Book · 2021

Migration Myths and the End of the Bronze Age in the Eastern Mediterranean

A. B. Knapp

Cambridge: Cambridge University Press

A study of migration claims for the end of the Late Bronze Age in the eastern Mediterranean, centred on the southern Levant and weighing material culture, climate, isotope and ancient DNA evidence.

Knapp examines how migration and mobility have been interpreted in archaeology and then assesses claims that Aegean or other groups moved into the southern Levant at the end of the Late Bronze Age. He reviews material culture, texts and iconography, environmental studies, ancient DNA and isotope research, and considers how movement and cultural interaction might be studied without assuming that material traits identify ethnic groups. The discussion centres on the twelfth and eleventh centuries BCE and the proposed migration around c. 1200 BCE.

How it is organised

Six chapters begin with an introduction and a survey of migration studies and their archaeological correlates. The third reviews migration scenarios in the Late Bronze Age eastern Mediterranean, including the migrationist and anti-migrationist views and debates about ethnicity. A fourth chapter takes up climate and palaeogenetics, a fifth mobility and migration in the southern Levant, and a sixth draws conclusions. References follow the main text (pp. 71–91).

The argument

Knapp challenges the Philistine model, which treats new material assemblages as evidence for a migration from the Aegean, and sets against it a mercantile model centred on seafaring traders and the circulation of objects and practices. Pottery styles, cooking installations, loomweights and other traits cannot by themselves, he argues, establish the origins or ethnicity of the people who used them. He also questions large-scale migration estimates and calls for attention to varied forms of mobility and local interaction (pp. 10–38).

He regards multiple forms of movement, exchange and local change as more consistent with the regional variation in the evidence. The climate and genetic studies reviewed do not, in his account, settle the scale or mechanism of any migration, and different evidence sets may support different interpretations (pp. 67–70).

The evidence

The evidence comprises archaeological assemblages and settlement patterns, Egyptian reliefs and inscriptions, and studies of pottery, hearths, textile equipment, food practices, metalworking, burials and bodily adornment, with interpretations compared from sites including Ashkelon and Tell Tayinat. Knapp also reviews palaeoclimatic proxies and radiocarbon dates, ancient DNA, and strontium isotope studies of human remains and livestock (pp. 14–55).

On dating, he reviews competing dates for the appearance of Philistine material culture and notes that the chronologies proposed for climate events and for archaeological change often have broad ranges. He proposes no single revised date for the movement of people.

What it records

  • Knapp argues that estimates of 25,000 seaborne and 5,000 to 6,000 land migrants to the southern Levant lack material, documentary or historical support.p. 2
  • In Knapp's presentation, the Philistine model, which links material change in the southern Levant to Aegean traits, is the majority view and the mercantile model a minority explanation.p. 11
  • Tell Tayinat covered at least 10–12 hectares and possibly up to 20 hectares.p. 30
  • The calibrated date range cited for the 3.2 kyr event spans at least three hundred years, c.1320–1025 Cal BC.p. 41
  • The Ashkelon DNA study analysed ten human samples, including four from early Iron Age infant burials.p. 50
  • The Tel Dothan isotope study examined 543 molars from a tomb and found no non-local individuals.p. 52
  • A meta-analysis of strontium isotope data from Mediterranean funerary populations was reported to have found fewer than 10 per cent of individuals to be non-local.p. 63
  • Knapp concludes that the Levantine material evidence points to multiple and varied types of mobility; it does not indicate a single, uniform migratory event.p. 67
  • A local Levantine gene pool spanning well over a millennium is, in Knapp's view, the more significant implication of the aDNA studies reviewed.p. 69

Where to read

  • Migrationist interpretations and debates over Philistine originspp. 11–37
  • Ethnicity and the archaeological identification of groupspp. 38–39
  • Climate studies and the dating of the Late Bronze Age transitionpp. 40–45
  • Ancient DNA and strontium isotope studiespp. 45–54
  • Mobility, material evidence and social change in the southern Levantpp. 55–70

Contents

  • 1 Introduction2
  • 2 Migration Studies in Archaeology3
  • 3 Migration in the Late Bronze Age Eastern Mediterranean10
  • The Migrationist View13
  • Anti-migrationist Views31
  • Ethnicity38
  • 4 Migrations, Climate and Palaeogenetics40
  • Climate and Cultural Change40
  • Palaeogenetics (aDNA) and Strontium Isotope Analyses45
  • 5 Mobility, Migration and the Southern Levant at the End of the Late Bronze Age55
  • Some Questions Answered?61
  • 6 Conclusions67
  • References71

People, places and institutions

People

Places

  • southern Levantmain region of the study
  • Philistiaregion central to the migration debate
  • Aegeanproposed source region in migration scenarios
  • Tell TayinatIron Age I settlement
  • Ashkelonsite of archaeological and DNA evidence
  • Tel Dothansite of an isotope study

Extent figs 1–11; references pp. 71–91

Defines migration, mobility

Late Bronze AgeForeign ContactsChronology and DatingPotteryTradeLandscape and Climate

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

2 pages

Who did what

2 records

Posts and family 2

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.