Article · 2013

Lead isotopic analysis within a multiproxy approach to trace pottery sources: The example of White Slip II sherds from Late Bronze Age sites in Cyprus and Syria

V. Renson, A. Martínez-Cortizas, N. Mattielli, J. Coenaerts, C. Sauvage, F. De Vleeschouwer, C. Lorre, F. Vanhaecke, R. Bindler, M. Rautman, K. Nys and P. Claeys

Applied Geochemistry

An article on lead-isotope, elemental and mineralogical analyses of White Slip II sherds from Hala Sultan Tekke, Sanidha and Minet el-Beida, tracing their clay sources and clay preparation.

Renson and colleagues compare White Slip II sherds from Hala Sultan Tekke, Sanidha and Minet el-Beida with clay samples collected around Sanidha. Lead-isotope analysis is combined with X-ray fluorescence, principal component analysis, mineralogical analysis and selected SEM-EDX measurements, to test whether the assemblages can be linked to potential raw materials. They also ask whether differences in isotopic signature can reflect sulfide content or clay preparation.

The Sanidha group has 30 sherds across White Slip II, Monochrome and Coarse Monochrome wares. The Hala Sultan Tekke set takes in settlement sherds, among them material from deposit F6031, and three samples from Tomb 24. From Minet el-Beida come five White Slip II and six White Slip II late sherds from chamber tomb III [1005]. Sherd surfaces were cleaned before the powders were prepared for isotope analysis (pp. 221–225).

Renson and colleagues find that Sanidha pottery has a narrow, homogeneous lead-isotope signature, compatible with weathered local gabbro, and the authors conclude that Moni formation clays are not the source of the White Slip II studied. Most Hala Sultan Tekke sherds and three Minet el-Beida sherds are compatible with Sanidha, whereas other Minet el-Beida sherds point to a separate source that is not identified. The analyses also indicate that finer clay fractions were selected before the pottery was made (pp. 227–233).

Renson and colleagues place White Slip ware in the Late Bronze Age and describe its spread in the Eastern Mediterranean in the 14th and 13th centuries BC. Sanidha White Slip II is assigned to Late Cypriote II, which they date from the last quarter of the 15th century BC to the end of the 13th century BC.

What it records

  • Hala Sultan Tekke flourished from the second half of the 14th century BCE to the first half of the 12th century BCE.p. 221
  • The Sanidha sample set has 19 White Slip II, seven Monochrome and four Coarse Monochrome sherds, all collected from the surface.p. 222
  • The Minet el-Beida sherds studied, five White Slip II and six White Slip II late, come from the ashlar-built chamber tomb III [1005].p. 222
  • The researchers collected 29 clay and soil samples around Sanidha, all but two from within 10 km of the site.p. 222
  • Weathered gabbro near Sanidha is identified as the source of the pottery made there, in the authors' conclusion.p. 233
  • White Slip II at Minet el-Beida has two origins in the authors' proposal: Sanidha for some sherds, and a source not yet identified for the rest.p. 233

Where to read

  • Archaeological contexts and sampled groups at the three sitespp. 221–222
  • Clay sampling, laboratory methods and lead-isotope resultspp. 222–227
  • Source interpretation and clay preparationpp. 228–233

Contents

  • 1. Introduction220
  • 2. Archaeological settings of the pottery samples221
  • 2.1. Hala Sultan Tekke221
  • 2.2. Sanidha221
  • 2.3. Minet el-Beida222
  • 3. Clay samples222
  • 4. Methods222
  • 4.1. Lead isotopic analysis222
  • 4.2. X-ray fluorescence222
  • 4.3. Mineralogy of clay samples (XRD) and elemental analysis of selected sherds (SEM-EDX)224
  • 4.4. Statistical analysis224
  • 5. Results224
  • 5.1. Bulk and clay mineralogy of the sediments224
  • 5.2. Sem-edx224
  • 5.3. Xrf225
  • 5.4. Lead isotope ratios225
  • 6. Discussion227
  • 6.1. Principal component analysis228
  • 7. Conclusions233
  • Acknowledgements233
  • References234

People, places and institutions

People

  • Ian Toddprovided Sanidha pottery samples
  • Öbrinkstudied the Hala Sultan Tekke sherd deposit
  • Xenophontosreported petrographic analyses of Sanidha sherds

Places

  • SanidhaWhite Slip pottery production site
  • Hala Sultan Tekkesource of White Slip II sherds
  • Minet el-Beidasource of tomb sherds

Also named: Ugarit, Ras Shamra, Kalavasos-Ayios Dhimritios, Alison South, Paul Åström, Popham, Musée d'Archéologie Nationale, Vrije Universiteit Brussel, Université Libre de Bruxelles.

Extent pp. 220–234, 6 figs including location maps and a simplified geological map; references

Late Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgePotteryTradeCraft ProductionChronology and Dating

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

2 pages

Who did what

3 records

Recording and study 3

  • U. ÖbrinkStudied

    Öbrink studied sherds from a deposit (F6031) at Hala Sultan Tekke.

    White Slip sherds from a sherd deposit (F6031)

    p. 221
  • C. XenophontosStudied

    Xenophontos conducted petrographic analyses of White Slip II and Monochrome sherds from Sanidha.

    p. 222
  • Ellen HerscherStudied

    Herscher investigated ceramics from Sanidha and discussed their dominant White Slip II style.

    p. 232

Mentioned in

3 mentions

Tomb records · 1

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.