (pp. 479–481).
What it records
- Simmons and Mandel associate the Aetokremnos occupation with an assemblage of over 500 individuals of the endemic and extinct Cypriot pygmy hippopotamus.p. 476
- Simmons and Mandel report that the Aetokremnos occupation is dated to around 10,000 cal. BCE.p. 476
- Stratum 4 contains 120 chipped stone artifacts, including eleven tools, amounting to 8.5 per cent of the entire chipped stone assemblage.p. 477
- The shoreline during the occupation lay about 1.5 km farther out than it does today, the authors state.p. 477
- Of 31 radiocarbon determinations from Aetokremnos, the authors reject three surface hippo bone samples as unreliable, leaving 28, of which six are on hippo bone.p. 479
- Oxford could not date 22 further bone samples from all strata submitted by Simmons and Mandel: 11 hippo, 2 elephant and 9 bird.p. 479
- A Level 2 charcoal sample submitted to Oxford returned a determination of 10,185 cal. BCE (OxA-15989).p. 479
- With the bone dates omitted, Simmons and Mandel count 22 dates for the site: sixteen from Level 2, two from the mixed Stratum 2/4 zone and four from Stratum 4.p. 480
Where to read
- Occupation, shelter dimensions and Stratum 4 artifactspp. 476–477
- Sea-level and sand-ramp interpretationspp. 477–479
- Radiocarbon determinations and proposed early sitespp. 479–481
Contents
- Human occupation476
- Sea levels477
- Chronology479
- Other issues480
People, places and institutions
Places
- Akrotiri Aetokremnosearly Holocene rockshelter discussed throughout
- KhirokitiaNeolithic comparison site
- Akrotiri Peninsulasetting of Aetokremnos
Also named: Sturt Manning, Carole McCartney, Tom Davis, Vassilou.
Extent pp. 475–482, 1 pl.; bibliography
Defines Akrotiri Phase
NeolithicChronology and DatingAnimalsLandscape and ClimateSettlements
Excavations it is cited for
1 project- 1987–2009Akrotiri-Aetokremnos: the Simmons excavationsDirected by Alan H. Simmons and Steve HeldExcavation
Who did what
3 recordsExcavation 1
- p. 476
Alan H. SimmonsExcavated withRolfe D. Mandel
Alan Simmons and Rolfe Mandel referred to four seasons of excavations at Aetokremnos as their own.
Recording and study 2
- p. 479
Alan H. SimmonsRecorded
A charcoal sample from Level 2 was submitted and returned a determination of 10,185 cal. BC.
one charcoal sample from Level 2No. OxA-15989Oxford's facility
- p. 479
Rolfe D. MandelRecorded
A charcoal sample from Level 2 was submitted and returned a determination of 10,185 cal. BC.
one charcoal sample from Level 2No. OxA-15989Oxford's facility
People it is cited for
1 person- Albert J. Ammerman3 citations
Institutions it is cited for
1 institutionCorrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.