Restorer / conservator · Scholar

Harold James Plenderleith

1898–1997 · United Kingdom

Scottish chemist of the British Museum Research Laboratory who cleaned and restored the inlaid silver cup from Enkomi in 1951 and wrote its technical report, later first director of ICCROM.

Biography

Harold James Plenderleith was the British Museum chemist who cleaned and restored the silver cup inlaid with gold from Enkomi and wrote its technical report for Schaeffer's Enkomi-Alasia10.

A conservator's career

He was born at Coatbridge, Lanarkshire, on 19 September 1898, the eldest of four children of an art teacher at the Harris Academy in Dundee and the daughter of a medical missionary in New Zealand11. On the Western Front from 1 August 1917 he was wounded in the arm at Ypres and won the MC for a night raid on a pill-box11. He took the BSc and PhD at St Andrews12. In 1924 the Department of Scientific and Industrial Research recruited him to work under Alexander Scott in the British Museum's laboratory, where according to Oddy he was Assistant Keeper 1927-38, Deputy Keeper 1938-49 and Keeper of the Research Laboratory 1949-5911. Andrew Oddy writes that he worked with Howard Carter on finds from the tomb of Tutankhamun and on Sir Leonard Woolley's finds from Ur, and that in the Second World War he helped Sir John Forsdyke save the collections from bombing11. He was elected to the Royal Society of Edinburgh on 5 March 193412. He published The Conservation of Antiquities and Works of Art in 195611. From 1959 to 1971 he directed the International Centre for the Study of the Preservation and Restoration of Cultural Property in Rome11.

The Enkomi cup

The cup came from an intact tomb dug at Enkomi in 1949 by the Franco-British expedition under Claude Schaeffer13. When found it was so encrusted that it was thought to be bronze14. In February 1951 the British Embassy in Paris handled "a bronze bowl, with inlaid gold ornamentation" bound for him15. On 1 August 1951 he wrote to Schaeffer that the box had arrived after long delay and that he would first record the pattern by X-ray, promising a provisional report before he left England on 25 August16.

His report describes a cup covered in green corrosion with fragments of thin gold adhering10. Spectrographic analysis of a residue beneath the gold showed silver and copper, and he identified it as niello10. Experiments on laboratory-made niello showed it stable in formic acid, which dissolves copper compounds, and working from the X-ray photographs he set the loose gold back in place10. He wrote that all the repairs except the soldering could be removed with acetone10.

On 9 September 1951 Schaeffer told T. D. Kendrick that Plenderleith had sent "a splendid report", and that nowhere else could such a restoration have succeeded, crediting the Museum's equipment and Plenderleith's skill, experience and enthusiasm17. Plenderleith had asked Schaeffer, on Kendrick's behalf, whether the cup might be shown at the British Museum; Schaeffer agreed subject to the concurrence of A. H. S. Megaw, who gave it, asking that the label say it was on loan from the Government of Cyprus13. Megaw called it "a most important find"18. The Illustrated London News reported in 1952 that the cup was on show at the British Museum until August, when it was to go back to the Cyprus Antiquities Department19.

Copies, returns and other finds

In May 1952 Megaw reported that Plenderleith advised against ordinary electrotyping, and agreed to keep the cup longer in London for a replica by the slow, safe process he proposed20,21. He undertook two electrotypes, one for the British Museum and one for the Louvre14. The cup reached Paris in March 1953 for show in the Louvre, and Schaeffer called the restoration "a splendid piece of work"22. In August 1953 Schaeffer received his own electrotype, "a marvellously fine reproduction"23. In 1954 Plenderleith wrote that he had had "the greatest difficulty in getting the Enkomi Cup returned to Cyprus by diplomatic bag"24.

Further Enkomi finds followed: Schaeffer sent him finds that included two copper votive ingots and a tablet with Minoan script, and in 1954 pieces from the 1953 excavations were in his hands at the laboratory, to return to Cyprus by diplomatic bag25,26,27. The Sotira Kaminoudhia report cites his analysis of a gold sheet from Tomb 164B at Bellapais-Vounous as gold alloyed with silver, copper and some lead28. With Herbert Maryon he wrote the chapter "Fine Metal-work" in A History of Technology (1954), which shows the cup as a silver bowl "with inlays of gold and niello"29.

A 1953 review in Antiquity said he had "restored it most skilfully"30. The Antiquaries Journal reviewer called it "the magnificent cup of silver decorated with gold and niello"31.

The niello dispute

The sources disagree on what the black inlay is: an article in Nature of 28 May 1960 called it probably niello, citing his report32. G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss replied that there was no evidence of niello and that the cup was inlaid with copper33. In his answer Plenderleith conceded that no sulphides had been detected and agreed the case was "not proven", asking for a re-examination7. Alessandra Giumlia-Mair later concluded that the black is an artificially patinated alloy similar to shakudo, not niello, and that a small black fragment among his conservation remains came from his own experimental niello34. "He must have been a lucky man," she wrote, since apparently nothing happened to the black patina under his formic acid34.

