Scholar

H. G. G. Payne

fl. 1927–1937

Humfry Payne, Director of the British School at Athens from 1929, who argued in 1928 that Cretan potters of the Iron Age borrowed forms and motives from Cyprus.

Biography

Humfry Gilbert Garth Payne was a British archaeologist, born at Wendover on 19 February 1902, whose study of early Greek vases from Knossos traced forms and motives in Cretan pottery to Cyprus3,4.

Oxford and Athens

Payne was the only son of the historian Edward John Payne and of Emma Leonora Helena Pertz, a granddaughter of Georg Heinrich Pertz3. He was educated at Westminster and at Christ Church, Oxford, where he was an open classical scholar, and took a first in classical moderations in 1922 and in literae humaniores in 19243. In his last year he turned to Greek art, partly under the influence of J. D. Beazley and Alan Blakeway, and resolved to make himself an archaeologist3. He was university research scholar in Mediterranean archaeology from 1924 to 1926, assistant at the Ashmolean Museum from 1926 to 1928 and senior scholar of Christ Church from 1926 to 1931, and he won the Conington prize in 19273. In 1926 he married Elizabeth Dilys Powell, daughter of Thomas Powell, a bank manager; they had no children3.

In 1929 Payne was appointed director of the British School at Athens, and the School printed him as Director for 1930-31 and 1931-323,5. Beazley wrote that Necrocorinthia (1931), a study of vase-painting and the other arts at Corinth, placed him at once, "as all admitted, in the front rank of classical archaeologists"3. Protokorinthische Vasenmalerei followed in 19333. He excavated Perachora, an archaic site opposite Corinth; the first Perachora volume, edited by T. J. Dunbabin, appeared in 1940 and is mostly Payne's3.

Cyprus and Crete

Payne's Knossos vases came from two tombs dug by Arthur Evans in 1907 and from one of several tombs Payne had excavated himself4. He held that the tripod foot of Cretan pithoi came to Crete from Cyprus, where it is common in styles matching Cretan geometric and early orientalising pottery4. His general rule was that forms un-Hellenic in Crete but well established in Cyprus showed "that the Cretans borrowed from Cyprus, not that the Cypriotes borrowed from Crete"4. Following Johansen, he traced the Knossian red-and-black polychrome style to Cyprus and concluded that "Cyprus gave this Asiatic technique to Knossos, not Knossos to Cyprus"4. Payne still judged those Knossian vases essentially Greek and, he thought, far superior to any painted pottery Cyprus was known to have produced4. He called Cyprus the source of many Cretan motives and noted that trees, unusual in Greek geometric, are exceedingly common there4.

The sources differ on how Payne read the Black-on-Red vessels nos 119-22. Payne wrote of no. 120 that it was "apparently a copy of a Cypriot model, if not actually imported"4. Antonis Kotsonas says Payne was the first to publish Cretan copies of Cypriot Black-on-Red but took them for Cypriot originals and was "confused over their provenance"6. Kotsonas adds that "a scholar of the status of Humfry Payne" apparently could not tell import from imitation in the late 1920s6.

Later readers

John Franklin Daniel thanked "the late Mr. H. G. G. Payne" for many suggestions and constant encouragement in his 1937 report on two Kourion tombs1. Payne had suggested that foreign matter in one pot's fabric was a temper of ground-up pottery, and Daniel wrote that his tripod-footed pot confirmed Payne's view that the type came to Greece from Cyprus1. Daniel also counted Payne among those who had recognised the Cypriot origin of duck vases found in Crete1. Sidney Smith wrote in 1942 that Payne showed the Phoenician strand in early Greek art "came through Cyprus to Crete, and reached the mainland later"7. A reviewer of George Hill's History of Cyprus in The Antiquaries Journal in 1940 objected that there is no such geographical entity as the "Creto-Cypriot region" Payne had written of in Necrocorinthia, and judged that Payne "stated the case much better" in his Knossos article8.

In 1936 a staphylococcic infection, present in a minor form for some years, suddenly became acute; he was taken to hospital too late and died in Athens on 9 May 19363. He was buried at Mycenae3.

Life and work

  1. 1937

    1. Named by J. F. Daniel as advising on pottery and types for the Kourion Late Cypriote III tombs

      KourionJ. F. Daniel (1937). Two Late Cypriote III Tombs from Kourion. American Journal of Archaeology 41, 56-85, pp. 57

Connections

1 person

Recording and study

1 record
Published1
  • Payne was the first to publish Cretan copies of Cypriot Black-on-Red but was confused over their provenance.

    No. nos 119–22Kotsonas 2012, p. 159

Mentioned in

6 mentions

Documents · 5

Sources

  1. 1.J. F. Daniel (1937). “Two Late Cypriote III Tombs from Kourion”. American Journal of Archaeology 41, 56-85.
  2. 2.Wikidata (2026). Humfry Payne (Q872366).
  3. 3.J. D. Beazley (1949). “Payne, Humfry Gilbert Garth (1902-1936)”. The Dictionary of National Biography 1931-1940, ed. L. G. Wickham Legg, 680-681.
  4. 4.H. G. G. Payne (1928). “Early Greek Vases from Knossos”. The Annual of the British School at Athens 29, 224-297.
  5. 5.British School at Athens. “[Managing Committee and officers, 1930-31]”. The Annual of the British School at Athens 31, 230.
  6. 6.Antonis Kotsonas (2012). “'Creto-Cypriot' and 'Cypro-Phoenician' Complexities in the Archaeology of Interaction between Crete and Cyprus”. Maria Iacovou (ed.), Cyprus and the Aegean in the Early Iron Age: The Legacy of Nicolas Coldstream, 155-182.
  7. 7.Sidney Smith (1942). “The Greek Trade at Al Mina: A Footnote to Oriental History”. The Antiquaries Journal 22.
  8. 8.[unsigned in the index text] (1940). “[Review of George Hill, A History of Cyprus, vol. I]”. The Antiquaries Journal 20.
  9. 9.A. Kotsonas (2012). “'Creto-Cypriot' and 'Cypro-Phoenician' complexities in the archaeology of interaction between Crete and Cyprus”. Cyprus and the Aegean in the Early Iron Age: The Legacy of Nicolas Coldstream, 155-181.
  10. 10.John Franklin Daniel, 1937, Two Late Cypriote III Tombs from Kourion.

Corrections and additions

Did you know this person?

We would like to hear from relatives, colleagues and anyone who knows more about this person's life and work.

Missing from this record

  • Dates of birth and death unknown
  • No photograph

We would like to hear about

  • Dates and places of birth and death
  • Other spellings or names they used
  • Photographs, letters or papers
  • Their work, collections or excavations
  • A mistake in what we say

If this page is about you, write to us and we will correct it or take it down. Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.