Article · 2009

X-radiography of Knossian Bronze Age vessels: assessing our knowledge of primary forming techniques

I. Berg

Annual of the British School at Athens 104 137-173

An article on X-radiography of 95 Bronze Age vessels from Knossos, comparing radiographic identifications of primary forming techniques with visual assessment.

Berg asks how well X-radiography identifies the primary forming techniques of Bronze Age pottery from Knossos. After reviewing the history of radiography of cultural materials and of ceramics, the signatures of different forming procedures and the method's limits, she describes the analysis of 95 vessels. A catalogue gives each vessel's radiographic reading, and a closing section sets the X-ray identifications against visual assessment and earlier publications.

The evidence

The vessels run from EM III to LM II and include a range of forms and fabrics, though Late Bronze Age material is underrepresented. Most are fragments. Berg took the radiographs at the museum and had the images digitised and processed at the University of Bradford (pp. 141–142).

Each catalogue entry records the vessel's description and dimensions, findspot or deposit, previous publication, wall thickness, voids and inclusions, visible coil seams, and the forming technique proposed in the original publication, by visual inspection and by X-ray. A carinated cup and a jug with cut-away spout serve as worked interpretations, and the entries are then grouped by period, from EM III/MM I A through MM I B, MM II A and B, MM III A and B to LM I A and LM II. Berg combines periods in parts of the analysis because individual groups are small (pp. 142–165).

The argument

Berg argues that surface features such as rilling and striations can mislead, because secondary shaping may hide or imitate primary forming. Radiographs show the orientation of voids and inclusions inside the wall, which can separate wheel-thrown vessels from coiled and wheel-coiled ones. Her recommendation is to combine radiography with visual examination, since radiographs do not reliably identify every vessel or its secondary treatment (pp. 165–166).

The comparison tests macroscopic classifications against the radiographs. Berg says that secondary shaping sometimes concealed the original method, above all where a coiled vessel was afterwards finished on a wheel. Berg finds that processing vessels are associated with handmade techniques, and that wheel use predominates among cups, and handmade construction stays common for larger vessels throughout (pp. 166–170).

What it records

  • Ninety-five open and closed coarse, semicoarse and fine vessels dated EM III to LM II, stored in the Stratigraphical Museum at Knossos, were selected for radiography.p. 141
  • The radiographs were taken at the Stratigraphical Museum at Knossos with a Faxitron single cabinet X-ray unit.p. 142
  • Coiled jug no. 18 shows five coil seams on its radiograph, the closest of them 1.5 cm apart.p. 144
  • In the radiographed sample, 80 vessels (over 80%) could be assigned to a specific primary forming technique, 9 could only be identified as handmade, and 6 were uncertain.p. 165
  • Radiographic identification is harder in heavily tempered clays, where overlying particles hinder the identification of specific forming techniques.p. 165
  • Pottery specialists disagree with one another's visual categorisation of forming techniques in 23% of cases, and secondary techniques cause misidentification in up to 25%.p. 166
  • Berg reports a long-term trend in which handmade vessels gradually decline while wheel-based techniques, used fully or in part, become more common after the wheel's introduction in MM I B; handmade techniques continue throughout.p. 166
  • Wheel-coiling continues as an occasional manufacturing method at Knossos into LM II.p. 166
  • The cup (no. 1) and the amphora (no. 68) are clear examples of combination techniques, joining wheel with coiling or coiling with drawing.p. 166

Where to read

  • Radiographic signatures used to identify forming techniquespp. 138–139
  • Sample selection, X-ray equipment and catalogue entry fieldspp. 141–143
  • Worked interpretations of a wheel-thrown cup and a coiled jugpp. 143–145
  • Vessel-by-vessel catalogue and forming-technique identificationspp. 146–165
  • Comparison of visual and radiographic identificationspp. 165–166
  • Changes in forming techniques by period and vessel typepp. 166–170

Contents

  • History of Radiography of Cultural Materials137
  • History of Radiography of Ceramics137
  • Identifying Vessel Formation Procedures138
  • Radiographic Case Studies Applied to Greek Bronze Age Ceramics140
  • Radiography: Theory, Methods, and Ceramic Analysis140
  • Methodology141
  • Catalogue Information142
  • Wheel-Thrown143
  • Coiled144
  • Wheel-Coiled145
  • Combination Techniques145
  • Catalogue146
  • Suitability of X-Radiography for Prehistoric Cretan Clays165
  • X-Radiography vs. Visual Inspection165
  • Discussion and Conclusion166

Objects published here

4
  • Rounded cup with wheel-thrown base and wheel-coiled body and rim, 'Floor deposit' of House A, IB 8g, 1, Plate 10 (p. 146)
  • Jug with cut-away spout, identified as coiled, Early Chamber beneath West Court, IB 60, 18, Plate 12 (p. 149)
  • Oval-mouthed amphora, identified as coiled, KV Trial, IB 34, 68, Plate 20 (p. 159)
  • Jug, identified as coiled, Area of Polychrome Jug, IB 54, 37, Plate 15 (p. 153)

People, places and institutions

People

  • Ryedescribed radiographic signatures of forming
  • Glanzmanstudied pottery forming with radiography
  • Vandiverstudied sequential slab-building
  • Rouxclassified experimental wheel-coiling methods

Institutions

  • Stratigraphical Museum at Knossosholds the analysed pottery
  • British Museumholds comparative pottery examined

Places

  • Knossossource of the analysed Bronze Age vessels
  • Creteregion of the pottery study

Also named: Wilhelm Röntgen, Fleming, Courty, University of Bradford, INSTAP Study Centre for East Crete, Baq'ah, Zagros region, Corinth.

Extent pp. 137–173, Figs 1–6, Pls 9–24; catalogue Nos 1–95; bibliography pp. 170–173

Defines pinching, drawing, coiling, slab-building, moulding, wheel-throwing, wheel-coiling, combination techniques

Early Bronze AgeMiddle Bronze AgeLate Bronze AgePotteryTechnologyChronology and Dating

Cited on Ancient Cyprus

1 page

Who did what

1 record

Recording and study 1

  • Ina BergStudied

    Ina Berg selected ninety-five vessels stored at the Stratigraphical Museum at Knossos for analysis.

    ninety-five open and closed coarse, semicoarse and fine EM III through to LM II vessels

    p. 141

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.