Article · 2012

The date of the Minoan Santorini eruption: quantifying the 'offset'

F. Höflmayer

Radiocarbon 54(3-4) 435-448

An article on the radiocarbon and archaeological evidence for the date of the Minoan Santorini eruption, with an estimate of the offset between the two chronologies.

Höflmayer reviews radiocarbon dates for the late Late Minoan IA period and the archaeological arguments for dating the Minoan Santorini eruption, drawing on Aegean sites, Egyptian and Levantine contexts and the chronology of the Egyptian New Kingdom. The radiocarbon review covers short-lived samples from Akrotiri, an olive-tree branch buried by the eruption, the Aegina Kolonna sequence and tsunami contexts at Palaikastro, with published measurements recalibrated and modelled using OxCal v 4.1 and IntCal09. The archaeological side includes more than 350 chemically analysed pumice samples from Egypt and the Levant.

He contrasts a radiocarbon-supported high chronology, placing the end of LM IA in the second half of the 17th century BCE, with a conventional chronology that places the eruption after the start of the Egyptian New Kingdom. The Aegean radiocarbon evidence puts the eruption shortly before 1600 BCE. Höflmayer argues that pumice deposits and White Slip I pottery in eastern Mediterranean contexts do not directly date the eruption, since their deposition may postdate production or the eruption by an unknown interval, and he treats Egyptian stone vessels from Mycenaean shaft-graves as the strongest archaeological synchronism, while noting limits in their dating (pp. 440–443). A Cypriot White Slip I milk bowl found on Santorini was one of the key arguments for the low dating of the eruption.

He concludes that the offset from the archaeological chronology is about 50 years or less if the New Kingdom began earlier than the conventional date, and calls for renewed study of Egyptian stone vessels (pp. 443–444).

What it records

  • The combined calibration of 28 short-lived samples from Akrotiri gives two reported date ranges, 1664–1651 cal BC and 1642–1616 cal BC.p. 436
  • Höflmayer reports 72 rings counted on the Santorini olive-tree branch and dates its last ring to 1621–1605 cal BC at 1σ.p. 437
  • The Aegina Kolonna sequence discussed by Höflmayer contains 46 radiocarbon measurements once possible contaminants and outliers are excluded.p. 438
  • At Tell el-Dab'a, Theran pumice first appears in Str. C/2, which Höflmayer dates to the late reign of Thutmose III and the reign of Amenhotep II.p. 441
  • Höflmayer argues that Egyptian and Levantine pumice deposits give a terminus ante quem for the eruption.p. 442
  • The Egyptian New Kingdom radiocarbon model gives a start date of 1566–1552 BCE at 68.2% probability and 1570–1544 BCE at 95.4% probability.p. 443
  • An offset of about 50 years or less between archaeological and scientific dates follows if a slightly earlier New Kingdom start is accepted, Höflmayer argues.p. 444

Where to read

  • Radiocarbon evidence from Akrotiri, the olive branch, Aegina Kolonna and Palaikastropp. 436–439
  • Egyptian stone vessels and Theran pumice in archaeological contextspp. 440–442
  • White Slip I pottery and Egyptian New Kingdom datespp. 442–444

Contents

  • Introduction: "High" and "Low" Chronology and Recent Developments435
  • Radiocarbon Evidence for Minoan Santorini Eruption and Late LM IA Period436
  • Short-Lived Samples from Akrotiri (Thera)436
  • Branch of an Olive Tree437
  • Sequence for Aegina Kolonna438
  • Palaikastro Tsunami Deposits438
  • Archaeological Arguments for a "Low" or "Conventional" Date440
  • Egyptian Stone Vessels440
  • Pumice in Egypt and the Levant441
  • White Slip I Ware on Thera and in the Eastern Mediterranean442
  • Egyptian New Kingdom Chronology and Radiocarbon Dating443
  • Conclusions: Quantifying the "Offset"443

Objects published here

4
  • Egyptian jug from shaft-grave IV, shaft-grave IV (p. 440)
  • Converted Egyptian alabastron, shaft-grave V (p. 440)
  • Olive-tree branch believed to have been killed by the eruption, Santorini, Figure 3 (p. 437)
  • Cypriot White Slip I milk bowl, Thera (p. 442)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Peter Warrenadvocate of the conventional chronology
  • Manfred Bietakadvocate of the conventional chronology
  • Malcolm Wieneradvocate of the conventional chronology
  • Wenteargued for longer royal reigns
  • van Siclenargued for longer royal reigns
  • Kitchenbasis for Egyptian reign-length model
  • Thutmose IIIEgyptian king used in dating contexts
  • Amenhotep IIEgyptian king used in dating contexts
  • Thutmose IVking whose reign length is disputed

Places

  • Akrotirisettlement destroyed by the eruption
  • Santoriniisland and eruption location
  • Aegina KolonnaBronze Age radiocarbon sequence
  • Palaikastrosite of tsunami deposits
  • Tell el-Dab'asite with pumice and White Slip finds
  • Tell el-Ajjulsite with Theran pumice
  • Sawamacemetery with a vessel parallel

Also named: Ashkelon, Megiddo.

Extent pp. 435–448, 5 figs; bibliography

Late Bronze AgeChronology and DatingPotteryForeign Contacts

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.