Collector

William Greenwell

fl. 1874–1969 · United Kingdom

Durham minor canon and barrow-digger who published a Cypriot ram coin of Salamis, owned Cypriot staters now in Boston, and collected the Cypriot hook-tang weapons now in the British Museum.

Biography

William Greenwell, a Durham cleric and collector known to everybody as Canon Greenwell, published a Cypriot coin in 1890 and gathered Cypriot staters and Cypriot bronze weapons that are now in Boston and London3,4,10,11.

He was born at Greenwell Ford, Lanchester, Durham, on 23 March 1820, the eldest son of William Thomas Greenwell and Dorothy Smales, and was the elder brother of the poet Dora Greenwell5. After a B.A. at University College, Durham, in 1839 he entered the Middle Temple, but ill-health brought him back to Durham in 1841; he took the theology course, graduated M.A. in 1843 and was ordained the next year5. He became a minor canon of Durham Cathedral in 1854 and held the living of St Mary-the-Less from 1865 until his death5. The sources differ on when his other cathedral posts began and ended: the DNB has him librarian from 1862 and resigning both offices in 1907, while H. D. Hughes gives minor canon 1854-1908 and librarian 1863-19095,6. As librarian he found a leaf of one of the Wearmouth-Jarrow bibles folded as the cover of an account book in a Newcastle bookshop, and gave it to the British Museum6. In 1872 he showed the foundation charters of the Benedictine convent at Durham to be forgeries5.

Barrows and collecting

His barrow excavations appeared in 1877 as British Barrows, written with George Rolleston, and he was elected a fellow of the Royal Society in 18785. Emma Reeve calls him an influential archaeologist and collector who gave Pitt Rivers practical lessons in excavation2. At the Royal Archaeological Institute's 1874 meeting at Ripon, Reeve records, Holmes showed Cypriot antiquities alongside Canon Greenwell, though she does not say Greenwell's exhibits were Cypriot2. The DNB dates his collecting to 1856, first Greek coins, then from 1858 prehistoric bronze implements5.

The Cypriot coins

In the Numismatic Chronicle for 1890 Greenwell published a find of archaic Greek coins from Egypt, which Sydney P. Noe lists as a hoard of 24 silver coins buried about 500 BC, among them coins of Cyprus and Tyre7. Under Cyprus he described a coin of 165.7 grains with a ram lying left and a legend in Cypriot letters, which he read as ve u e4. He noted that J. P. Six had classed such coins to Evelthon, King of Salamis, and his descendants, and judged that his coin "probably belongs to the earlier, and if so to Evelthon himself"4. A smaller ram coin of 51.3 grains came from the same find4.

The DNB says the coins were sold to America in 1901, but K. Regling states that Edward Perry Warren acquired the collection in July 1902, and R. Weil also gives 19025,8,9. Regling counts 1,016 of Warren's 1,769 coins as Greenwell's, and says Greenwell had cultivated the electrum series with particular care8. Weil says Greenwell collected chiefly from an art-historical point of view, and regretted that no one in England bought the collection for a public institution in 19029. Among the Greenwell coins Regling lists a Paphos diobol attributed to Stasandros and a Salamis didrachm of 10.79 g with a recumbent ram, its legend referred to Euelthon8. The Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, bought Cypriot coins of Greenwell's from Warren in September 1904, including a stater of Idalion struck under Baalmelek II, a stater of Salamis struck under Euagoras I, and a Paphos coin that had been in the Moore sale of 188910.

The "Cypriot daggers"

Greenwell's prehistoric metalwork, some 2,437 pieces, reached the British Museum in 1908 according to Trevor Watkins; the museum's 1920 guide and Veronica Tatton-Brown give 1909, as J. Pierpont Morgan's gift11,12,13. Most pieces had paper labels, which record what Greenwell believed or had been told of their origins11. Watkins found that all his hook-tang weapons were Cypriot but purported to come from south Levantine sites, and thought it "altogether too remarkable" that 21 of the 22 such weapons from supposed Levantine contexts were in one private collection11. A pencilled note in the museum's records quotes R. A. S. Macalister saying the "Gezer" pieces were not from his diggings and that "dealers assign objects to any well-known excavation"11. Watkins found no indication that Greenwell ever travelled in the Levant, judged the place-names on the Cypriot weapons spurious, and concluded that Greenwell bought his Levantine bronzes in Britain11. Pieces to which Greenwell himself gave a Cypriot provenance are now in the Department of Greek and Roman Antiquities, Watkins notes; the museum's records include a bronze blade and a toggle-pin with findspot Cyprus, ex Greenwell and given by Morgan11,14.

