Article · 2018
Looting, the Antiquities Trade, and Competing Valuations of the Past
Alex W. Barker
Annual Review of Anthropology 47 455-474
A review article on the scale and effects of archaeological looting, legal and museum responses, the online trade, and debates over heritage, community rights and archaeological stewardship.
Barker reviews terrestrial looting and antiquities trafficking, their effects on archaeological evidence and on people, and the responses made through law, museum policy and monitoring technologies. The evidence includes reported site surveys, archaeologists' experiences, satellite imagery, auction and online sales data, legal instruments, museum policies and ethnographies, with examples from looting rates in western Turkey and Egypt to antiquities and coin listings online.
He argues that legal remedies and professional guidelines have not matched the scale or changing causes of looting. Effective responses, he says, need action at looting sites, coordinated restrictions on trafficking, enforcement in market countries and measures to reduce demand (pp. 458–460). Barker describes responses to conflict antiquities as closely tied to counterterrorism, and warns that freely available monitoring tools can also help looters identify sites.
A later section sets the preservation of archaeological evidence for future inquiry against the use and interpretation of the past by living communities. Barker holds that recording context need not exclude other forms of knowledge, and he leaves open how obligations to past and future communities should be balanced with those to living ones. He concludes that looting is unlikely to lessen in scale or impact in the near term (pp. 465–467).
What it records
- Roosevelt and Luke report signs of looting at 90% of the 400 Lydian burial tombs they inspected in western Turkey.p. 456
- Parcak and colleagues documented a 940% increase in observed looting pits in Egypt between 2008 and 2010.p. 456
- In Proulx's survey, 97.9% of responding archaeologists said looting was a problem in their research areas.p. 456
- Looting destroys the contextual information on which archaeological inference depends, in Barker's account.p. 457
- The United States has bilateral cultural-property agreements with Cyprus and 16 other countries, alongside emergency actions for Iraq and Syria.p. 458
- VCoins listed 91,764 ancient coins from 137 dealers in February 2015, with a combined asking price of almost US$23 million.p. 462
- Barker distinguishes archaeology, the potential to understand the past, from heritage, possession of it.p. 466
Where to read
- Legal and international responses, including the US agreement with Cypruspp. 458–459
- Museum acquisition policies and provenancepp. 459–460
- Community rights, heritage and archaeological stewardshippp. 465–467
Contents
- Introduction456
- Scale of Looting456
- Impact and Costs of Looting457
- Legal Responses458
- Museum Responses459
- Effect of the Internet461
- Coins461
- Iconoclasm and Ideological Spoliation462
- Links Between Looting and Drug Trafficking and Other Criminal Activity463
- Ethnographies of Looting464
- Epistemology, Ontology, and Deontology465
- Conclusion: Looking Forward466
- Disclosure Statement467
- Literature Cited467
- Related Resources473
People, places and institutions
People
- Gill DWJcited on looting and antiquities returns
- Neil Brodieco-authored an earlier review of looting
- Colin Renfrewco-authored an earlier review of looting
- Mackenziediscussed demand-reduction strategies
- Hamilakiscriticised archaeologists' military collaboration
- Stonewrote on heritage work with the military
- Casanastudied looting in Syria
- Hartogframework for differing orders of time
- Fieldco-authored a critique of heritage dichotomies
Institutions
- UNESCOconvention and heritage-law database
- United Statescultural-property agreements and legislation
- Association of Art Museum Directorsissued antiquities acquisition guidelines
- American Association of Museumsissued standards for archaeological material
- International Council of Museumsissued Red Lists of cultural objects at risk
Places
- ApameaRoman-period site in Syria
Also named: Khaled al-Asaad.
Extent pp. 455–474
ModernLooting and the LawCollectingMuseumsHistory of Archaeology
People it is cited for
1 personCorrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.