He married Elizabeth K. S. Smyth in 1926, who died in 1982, and Margaret MacLennan in 198812. He died on 2 November 1997; the sources disagree on the place, Inverness according to Oddy and Dundee according to the Royal Society of Edinburgh11,12.

Life and work

  1. 1959

    1. Retired from the British Museum to become first director of ICCROM, Rome

      RomeHarold Plenderleith. Wikipedia

  2. 1960

    1. Co-signed the note 'The Enkomi Silver Cup' in Nature with G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss (the former two from the British Museum (Natural History)), on the inlay of the cup

      London(1960). Nature, vol. 187, supplement (contents list): 'The Enkomi Silver Cup'. Dr. G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss; Dr. Harold J. Plenderleith. Nature

  3. Undated

Connections

4 people

Mentioned in

6 mentions

Institutions · 1

  • British Museum

    Head of the research laboratory (conservation chemist) · 1924

    Karageorghis 1969, p. 95

Sources

  1. 1. (1960). “Nature, vol. 187, supplement (contents list): 'The Enkomi Silver Cup'. Dr. G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss; Dr. Harold J. Plenderleith”. Nature.
  2. 2.Eastern Mediterranean Metallurgy in the Second Millennium BC: a conference in honour of James D. Muhly, Nicosia, 10th-11th October 2009. pp. 124-129.
  3. 3.Vassos Karageorghis (1969). Ancient Civilizations: Cyprus. p. 95.
  4. 4.Ellen N. Davis (1977). The Vapheio Cups and Aegean Gold and Silver Ware. p. 213.
  5. 5. (1953). “The Antiquaries Journal, vol. 33, nos 1-2 (review of Enkomi-Alasia)”. The Antiquaries Journal.
  6. 6.H. J. Plenderleith (1952). “Technical report on the metal objects (including the niello inlay of the silver cup), in C. F. A. Schaeffer, Enkomi-Alasia I”.
  7. 7.H. J. Plenderleith (1960). “[Reply to Claringbull and Moss on] The Enkomi Silver Cup”. Nature 187, 1052.
  8. 8.Harold Plenderleith (Wikidata/GND record). Online
  9. 9.“Harold Plenderleith”. Wikipedia. Online
  10. 10.H. J. Plenderleith (1952). “Technical report [on the treatment of the bull cup]”. C. F. A. Schaeffer, Enkomi-Alasia I, 381-389.
  11. 11.Andrew Oddy (1997). “Obituary: Harold Plenderleith”. The Independent. Online
  12. 12.Royal Society of Edinburgh (2006). Biographical Index of Former Fellows of the Royal Society of Edinburgh 1783-2002.
  13. 13.A. H. S. Megaw (1951). “[Letter to Sir Thomas Kendrick on lending the Enkomi cup for exhibition, 20 September 1951]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179.
  14. 14. (1952). “Discovery at Enkomi”. The Cyprus Review (cutting in the Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179), 17.
  15. 15. (1951). “[Letter from the British Embassy, Paris, on the transport of a bronze bowl for Dr Plenderleith, 8 February 1951]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179.
  16. 16.H. J. Plenderleith (1951). “[Letter to C. F. A. Schaeffer, 1 August 1951, on the arrival of the bowl]”. Fonds Schaeffer, Collège de France (34 CDF art. 179).
  17. 17.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1951). “[Letter to T. D. Kendrick, 9 September 1951, on the loan of the bowl]”. Fonds Schaeffer, Collège de France (34 CDF art. 179).
  18. 18.A. H. S. Megaw (1951). “[Letter to C. F. A. Schaeffer, 20 September 1951]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France.
  19. 19.[Illustrated London News] (1952). “The Superb Enkomi Cup: A 3300-Year-Old Masterpiece”. The Illustrated London News 220.
  20. 20.A. H. S. Megaw (1952). “[Letter to C. F. A. Schaeffer on the replica of the bowl, 19 May 1952]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France.
  21. 21.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1952). “[Letter to Bernard Ashmole about the replica, 23 May 1952]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179.
  22. 22.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1953). “[Letter to Bernard Ashmole, 30 March 1953]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179.
  23. 23.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1953). “[Letter to H. J. Plenderleith acknowledging the electrotype, 15 August 1953]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 179.
  24. 24.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1954). “[Letter to A. H. S. Megaw, 1954, on men for the mission and the Enkomi bronzes]”. Fonds Schaeffer, Collège de France (34 CDF art. 169).
