Article

The material side of magic and its archaeological contexts (review of Wilburn 2012)

Alexander Hollmann

A review of *Materia Magica*, a study of how magical objects and their archaeological contexts are interpreted, with case studies at Karanis, Amathous and near Emporiae.

Wilburn's Materia Magica examines how objects and their archaeological contexts can be used to identify and interpret magic, moving from a theoretical discussion of magic and materia magica to case studies at Karanis, Amathous and near Emporiae. Hollmann outlines Wilburn's preference for an “etic” working definition based on ritual action, religious traditions and private or personal practice. He describes Wilburn's caution about using spell-books as direct templates for interpreting finds, and his emphasis on production, use, decoration and depositional context.

The five Karanis examples are a papyrus testimony, an amulet, an inscribed ostracon, a figurine with hairpins and groups of painted bones. Hollmann notes the limits of their contexts and weighs alternative readings of the ostracon and the figurine deposit. At Amathous he describes lead and selenite curse tablets recovered from a shaft, with the reports of their discovery and the uncertain interpretation of their placement. At Emporiae three lead tablets lay in separate cinerary urns, their texts naming Roman officials and inhabitants of nearby towns, and Wilburn associates them with a legal dispute (pp. 918–922).

Hollmann welcomes the attention to materiality and archaeological context but holds that some interpretations go beyond the evidence. He questions the proposed display of the curse tablets in a shaft at Amathous, and the claim that the Emporiae tablets express resistance to Roman rule.

What it records

  • Wilburn interprets the Karanis ostracon as a possible incomplete spell template or mnemonic device.p. 919
  • Wilburn dates the cache of lead and selenite tablets from Amathous to the late second or third century CE.p. 920
  • Villagers found the Amathous tablet cache while clearing an ancient shaft to prepare it for use as a well.p. 920
  • The three Ballesta tablets were each found in a separate cinerary urn, and the urns lay together in one part of the cemetery.p. 922
  • Hollmann concludes that Wilburn sometimes exaggerates what can be established from the archaeological evidence.p. 923

Where to read

  • Karanis case studies and the interpretation of their archaeological contextspp. 918–920
  • Amathous curse tablets, discovery reports and proposed depositionpp. 920–921
  • Ballesta tablets and the interpretation of resistance to Roman rulep. 922

People, places and institutions

People

  • Andrew T. Wilburnauthor of the book under review
  • Gemelluscomplainant in papyrus testimony
  • Juliusaccused in papyrus testimony
  • Captain Gerald Handcockreported shaft discovery to British Museum
  • Cecil Smithreported information about tablet discovery
  • H. C. Youtieproposed an alternative reading of ostracon
  • Theodorostarget of two curse texts

Places

  • Karanislocation of case studies
  • Amathousfindspot of curse tablets
  • Emporiaelocation of three curse tablets
  • Ballesta necropolisfindspot of three lead tablets

Also named: Fayum, British Museum, Timon, Metrodoros.

Extent pp. 917–923

RomanReligion and CultBurialWritingHistory of Archaeology

Who did what

4 records

Buying, selling and giving 1

  • J. HandcockConnected withBritish Museum

    Captain Gerald Handcock played a part in the sale of the tablets to the British Museum.

    p. 920

Recording and study 3

  • J. HandcockCorresponded withBritish Museum

    Captain Gerald Handcock wrote to the British Museum about the tablets’ discovery in the shaft.

    Lead tablets and selenite tablets

    1890 · p. 920
  • Andrew T. WilburnStudied

    Andrew T. Wilburn studied the Amathous tablets, including their production, deposition and social context.

    Lead tablets and selenite tablets

    p. 920
  • J. HandcockConnected withCecil Smith

    Captain Gerald Handcock relayed information about the tablets’ discovery to Cecil Smith.

    p. 920

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

Missing from this record

  • Date not recorded
  • Journal not recorded

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.