Greenwell died at Durham, unmarried, on 27 January 1918, in his ninety-eighth year3,5.

Life and work

  1. 1874

    1. Exhibited as an archaeologist-collector at the Royal Archaeological Institute's Ripon meeting alongside Holmes, who showed Cypriot antiquities; the source does not say Greenwell's exhibits were Cypriot

      RiponAnna Holly Reeve (2021). Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947. PhD thesis, University of Leeds, p. 99

  2. 1902

    1. Was the source of 4 objects (among them 'Stater of Idalion with Herakles, struck under Baalmelek II', inv. 04.1154) that Edward Perry Warren acquired in 1902 (the record does not say how); now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

      Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, inv. 04.1154; 04.1155; 04.1157

  3. 1909

    1. Part of his collection, including Bronze Age Cypriot weapons, was bought by J. Pierpont Morgan and donated to the BM in 1909.

      Tatton-Brown 1987, Ancient Cyprus (British Museum), Preface

  4. 1935

    1. Owned 36 objects (among them 'knife', reg. 1935,0823.6), now in the British Museum.

      British Museum collection online, reg. 1935,0823.6; 1969,1231.100; 1969,1231.101

  5. 1969

    1. Owned an object ('blade', reg. 1969,1231.110), now in the British Museum.

      British Museum collection online, 'blade', reg. 1969,1231.110

  6. Undated

    n.d.

    1. Owned 3 objects (among them 'Stater of Idalion with Herakles, struck under Baalmelek II', inv. 04.1154), now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

      Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, inv. 04.1154; 04.1157; 04.1158

    2. Owned an object ('Stater of Paphos with standing bull, struck under Onasi[...]', inv. 04.1155), now in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston.

      Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, 'Stater of Paphos with standing bull, struck under Onasi[...]', inv. 04.1155

Connections

2 people

Mentioned in

9 mentions

Sources

  1. 1.Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow.
  2. 2.Anna Holly Reeve (2021). “Ancient Cyprus in Leeds: Objects, Networks and Museums from 1870 to 1947”. PhD thesis, University of Leeds.
  3. 3.Anon. (1918). “Dr. William Greenwell, F.R.S.”. Nature 100, 428.
  4. 4.W. Greenwell (1890). “On a find of archaic Greek coins in Egypt”. Numismatic Chronicle, 3rd series 10, 1-12.
  5. 5.K. C. B. (1927). “Greenwell, William (1820-1918)”. The Dictionary of National Biography 1912-1921, ed. H. W. C. Davis and J. R. H. Weaver.
  6. 6.H. D. Hughes (1925). A History of Durham Cathedral Library.
  7. 7.Sydney P. Noe (1925). “A Bibliography of Greek Coin Hoards”. Numismatic Notes and Monographs 25. American Numismatic Society.
  8. 8.K. Regling (1906). Die griechischen Münzen der Sammlung Warren.
  9. 9.R. Weil (1907). “[Review of K. Regling, Die griechischen Münzen der Sammlung Warren, 1906]”. Zeitschrift für Numismatik, 323-326.
  10. 10.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston. Collections online records (Greek coins 04.1154-04.1159). Online
  11. 11.Trevor Watkins (1981). “Levantine bronzes from the collection of the Rev. William Greenwell, now in the British Museum”. Levant 13, 119-155. Online
  12. 12.British Museum (1920). A Guide to the Antiquities of the Bronze Age in the Department of British and Mediaeval Antiquities.
  13. 13.Veronica Tatton-Brown (ed.) (2001). Cyprus in the 19th Century AD: Fact, Fancy and Fiction. Oxford, Oxbow.
  14. 14.British Museum. Collection online records (Greenwell bronzes from Cyprus). Online
  15. 15.Tatton-Brown 1987, Ancient Cyprus (British Museum).
  16. 16.British Museum collection online.
  17. 17.British Museum collection online, 'blade'.
  18. 18.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online.
  19. 19.Museum of Fine Arts, Boston collection online, 'Stater of Paphos with standing bull, struck under Onasi[...]'.
  20. 20.Tatton-Brown 2001, 'Excavations in ancient Cyprus: original manuscripts and correspondence in the British Museum', in Tatton-Brown (ed.), Cyprus in the 19th Century AD.
  21. 21.V. Tatton-Brown, 2001, Excavations in ancient Cyprus: original manuscripts and correspondence in the British Museum, n. 97.
  22. 22.Veronica Tatton-Brown, Ancient Cyprus (1987).
  23. 23.V. Tatton-Brown (ed.), 2001, Cyprus in the 19th century AD: fact, fancy and fictionn. 97.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.