  25. 25.C. F. A. Schaeffer. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 124 (5th and 6th seasons at Enkomi, excavation notebook).
  26. 26.C. F. A. Schaeffer (1953). “[Letter returning Enkomi finds exported under licence 2683]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France, 34 CDF art. 142-2 (Enkomi-Alasia, 7th season, 1953).
  27. 27.A. H. S. Megaw (1954). “[Letter to C. F. A. Schaeffer, 17 August 1954]”. Fonds Claude Schaeffer, Collège de France.
  28. 28.Stuart Swiny (ed.), George Rapp (ed.), Ellen Herscher (ed.) (2003). Sotira Kaminoudhia: An Early Bronze Age Site in Cyprus. Boston, American Schools of Oriental Research.
  29. 29.Herbert Maryon and H. J. Plenderleith (1954). “Fine Metal-work”. A History of Technology, vol. 1, ed. C. Singer, E. J. Holmyard and A. R. Hall (Oxford).
  30. 30. (1953). “[Review of C. F. A. Schaeffer, Enkomi-Alasia]”. Antiquity 27 (no. 105).
  31. 31.[reviewer, Antiquaries Journal] (1953). “[Review of Schaeffer, Enkomi-Alasia I]”. The Antiquaries Journal 33.
  32. 32.[unsigned, Nature] (1960). “[Article on the scientific examination and conservation of museum objects]”. Nature 186, 676.
  33. 33.G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss (1960). “The Enkomi Silver Cup”. Nature 187, 1051-1052.
  34. 34.A. Giumlia-Mair. “The Enkomi cup: niello versus kuwano”. V. Kassianidou and G. Papasavvas (eds), Eastern Mediterranean Metallurgy in the Second Millennium BC: a conference in honour of James D. Muhly, Nicosia, 10th-11th October 2009, 107-116.
  35. 35.Collège de France, Paris, archives, Fonds Claude Schaeffer: Correspondence, 1950–1959: 34 CDF art. 179 (1 August 1951); 34 CDF art. 179 (23 August 1951); 34 CDF art. 179 (28 September 1951); 34 CDF art. 179 (9 November 1951); 34 CDF art. 179 (18 January 1952) and 10 more.
  36. 36.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 168-3, «["Achéens et peuples de la mer, les fouilles franco-britanniques de Chypre"]», 8 August 1952of 2, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 179, «[Tiré à part "De Midea à Salamis de Chypre à propos de deux coupes d'or et d'argent"]», 1953of 28, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 179, «[Tiré à part "The Bull Cup from Enkomi-Alasia, technical report", extract from C.F.A. Schaeffer, Nouvelles missions en Chypre 1946-1950, p.381 à 389]», 1952of 20, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 179, «["Discovery at Enkomi" in the Cyprus Review, p. 17]», 1 November 1952of 2. Online
  37. 37.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 142-2, «[Enkomi-Alasia, 7e campagne de fouilles, 1953]», 1953of 71, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 168-1, «[Correspondance entre Megaw et Schaeffer à propos de la rupture de collaboration entre les missions françaises et chypriotes]», 16 August 1951of 6, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 168-1, «[Lettre de Megaw à Schaeffer à propos des dispositions à prendre pour rompre la collaboration entre la mission française et la mission chypriote]», 20 September 1951of 2, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 168-1, «[Correspondance entre Megaw et Schaeffer à propos de l'exposition d'un bol en argent au British Musuem et de la fin de la collaboration, jointe, une copie d'une lettre de Megaw à Haynes]», 1951of 12, Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 168-1, «[Lettre de Schaeffer à Megaw à propos de l'exposition au British Museum et de la fin de leur collaboration]», 12 February 1952of 4, and 43 more. Online
  38. 38.Nature 1960-09-17: Vol 187 Supplement (1960).
  39. 39.Vassos Karageorghis, 1969, Ancient Civilizations: Cyprus.
  40. 40.1960, Nature, vol. 187, supplement (contents list): 'The Enkomi Silver Cup'. Dr. G. F. Claringbull and A. A. Moss; Dr. Harold J. Plenderleith, leaf 10.
  41. 41.Harold Plenderleith.
  42. 42.Nature, Vol-186, Issue no.-April-June.
  43. 43.Nature 1960: Vol 187 Index (1960).
  44. 44.Phyllis Williams Lehmann; J. Walter Graham; T. Leslie Shear, Jr.; Emily Townsend Vermeule; Sterling Dow, A Land Called Crete: A Symposium in Memory of Harriet Boyd Hawes 1871-1945 (1968).
  45. 45.Collège de France, Paris, Fonds Claude Schaeffer (34 CDF), 34 CDF art. 179, «[Lettre de Plenderleith à Schaeffer accusant réception de la coupe]», 1 August 1951. Online

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.