Dealer · Collector
Moses Wilhelm Shapira
1830–1884
Jerusalem dealer in antiquities and manuscripts who held a small collection of Cypriot antiquities in 1876 and whose "Moabite" figures were judged against Cypriot sculpture.
Biography
Moses Wilhelm Shapira was a dealer in antiquities and manuscripts in Jerusalem whose "Moabite" figures were judged forgeries by setting them beside Cypriot sculpture, and who in the 1870s held a small collection of Cypriot antiquities of his own7,8.
A Cypriot collection in Jerusalem
Isaac H. Hall of the Protestant College, Beirut, described the collection in his 1876 paper Cypriote Antiquities and Inscriptions8. On a trip to Jerusalem Hall first saw a collection at Jaffa held by one Rosedale, one of the German colonists, who had obtained it by sending to Cyprus for it, from a Greek native of the island8. Hall had "no doubt" that these pieces were obtained surreptitiously from the workmen of Luigi Palma di Cesnola8. In Jerusalem he then saw "a small but good collection" in Shapira's possession, which appeared to be the choicest pieces selected from the Jaffa collection8. Shapira told him that he had bought it, without saying from whom, only "in order to study the antiquities of Cyprus"8. Hall also handled Shapira's few hundred Moabite pieces many times and could not believe that a single one was genuine, though he granted that the inscriptions were made with much more skill than earlier forgeries detected in America8.
The Moabite pottery
According to the Jewish Encyclopedia, Shapira appears to have converted to Christianity young, gone to Palestine and opened a shop selling local antiquities; it gives his birth as about 18309. Wikipedia alone gives his birthplace as Kamenets-Podolski5. Georges Perrot and Charles Chipiez record rumours early in 1872 of terracottas said to come from Moab in his hands2. In April 1872 papers read to the American Oriental Society denounced the inscriptions as forgeries, yet the Prussian government bought his whole collection for the Berlin Museum, and he began another10. Charles Clermont-Ganneau gives the purchase as about 1,700 numbers11. The sources disagree on the price. Perrot and Chipiez give 20,000 thalers, and Clermont-Ganneau gives 20,000 "je crois", while the Jewish Encyclopedia gives 22,000, as Clermont-Ganneau says Sprenger did2,9,11.
Charles Clermont-Ganneau visited the new collection in Jerusalem through the good offices of a Mr. Drake7. Clermont-Ganneau wrote that it was enough to compare the figures with the statues of Cyprus, "certainly rough, but authentic", to see the work of "a modern Arab reproducing mechanically models"7. In 1885 he repeated that the crudest products of Cypriot art were masterpieces beside these figures11. Charles Dudley Warner, writing in 1877, thought some of the images resembled the rudest "Phoenician" figures that Cesnola unearthed in Cyprus4. Warner also reported that it was generally thought in Jerusalem that if the collection was a forgery, Shapira "himself is imposed on"4. According to Perrot and Chipiez, Clermont-Ganneau learned from workmen that the figures were modelled for Shapira by Selim el-Gari, a native painter, and the collection was later withdrawn from the Berlin Museum2.
Manuscripts and death
Shapira supplied many early Yemenite Hebrew manuscripts to the Berlin Royal Library and the British Museum, according to the Jewish Encyclopedia9. In 1877, Clermont-Ganneau says, he brought to London a piece claimed to be from the sarcophagus of Samson11. In July 1883 he offered the British Museum, it is said for £1,000,000, leather strips in archaic Hebrew with a text like the speeches of Moses in Deuteronomy, which he said a Bedouin had found in a cave in Moab9. Clermont-Ganneau called it a fraud that failed after coming close to success11.
Clermont-Ganneau says that Shapira then left London for Holland, staying at Amsterdam, Bloemendaal and Rotterdam, and that he had shown signs of mental disturbance, the Schiedam police having detained him as suspected of insanity11. Early in March 1884 the police broke into his Rotterdam hotel room and found his body11. The sources give two dates for his suicide: 11 March 1884 in the Jewish Encyclopedia, and 9 March in Guil9,12. Clermont-Ganneau declined to draw any conclusion for or against Shapira's personal guilt11.
