Article · 2022

Between Frustration and Progress: An Integrated Cypro-Minoan Signary and Its Paleographic Diversity

Martina Polig and Cassandra M. Donnelly

Studi Micenei ed Egeo-Anatolici, Nuova Serie 8 41-62

An article on Cypro-Minoan sign classification, presenting an 88-sign integrated signary and the variation in sign shapes across periods, regions and writing media.

Polig and Donnelly review the history of Cypro-Minoan signaries and propose an integrated signary that treats Cypro-Minoan as one script and classifies signs by shape. They argue that the CM1, CM2 and CM3 divisions have fewer unique signs and less distinct paleographies than earlier signaries suggested, and that sign overlap and shared paleographic features weaken the case for separate scripts.

The signary rests on Polig's dataset of 251 inscriptions counted by 2019, of which she documented 154 objects in 3D, and it admits signs only where the readings are reliable and verifiable. It holds 88 unique signs and 278 variants, of which 204 are classed as reliable, 43 as likely and 31 as problematic, and the authors state that new inscriptions may change the inventory and the placement of variants. Sign shapes are compared across inscriptions with 3D models, digital databases and purpose-built Python scripts (pp. 45–53).

The variation examined covers dots and short strokes, which the article finds are interchangeable across materials and periods, changes between inclined and orthogonal lines, and lines made in multiple strokes. Polig and Donnelly report that this practice occurs at southern Cypriot sites, Ugarit and Tiryns, and the authors associate it with prestige or non-quotidian objects. The authors state that X-shaped variants occur from LCI through the final phase of Cypro-Minoan writing. The authors argue that paleographic diversity persists across periods, regions and media, and that it suggests Cypro-Minoan writing was more widespread than the surviving inscriptions show.

What it records

  • Polig's integrated signary draws on 251 texts that had been counted as inscriptions by 2019.p. 45
  • Polig documented 154 objects in 3D at sub-millimetre resolution.p. 45
  • The Ras Shamra material, all held at the Damascus Museum, was left out of the study because it could not be accessed during the Syrian civil war.p. 46
  • Polig identified 278 sign variants through comparisons across the inscriptions, adding to Olivier's list.p. 49
  • The integrated signary contains 88 signs.p. 51
  • Of the 278 variants, the authors classify 204 as reliable, 43 as likely and 31 as problematic.p. 53
  • Variants that render one line in multiple strokes occur only at sites on the south coast of Cyprus, at Ugarit and at Tiryns.p. 57
  • Donnelly's claim that paleographic diversity marks single-sign texts as the work of writers literate in Cypro-Minoan can now be tested with better data, the authors state.p. 60

Where to read

  • Dataset composition, exclusions and 3D documentationpp. 45–48
  • Integrated signary and variant classificationpp. 49–53
  • Paleographic variation across materials, periods and sitespp. 54–59

Contents

  • 2. Aims44
  • 3. Data and Conventions44
  • 3.1 Definitions44
  • 3.2 The Data Set45
  • 3.3 Looking at the Material in New Ways46
  • 3.4 What Does 3D Add?47
  • 3.5 The CM1-CM2-CM3 Subdivision - Working with One Signary and Why48
  • 4. The Integrated Signary49
  • 4.1 The Rearrangement of Signs and Variants, in Brief51
  • 4.2 The Reliability of Sign Variant Readings51
  • 4.2.1 A Note on Épines53
  • 4.3 'Sign Use' as Criterion53
  • 5. Paleographic Diversity According to the Overarching Rules of Sign Variation54
  • 5.1 Dot-Linear Stroke Alternation54
  • 5.2 Changes in Line Orientation: X-H, V-U, and Other Patterns56
  • 5.3 Single Line-Multiple Stroke Alternation57
  • 5.4 Sign 102 and Its Variants58
  • 6. Outlook and Conclusion59

Objects published here

3
  • stone anchor bearing an inscription, ADD##224 ENKO Pblo 002, 1 (p. 47)
  • metal object with a Cypro-Minoan inscription, Pyla-Kokkinokremos, ##177 PYLA Mlin 001, 2 (p. 47)
  • clay ball with an inscription, Enkomi, ##056 ENKO Abou 053, 2, 3 (p. 47)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Oliviercompiled a signary and a list of inscriptions
  • É. Massonproposed a tripartite script division
  • Ferraraproduced a signary and a list of inscriptions
  • Valérioproposed sign readings and variant groupings
  • John Franklin Danielset criteria for identifying script signs
  • Philippa Steelediscussed the status of épines

Institutions

  • Damascus Museumholds the Ras Shamra material

Places

  • Enkomisource of numerous Cypro-Minoan inscriptions
  • Ras Shamrasource of inscriptions omitted from 3D study
  • Pyla-Kokkinokremossource of tablets and prestige goods
  • Tirynssite with Cypro-Minoan inscriptions
  • Ugaritsource of inscriptions and sign variants

Also named: Erimi-Kafkalla, Palaepaphos-Skales, Ashkelon, Melos, Hala Sultan Tekke, Department of Antiquities, Cyprus, Alice Kober, Palaima.

Extent pp. 41–62, figs 1–11; bibliography

Defines signary, script, paleography, ductus

Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricWritingChronology and DatingTechnology

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

2 pages

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.