Article · 1998

Illicit antiquities and international litigation: the Turkish experience

Janet Blake

Antiquity 72(278) 824-830

An article on international litigation as a way to recover stolen or illegally exported antiquities, drawn from Turkish claims in the United States against the Metropolitan Museum and OKS Partners.

Blake takes Turkish restitution claims in the United States to discuss the legal obstacles to recovering stolen or illegally exported antiquities and the wider measures for controlling the trade. She argues that protecting archaeological sites requires action against the market for illicit antiquities as well as protection in situ. Litigation can support restitution and put pressure on buyers, dealers and museums, although its costs and legal difficulties confine it to a small number of cases.

Turkey v. the Met concerned over 360 artefacts from Lydian tumuli in the Ushak region, acquired by the Metropolitan Museum between 1966 and 1970. Blake describes the Turkish claim, the Museum's limitation defence, the evidence disclosed during discovery and the negotiations that ended in an agreement for the hoard's return, which she presents as a successful claim that put pressure on museums and the antiquities market. Turkey v. OKS Partners concerned over 2,000 silver coins excavated at Elmali in 1984 and exported to Germany; the defendants argued limitation and ownership, and the court applied the discovery rule and recognised Turkey's right of possession. Blake also notes the 1994 return of a Roman sarcophagus and the dispute over the two parts of the statue of the weary Herakles (pp. 826–828).

Litigation, she concludes, can encourage the return of antiquities and influence policy but is not a practical remedy in most cases. She sets it beside the 1970 UNESCO Convention and the 1995 UNIDROIT Convention as frameworks for international claims and returns (pp. 828–829).

What it records

  • Between 1993 and 1995, more than 17,500 official police operations investigated stolen and smuggled antiquities in Turkey.p. 824
  • The Metropolitan Museum acquired the Lydian collection between 1966 and 1970 for $1.4 million.p. 826
  • Turkey filed a civil suit against the Metropolitan Museum in the New York District Court in May 1987.p. 826
  • The Turkish government and the Metropolitan Museum signed an agreement for the hoard's return to Turkey on 23 September 1993.p. 827
  • The Elmali collection comprised over 2,000 silver coins illicitly excavated in 1984 and illegally exported to Germany.p. 827
  • The bulk of the Elmali coins, over 1,700, was sold to OKS Partners in 1984 for 2.7 million.p. 827
  • The lower half of the statue of the weary Herakles was found during excavations at Perge in 1980 and placed in Antalya Museum.p. 828
  • A monumental Roman sarcophagus was returned to Turkey from the Brooklyn Museum on 26 April 1994.p. 828

Where to read

  • Turkey v. the Met: collection, discovery and settlementpp. 826–827
  • Turkey v. OKS Partners and the Elmali coinsp. 827
  • UNESCO and UNIDROIT conventions and market policypp. 828–829

Contents

  • Introduction824
  • International litigation for the restitution of stolen artefacts825
  • International litigation by Turkey826
  • Turkey v. the Met.826
  • Turkey v. OKS Partners827
  • Conclusion827
  • References830
  • Appendix: Turkish legislation830

Objects published here

4
  • Lydian artefacts from tumuli in the Ushak region, Metropolitan Museum, tumuli in the Ushak region of Turkey (p. 826)
  • Silver Greek coin collection from Elmali, OKS Partners, Elmali (near Antalya) (p. 827)
  • Part of the apse mosaic of the church of Panagia Kanakaria, church of Panagia Kanakaria in the occupied north (p. 825)
  • Monumental Roman sarcophagus, Brooklyn Museum (p. 828)

People, places and institutions

People

Institutions

  • Turkeypursued restitution claims
  • Republic of Turkeyclaimant in US restitution suits
  • Metropolitan Museumdefendant in Turkey’s restitution suit
  • OKS Partnersdefendant in coin restitution suit
  • Boston Museum of Fine Artsheld the upper statue half
  • Brooklyn Museumheld a Roman sarcophagus on loan
  • UNIDROITadopted a cultural objects convention
  • UNESCOconvention and return mechanism

Places

  • Ushakregion of the looted tumuli
  • Elmalifindspot of the silver coin hoard
  • Pergeexcavation site of statue fragment
  • Antalya Museumreceived the lower statue half

Also named: Sothebys, Panagia Kanakaria, Antalya, Dr Gary Vikan.

Extent pp. 824–830; references; appendix on Turkish legislation

ModernLate AntiqueRomanLooting and the LawTradeMuseumsHistory of Archaeology

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.