Life and work
1872
1872–1873
The lot of 'Moabite' clay figures, jars and tablets he owned was acquired by Prussia, on M. Schlottmann's recommendation, for 20,000 thalers (Perrot and Chipiez); Wikipedia gives 1,700 pieces for 22,000 thalers in 1873.BerlinGeorges Perrot; Charles Chipiez (1890). History of Art in Sardinia, Judaea, Syria, and Asia Minor; Wikipedia (2026). Moses Wilhelm Shapira
1872–1876Accused
Perrot and Chipiez (1890, citing Clermont-Ganneau's Fraudes archéologiques) report that the 'Moabite' figures were modelled for Shapira in a back street of Jerusalem by the painter Selim el-Gari; the Revue critique (1876) judged his terracotta figurines apocryphal; the attribution of forgery to Shapira himself is the authors' own, and Warner (1877) records the Jerusalem view that Shapira was himself imposed on.Georges Perrot; Charles Chipiez (1890). History of Art in Sardinia, Judaea, Syria, and Asia Minor; Revue critique d'histoire et de littérature (1876). Review of the Moabite pottery controversy (Clermont-Ganneau's account of his visit to Shapira). Revue critique, leaf 195-199; Charles Dudley Warner (1877). In the Levant
1876
- Showed a visitor to Jerusalem a small, good collection of Cypriot antiquities which the visitor judged to be choice pieces from the Jaffa (Rosedale) collection; Shapira said he had bought it, without naming the seller, in order to study the antiquities of Cyprus.
- Described by C. D. Warner as a Hebrew antiquarian and bookseller who claimed to have determined 23 characters of the inscriptions on his clay figures and jars, some of whose images Warner thought resembled the rudest 'Phoenician' images Cesnola unearthed in Cyprus.
Connections
2 peopleDisputes & the law
Colleagues & contacts
- Connected with Charles Clermont-GanneauMoabite clay figures; Moabite forgeries; Moabite/Jerusalem forged figures Georges Perrot , Charles Chipiez, History of Art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor (1890); Perrot, Georges, 1832-1914, History of art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor / (1890)1874
- Connected with Luigi Palma di Cesnolahis Cypriot collection was said to be selected from the Jaffa collection derived, the visitor thought, from Cesnola's workmen; Cypriote collection from the Jaffa collection University of the State of New York, 1876, Proceedings of the Twelfth Convocation (paper on Cypriote antiquities and inscriptions), leaf 119 (p. 109); University of the State of New York, Proceedings of the ... Convocation (1876)1876
Sources
- 1.University of the State of New York (1876). “Proceedings of the Twelfth Convocation (paper on Cypriote antiquities and inscriptions)”. University Convocation proceedings, pp. 109-110 (leaf 119-120).
- 2.Georges Perrot; Charles Chipiez (1890). History of Art in Sardinia, Judaea, Syria, and Asia Minor.
- 3.Revue critique d'histoire et de littérature (1876). “Review of the Moabite pottery controversy (Clermont-Ganneau's account of his visit to Shapira)”. Revue critique, leaf 195-199.
- 4.Charles Dudley Warner (1877). In the Levant.
- 5.Wikipedia (2026). Moses Wilhelm Shapira. Online
- 6.Wikidata / GND (2026). Moses Shapira (1830-1884). Online
- 7.Charles Clermont-Ganneau (1874). “The Shapira Collection”. Palestine Exploration Fund Quarterly Statement.
- 8.Isaac H. Hall (1876). “Cypriote Antiquities and Inscriptions”. Proceedings of the Twelfth University Convocation, University of the State of New York.
- 9.Isidore Singer; Joseph Jacobs (1906). “Shapira, M. W.”. The Jewish Encyclopedia. Online
- 10. (1874). “[Letter on the Shapira Moabite pottery]”. The Nation 18.
- 11.Charles Clermont-Ganneau (1885). Les fraudes archéologiques en Palestine, suivies de quelques monuments phéniciens apocryphes. Ernest Leroux.
- 12.Shlomo Guil (2017). “The Shapira Scroll was an Authentic Dead Sea Scroll”. Palestine Exploration Quarterly 149, 6-27.
- 13.Georges Perrot , Charles Chipiez, History of Art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor (1890).
- 14.Perrot, Georges, 1832-1914, History of art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor / (1890).
- 15.Perrot, Georges, 1832-1914, History of art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor (1890).
- 16.Georges Perrot; Charles Chipiez, 1890, History of art in Sardinia, Judaea, Syria, and Asia Minor, leaf 391-392; Revue critique d'histoire et de littérature, 1876, Review of the Moabite pottery controversy (Clermont-Ganneau's account of his visit to Shapira), leaf 195.
- 17.University of the State of New York, 1876, Proceedings of the Twelfth Convocation (paper on Cypriote antiquities and inscriptions), leaf 119 (p. 109).
- 18.University of the State of New York, Proceedings of the ... Convocation (1876).
- 19.Perrot, Georges, 1832-1914; Chipiez, Charles, 1835-1901, joint author; Gonino, I., tr, History of art in Sardinia, Judæa, Syria, and Asia Minor (1890).
Corrections and additions
Did you know this person?
We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.
Missing from this record
- No photograph
We would like to hear about
- Dates and places of birth and death
- Other spellings or names they used
- Photographs, letters or papers
- Their work, collections or excavations
- A mistake in what we say
If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.