Book · 2001
Personal Styles in Early Cycladic Sculpture
Pat Getz-Gentle
Madison: University of Wisconsin Press
A study of Early Cycladic marble sculpture from Neolithic precursors to the folded-arm figures of Early Cycladic II, on typology, the hands of individual sculptors and proportion.
Getz-Gentle follows Cycladic marble sculpture from Late Neolithic images to the reclining folded-arm figures of Early Cycladic II, and asks how far the hands of individual sculptors can be told apart within a conservative tradition. Close visual comparison runs alongside object histories, checklists, photographs, drawings, tables and measurements, and an addendum deals with the dealers through whom material associated with the Keros hoard was distributed.
How it is organised
Chapter 1 follows sculpture from Late Neolithic images through Plastiras, violin, hybrid, Louros and precanonical forms. Chapter 2 treats the reclining folded-arm figure and its Kapsala, Spedos, Dokathismata and Chalandriani varieties. Chapter 3 turns to the sculptors of Plastiras figures and chapter 4 to the makers of folded-arm figures. Jack de Vries contributes chapter 5, a measurement study of Spedos figures. Notes, revised checklists of twenty sculptors, a bibliography, notes on the plates and text figures, the addendum and an index complete the book (pp. 3–124).
The argument
Individual hands can be distinguished, Getz-Gentle argues, through the combined study of contours, proportions, carving and incision details. She attributes works on the whole visual character of a piece, seen from several views, and allows that variation within one sculptor's output may come from the sculptor's development, from experiment, from the marble, or from adjustments made after accidents in carving. She also discusses the uncertainty around unprovenanced pieces and the limits of visual and scientific tests of authenticity (pp. 97–108).
Precanonical figures form for her a diverse transitional group in which sculptors tried out arm placement, posture and the separation of the legs. She proposes that several carvers reached the folded-arm arrangement independently, and that it became established with the Kapsala variety and the earliest Early Spedos figures. The convention of the right arm below the left she reads as a design solution that could create an apparent balance (pp. 16–33).
Kapsala figures are slender, with extended folded arms and often a broken profile. Early Spedos figures divide into Styles A and B, and Late Spedos combines and streamlines traits of both. Dokathismata and Chalandriani figures carry on the developments of late Early Cycladic II, with variation in shoulder breadth, profile, leg-cleft and arm arrangement. Classification becomes difficult, Getz-Gentle stresses, where traits overlap or works are fragmentary (pp. 29–52).
In the chapters on individual sculptors she revises earlier attributions and proposes developmental sequences for the Kontoleon, Goulandris, Bastis, Schuster, Ashmolean, Berlin and Louvre Sculptors. Four complete works formerly given to the Stafford Master she withdraws as replicas based on a Louvre reproduction, and she renames the sculptor after the Louvre figure (pp. 67–108).
The evidence
The comparisons rest on complete figures and fragments: excavated objects, pieces in private collections and works associated with the Keros hoard. Photographs and drawings set whole forms and details side by side, and the revised checklists give dimensions, collection information, findplaces, acquisition details and selected references for each sculptor's works. For the Goulandris Sculptor, stable-isotope results from sampled pieces stand beside stylistic comparison in the discussion of marble sources and attributions (pp. 84–93).
De Vries measured complete Spedos figures with an apparatus built for the purpose, analysed a group of fifty, and compares the results with a proposed four-part plan that fixes, among other points, the placement of the neck and knees, the midpoint of the abdomen and shoulder width. He concludes that many, perhaps most, Spedos sculptors used the plan as a guide, at least in roughing out, and reports that 150 of 202 measured proportions deviate from the proposed standard by 1 cm or less, while individual works follow it to differing degrees (pp. 110–124).
Dating
Early Cycladic I, a transitional I/II phase and Early Cycladic II are the divisions used. Getz-Gentle places the precanonical group around the transition from I to II and notes that its chronology is uncertain. The opening chapter gives the folded-arm figure a span from about 2700 to perhaps 2200 BCE, and the five Early Cycladic II varieties overlap in their traits and proposed sequences (pp. 3, 29–50).
