Article · 2007

Constans II and the Byzantine navy

S. Cosentino

Byzantinische Zeitschrift 100 577-603

An article on late antique naval organisation and the reign of Constans II, taking in the battle of Phoenix and the Italian expedition, and arguing that the reign changed the Byzantine navy's strategic role.

Cosentino follows the Roman and Byzantine navy from Late Antiquity through the reign of Constans II in sections on fleet organisation, Muslim naval expansion, the battle of Phoenix, the emperor's expedition to Italy and the development of naval commands. For the small late antique warships, their crews and their cooperation with land forces he draws on chronicles, military treatises, inscriptions, a seal and ship imagery, with modern estimates of vessel dimensions and crew sizes.

A military navy with its own personnel and institutions existed before Constans II, he argues, against the view that attributes the navy's creation to the emperor. The reign instead changed the navy's strategic role, from logistical, patrol and army-support duties towards offensive operations. Cosentino reads the battle of Phoenix as one part of a Muslim land-and-sea campaign against Constantinople in 653–654, reconstructed from Byzantine, Syriac, Armenian, Arabic and Latin accounts whose dates and details are uncertain. Cosentino favours summer 654, reconciling the chronology of the Christian accounts with Muslim dating (pp. 586–593).

For the Italian expedition and its fiscal measures he relies chiefly on the Liber Pontificalis, read together with the Chronicon Paschale and other evidence. He disputes the interpretation that Constans introduced compulsory recruitment of oarsmen on a Muslim model. He proposes that the Karabésianoi were instituted between 654 and 663 and that Constans established at least two high naval commands, developments he ties to the fleet's growing offensive role and to the larger, more heavily equipped ships of later Byzantine practice (pp. 593–603).

What it records

  • Late antique dromon crews from the fourth to the sixth centuries averaged 20–30 men in written sources and 30–35 in pictorial sources, by Cosentino's estimate.p. 581
  • The first naval raid of some importance against Cyprus came in 649, from a joint Syrian-Egyptian force.p. 585
  • The Muslim squadron sent against Cyprus in 649 was destroyed by the Byzantines near the Lycian coast, and a new fleet attacked Cyprus again in 650.p. 585
  • Cosentino concludes that the battle of Phoenix was fought off the town of Phoenix in Lycia, that Constans led the Byzantine fleet and that the Muslims won despite heavy losses.p. 587
  • Summer 654 is the most probable date for the battle of Phoenix, in Cosentino's view.p. 587
  • The Karabésianoi were most probably instituted between 654 and 663, Cosentino proposes.p. 602
  • Constans II first gave the rank of stratégos (magister militum) to an official permanently responsible for a squadron of warships, Cosentino argues.p. 602

Where to read

  • Late antique fleet organisation, crews and vessel sizepp. 578–583
  • Sources and reconstruction of the battle of Phoenixpp. 586–593
  • Italian fiscal measures and the development of naval commandspp. 595–603

Contents

  • The Navy in Late Antiquity577
  • Byzantine and Muslim naval armament in the second third of the seventh century583
  • The battle of the Masts (summer 654)586
  • Constans II's expedition to Italy593
  • Constans II and the Byzantine navy601

People, places and institutions

People

  • Constans IIemperor who led the fleet at Phoenix
  • Mu'āwiyaMuslim governor and campaign leader
  • Sebeossource for the campaign against Constantinople
  • Theophanessource for the battle and its date
  • John B. Buryattributed the navy's creation to Constans II
  • Hélène Ahrweilerchallenged Bury's interpretation
  • Dieter Kienastargued against a decline of the late Roman fleet
  • M. Reddédiscussed regional naval responsibilities

Places

  • Phoenixsite of the battle, in Lycia
  • Lyciaregion where the battle was fought
  • Constantinopletarget of the proposed 654 campaign
  • Sicilybase of Constans II's Italian operations
  • Syracuseresidence of Constans II in Sicily
  • Alexandrianaval arsenal and campaign base
  • Tripoli of Syrianaval preparation and dockyard site
  • Rhodesisland attacked during the campaign

Extent pp. 577–603

Defines dromonarii

Late AntiqueMedievalSeafaringWarfareKingship and PoliticsTrade

Corrections and additions

Know this document?

Help us cite it fully and point readers to a copy.

We would like to hear about

  • The full citation, or a correction to ours
  • Where a copy can be read or downloaded
  • Missing parts, volumes or plates
  • Related documents

Tell us if you would like to be thanked by name on the page.