Article · 1963

A Colossal Head from Memphis, Severan or Augustan?

H. Ingholt

Journal of the American Research Center in Egypt 2 125-145

An article on a colossal marble and stucco head in the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, claimed to come from Memphis, and on whether it portrays Alexander Severus or Herod the Great.

A colossal head of marble and stucco, acquired by the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, with Memphis as its claimed provenance, is examined for its material, repairs, style and identity. Ingholt compares it with Egyptian and Mediterranean sculpture and with portraits of rulers, coins among them, and proposes Herod the Great as its subject. An appendix by John E. Sanders reports a petrographic analysis of stucco samples from the nose and beard.

The head is a marble facial mask and front of the neck, with hair, beard and much of the back completed in stucco. Ingholt records red pigment on the lips, eyes and nostrils, a dowel hole in the base, incised tool marks and joins between marble pieces (pp. 125–130).

Ingholt rejects the identification with Alexander Severus, arguing that the nose, lower lip, beard and expression differ from the accepted portraits of the emperor. He also disputes Vermeule's proposal that an earlier portrait was reworked as Alexander Severus, holding that the stucco beard belongs to the original execution and that the nose stucco is a later repair over a break (pp. 127–131).

After weighing Ptolemaic and Roman candidates, Ingholt turns to Herod, on the grounds of the head's Semitic features, a surface preparation related to a diadem, and the historical possibility of a statue honouring Herod in Memphis, where the Idumean community could have honoured him. He places the head in the ‘linear’ style group, current from about 45 BC into the early Empire, and proposes a date between 30 and 20 BC, which suits Herod's age in those decades. In his view the head is essentially an original that portrays a human being, with only a minor repair at the nose, and he grants that the identification is not proven incontrovertibly. The Severan attribution would instead place it in the early third century AD (pp. 132–141).

What it records

  • The head was acquired for the Museum of Fine Arts, Boston, at an auction in Basel in November 1958.p. 125
  • The head is carved on a scale about twice life-size, Ingholt reports.p. 125
  • The facial mask is marble, with the hair, the beard and undoubtedly the right ear added in stucco.p. 125
  • Memphis is the provenance claimed for the head.p. 126
  • Ingholt rejects Alexander Severus as the subject, citing differences between the head's features and the accepted portraits of the emperor.p. 128
  • An X-ray showed that an area of the right nostril under the nose stucco had been broken away.p. 131
  • Ingholt places the head in the ‘linear’ style group of portraits and suggests a date within the decade 30–20 BC.p. 138
  • Ingholt proposes Herod as the subject of the Boston head and concedes that the identification is not incontrovertibly proven.p. 141
  • Sanders finds that the stucco of the nose and of the beard was applied wet and crystallised in place, but came from different mixtures.p. 143

Where to read

  • The head's material, construction and surface tracespp. 125–126
  • The Severan attribution and the repairspp. 127–131
  • Herod, the Idumeans of Memphis and the proposed identificationpp. 132–135
  • Comparisons with portraits and the proposed datepp. 135–141
  • Petrographic analysis of the nose and beard stuccopp. 143–145

Objects published here

2
  • Colossal marble and stucco head, proposed as Herod, Memphis, claimed provenance, 59.51, pls. XXIX–XXX, figs. 1–5; pl. XLI, fig. 38; pl. XLII, fig. 41 (p. 125)
  • Marble head identified by Ingholt as Augustus, supposedly Alexandria, pl. XXXV, figs. 25–28 (p. 136)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Harald Ingholtexamines and interprets the head
  • Herod, called the Greatproposed subject of the head
  • John E. Sandersreports the petrographic examination of the stucco
  • Cornelius Vermeulecurator and earlier interpreter of the head
  • Herbert Cahnfirst described the head
  • Alexander Severusemperor whose identification Ingholt rejects
  • Mark Antonyconsidered as a possible subject
  • Ptolemy IV Philopatorcompared as a possible subject
  • Ptolemy VI Philometorcompared as a possible subject
  • AugustusRoman ruler in the Herod argument
  • AntipaterHerod's father and political predecessor

Institutions

Places

  • Memphisclaimed provenance and historical setting
  • IdumeaHerod's ancestral region
  • AlexandriaEgyptian city in historical comparisons
  • Sitasite of a temple with a statue of Herod

Also named: Bernard V. Bothmer, Yale University, Cairo, Basel.

Extent pp. 125–145, plates XXIX–XLIV, 41 figs; appendix by John E. Sanders, pp. 143–145

HellenisticRomanSculptureChronology and DatingMuseums

People it is cited for

1 person

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.