What it records
- Nicolas Koutoulakis took over the gallery after the death of his uncle in 1949.p. 183
- Getz-Gentle suggests that Manolis Segredakis, founder of the Galerie Segredakis in Paris, or his agents may have obtained the material later called the Keros hoard, possibly before World War II.p. 183
- Christos Bastis acquired the name-piece of the Bastis Sculptor from the Galerie Segredakis in 1947.p. 184
- A cache of Early Cycladic objects found at Akrotiri on Thera in 1992 included nine mostly fragmentary figures and three kandiles.p. 22
- Five varieties of the standard folded-arm figure are recognised, named after sites: Kapsala, Early Spedos, Late Spedos, Dokathismata and Chalandriani.p. 29
- More than forty early female figures (Plastiras, violin, hybrid and Louros types) and ten late Early Cycladic II female figures have abdominal grooves, by Getz-Gentle's count.p. 62
- The complete and fragmentary works attributed to the Goulandris Sculptor represent at least sixty distinct images, by Getz-Gentle's count.p. 84
- Samples from twenty-three pieces attributed to the Goulandris Sculptor have been analysed for stable isotopes.p. 91
- The three tested works that Getz-Gentle accepts as genuine Louvre Sculptor pieces have isotope signatures and grain sizes consistent with field samples from southeast Naxos.p. 106
- De Vries studied eighty-five complete Spedos figures over twelve years with a purpose-built apparatus.p. 110
- De Vries concludes that many, perhaps most, Spedos sculptors used a four-part plan to guide the layout and carving of their figures.p. 119
- The revised checklists cover twenty sculptors: revised versions of sixteen earlier lists, plus four sculptors discussed in detail for the first time in chapter 4.p. 151
Where to read
- Neolithic precursors and the Plastiras typepp. 3–13
- Precanonical figures and the development of folded armspp. 16–28
- The folded-arm varieties and their chronologypp. 29–60
- The Goulandris Sculptor and marble-source analysispp. 84–93
- The Louvre Sculptor and replica-based figurespp. 104–108
- De Vries's four-part plan and the measurementspp. 109–121
- Keros hoard distribution and dealerspp. 183–184
Contents
- Before the Arms Were Folded: Cycladic Sculpture from the Late Neolithic through the Transitional Early Cycladic I/II Phase3
- The Reclining Folded-Arm Figure and Its Varieties: Cycladic Sculpture of the Early Cycladic II Period29
- Sculptors of Early Cycladic I: Plastiras Figures61
- Sculptors of Early Cycladic II: Reclining Folded-Arm Figures67
- Pattern and Precision: Taking the Measure of Early Cycladic II Spedos Variety Figures109
- Abbreviations127
- Notes131
- Checklists of Twenty Sculptors151
- Bibliography171
- Notes on the Plates173
- Notes on the Text Figures179
- Addendum183
- Illustration Sources189
- Index195
- Plates197
Objects published here
4- Male Plastiras figure from Glypha Tomb 23, listed under the Doumas Sculptor, Paros, Glypha Tomb 23, Athens, NAM 4762, Plate 53b (p. 152)
- Large Kapsala figure attributed to the Kontoleon Sculptor, Shelby White and Leon Levy Collection, Plates 57, 65d
- Large folded-arm figure attributed to the Karlsruhe/Woodner Sculptor, Keros, in a cave, Athens, NPGM 724, Plates 64–66: c (p. 158)
- Figure attributed to the Louvre Sculptor, Naxos, Paris, Musée du Louvre Ma 3093, Plates 91, 93–94: c; 92b; 96a (p. 169)
People, places and institutions
People
- Nicolas Koutoulakistook over his uncle's gallery in 1949
- Manolis Segredakisfounded the Paris gallery; possible source of hoard material
- Christos Bastisbought the Bastis Sculptor name-piece in 1947
Institutions
- Galerie SegredakisParis gallery that sold a Bastis figure
Places
- Kerossite associated with the Keros hoard
- Akrotirisource of a cache of Early Cycladic objects
- Theraisland where the Akrotiri cache was found
- Naxossource of excavated figures and proposed marble
- Aplomatacemetery with Early Cycladic figures
- Louroscemetery and source of Louros-type figures
- Parossource of Plastiras-type figures
- Saliagossource of a Neolithic head
- GlyphaParos tomb with a Plastiras figure
- PhiontasNaxos cemetery with sculptor finds
Also named: Antiparos.
Extent 98 plates, 44 text figures, 2 maps; bibliography, index
Defines Plastiras type, hybrid images, Louros type, precanonical, Kapsala variety, Early Spedos variety, Style A, Style B, Late Spedos variety, Dokathismata variety, Chalandriani variety
Early Bronze AgeNeolithicModernSculptureIconographyChronology and DatingCollectingMuseums
People it is cited for
2 people- Nicolas Koutoulakis8 citations
- Emmanuel (Manolis) Segredakis3 citations
Institutions it is cited for
1 institution- Galerie Segredakis3 citations
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.