Article · 2015
Telling Stories: The Mycenaean Origins of the Philistines
G. D. Middleton
Oxford Journal of Archaeology 34(1) 45-65
An article on the claim that the Philistines were Mycenaean migrants to Canaan around 1200 BCE, weighing the Egyptian texts and the pottery, diet, script, figurine and architectural evidence.
Middleton examines the narrative that identifies the Philistines as Mycenaean or Aegean arrivals in Canaan around 1200 BCE. He traces how the story took shape, tests the textual and material evidence for it, and proposes reading Aegeanizing objects and practices through continuing contact, local choices and cultural hybridity.
Middleton argues that the Sea Peoples migration story rests heavily on nineteenth-century readings of Egyptian monuments, and that those records do not establish a migration. He also finds implausible both the refugee and the mass-migration accounts of why and by what routes people moved from Greece to Canaan (pp. 47–49).
The material evidence includes locally made pottery with Mycenaean features, dietary remains, cooking equipment, inscribed pot handles and an ostracon, figurines, hearths, bathtubs and loomweights. He sets these against evidence from Greece, Cyprus and the wider eastern Mediterranean and asks how local practice, status and exchange could shape their use (pp. 49–58).
Middleton concludes that no category of evidence, alone or together, proves a Mycenaean migration or shows that migrants became Philistines. Philistine material culture draws on several sources, and Middleton offers local agency and continued maritime contacts as alternatives to a straightforward migration account. The dates the migration account commonly gives, around 1200 BCE and, sometimes from pottery styles, the second quarter of the twelfth century BCE, he treats as claims within that account (pp. 58–60).
What it records
- Emmanuelle de Rougé published his translation of the Year 8 inscription of Ramesses III from Medinet Habu in 1855.p. 47
- Mycenaean-type pottery had circulated in the eastern Mediterranean for over two centuries and had been found at more than one hundred Levantine sites.p. 51
- The Ashkelon evidence discussed comprises 18 inscribed pot handles and an ostracon; five pots came from Cyprus and one from Crete.p. 55
- About 120 Philistine figurines are known, against more than 1,000 from Mycenae alone.p. 57
- A monumental circular hearth at Ekron, 1.2 m across, had a pebble base and plastered edges.p. 57
- Middleton points to continued maritime contacts between Greece, the Aegean and Cyprus in the west and Cyprus, Cilicia and the Levant in the east.p. 59
- Middleton describes mobility as a normal feature of life in the eastern Mediterranean and separates movement of people from proof of the proposed migration.p. 60
Where to read
- Philistine pottery names and mixed stylistic sourcespp. 50–52
- Diet, cooking equipment and the use of food as evidencepp. 52–55
- Ashkelon inscriptions, figurines and hearthspp. 55–58
Contents
- Introduction45
- Questioning the Migration Narrative47
- Physical Evidence49
- Pottery and nomenclature50
- Dietary practices52
- Cooking techniques54
- Linear script55
- Figurines56
- Hearths57
- ‘Bathtubs’ and textiles58
- Conclusions58
- Acknowledgements60
- References60
People, places and institutions
People
- Emmanuelle de Rougétranslated the Year 8 inscription of Ramesses III
- Yasur-Landauadvocates migration interpretations
- Karageorghisproposes elite flight through Cyprus
- Dothandiscusses Philistine material evidence
- Ben-Shlomoanalyses figurines and domestic material
- Stageradvocates migration interpretations
- Sherrattdiscusses pottery and material exchange
- Sandarsquestions Philistine origins and pottery
- Drewschallenges migration interpretations
- Killebrewdiscusses pottery and hearths
- Hirschfelddiscusses Cypro-Minoan script
Places
- Medinet Habusource of the Year 8 inscription
- Ashkelon18 inscribed pot handles and an ostracon
- Ekronfigurine and hearth evidence
- Pyloscomparison for cooking and hearths
Also named: Chabas, Maspero, Ashdod.
Extent pp. 45–65; bibliography pp. 60–65
Late Bronze AgeCypro-GeometricModernPotteryForeign ContactsFood and FarmingWritingFigurines
Cited on Ancient Cyprus
2 pages- Late Bronze Age CyprusCompendium
- The PhilistinesCompendium
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.