Article · 2017
A tale of two Yusifs: recovering Arab agency in Palestine Exploration Fund excavations 1890-1924
Palestine Exploration Quarterly 149(3) 223-236
An article on Yusif Khazin and Yusif Khattar Kanaan, Arab foremen on Palestine Exploration Fund excavations between 1890 and 1924, and on the knowledge they brought to the work.
Irving reconstructs the careers of Yusif ‘abu Selim’ Khazin and Yusif Khattar Kanaan from Palestine Exploration Fund reports and related writings. She follows their work on excavations and expeditions from 1890 to the First World War, and the knowledge and responsibilities they brought to it, in a section on each man followed by a conclusion.
For Khazin, Irving draws on Frederick Jones Bliss's reports of his management of labour and land negotiations at Tel el-Hesi, his supervision at Silwan and his observations of walls and passages. Bliss also records Khazin suggesting interpretations of features at the excavations (pp. 226–228).
For Kanaan the sources are reports by Bliss, R. A. S. Macalister and Duncan Mackenzie, which describe his work as cook and foreman, his help with measurements and inscriptions, his observations of finds, and his collection of folklore and ethnographic material. Irving also traces his part in the Wilderness of Zin Survey (pp. 228–233).
Irving argues that archaeological histories centred on Western directors obscure the agency of Arab workers and foremen. Khazin and Kanaan acted as managers and intermediaries, and their observations could inform excavation practice and interpretation. Using relational history, she describes these exchanges while keeping in view the colonial and economic constraints on their choices, and concludes that the two brought archaeological experience, local relationships and interpretive knowledge to PEF projects, providing continuity between excavations (pp. 232–234).
What it records
- At the 1892 Tel el-Hesi excavations, Yusif Khazin brought Bliss a cuneiform tablet that he had taken from the excavator Suleiman.p. 228
- Bliss reported that Yusif Khazin died of pneumonia on 29 March 1896 after a week's illness.p. 229
- Macalister cited Kanaan's part in bringing him the Gezer tablet as evidence for its provenance.p. 230
- In 1907, Yusif Kanaan travelled through Palestine collecting folklore for a project associated with the PEF excavators.p. 231
- Macalister used Kanaan's findings, recorded in four handwritten notebooks, as the basis for several articles in the PEF Quarterly.p. 231
- At ‘Ain Shems, Mackenzie reports that Kanaan's knowledge of finds at other sites helped distinguish the tomb pottery from material he knew at Gezer.p. 232
Where to read
- Yusif Khazin's excavation work and observationspp. 226–228
- Yusif Kanaan's archaeological, folklore and ethnographic workpp. 229–232
- Conclusions on Arab agency and continuity in PEF excavationspp. 233–234
Contents
- Yusif ‘abu Selim’ Khazin226
- Yusif Khattar Kanaan228
- Conclusion233
- Acknowledgements234
Objects published here
1- Cuneiform tablet from Gezer, Gezer (p. 230)
People, places and institutions
People
- Yusif KhazinPEF foreman at Tel el-Hesi and Silwan
- Yusif Khattar KanaanPEF cook, foreman and researcher
- Frederick Jones BlissPEF excavation director
- R.A.S. MacalisterPEF excavator and researcher
- Duncan MackenziePEF excavator at ‘Ain Shems
- Nadia Abu el-Hajcited on archaeology and colonialism
- Ussama Makdisicited in the discussion of relational history
- Zachary Lockmancited in the discussion of relational history
Institutions
- Palestine Exploration Fundemployer and sponsor of the excavations
Places
- Tel el-HesiPEF excavation site
- Silwanexcavation overseen by Khazin
- Gezerexcavation where Kanaan worked
- JerusalemPEF excavation location
- ‘Ain ShemsPEF excavation site
- Wilderness of Zinsurvey accompanied by Kanaan
Also named: T.E. Lawrence, Leonard Woolley, Archibald Dickie, Ernest Masterman, Suleiman.
Extent pp. 223–236; bibliography pp. 235–236
Defines agency
Corrections and additions
Know this document?
Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.
We would like to hear about
- The full citation, or a correction to ours
- Where a copy can be read or downloaded
- Missing parts, volumes or plates
- Related documents
Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.